3 ms·
This came up a few years ago. It resulted in an interesting debate about whether NYC water was kosher to drink. When I heard about it, the question was still
by btilly 16y ago
This came up a few years ago.
It resulted in an interesting debate about whether NYC water was kosher to drink. When I heard about it, the question was still being debated, and I don't know how it turned out. (Not being Jewish or religious, it wasn't particularly material to my life.)
Oddly enough it turns out that the water was unquestionably kosher to drink before the local Jews were told about the arthropods. But once they had been told, there was a real question about whether they could continue to drink it. The reason for this is that there is a dispensation for breaking the dietary rules out of sheer ignorance. But once you know the rules, you are responsible for following them. The classic example being, if I recall correctly, the case of a blind man who didn't know that he had been eating pork.