2 ms·

In that case I'd suggest that perhaps they just aren't understanding exactly what's being announced here. Eliminating the top banner was something AMP announce

In that case I'd suggest that perhaps they just aren't understanding exactly what's being announced here. Eliminating the top banner was something AMP announced they were going to do _months_ ago, just as soon as they could do so without negatively impacting performance: https://amphtml.wordpress.com/2018/01/09/improving-urls-for-amp-pages/ https://amphtml.wordpress.com/2018/01/09/improving-urls-for-... And AMP having "the right to run their own arbitrary JS on YOUR site" is not something that can happen when you're not even being required to use AMP in the first place: > we now feel ready to take the next step and work to support more instant-loading content not based on AMP technology [emphasis mine]

tyingq 9y ago
Can you quote something specific that says either the top banner or carousel takeover UI goes away? To me, it seems very high level and opaque. They could have been very specific, but haven’t been. Web packaging does still require including a named google js url, right? With little restrictions on what it’s able to do with the DOM. Why, for example, is there no Google source saying that the AMP page header is going away? They have not yet specified if they will only allow a very specific implementation of web packaging that allows your site into the carousel and other top of page search result URLs.