7 ms·
I'm torn on this. Yes, having a shift of a full hour in a week is obnoxious. However, the natural sun up and sun down time changes so dramatically in its own,
by taeric 9y ago
I'm torn on this. Yes, having a shift of a full hour in a week is obnoxious. However, the natural sun up and sun down time changes so dramatically in its own, that it is hard to really complain about it. If anything, I could see society moving to a time more based on when the sun comes up. Yes, there are difficulties scheduling something with someone across distance on the earth. But... I don't see a practical solution to that.
- RhodesianHunter 9y agoWhy not just have the hour shift slowly a few seconds per day over the course of the year?
- cvaidya1986 9y agoKeep the time the same. Just change company work hours.
- Sargos 9y agoYou just gave systems programmers panic attack with those words.
- hypervis0r 9y agoCan confirm, just got a slight arrhythmia just by reading that
- chillingeffect 9y agothe interesting thing is daylight savings' shifts do cause heart attacks! https://duckduckgo.com/?q=heart+attacks+daylight+savings&t=ffsb&ia=news https://duckduckgo.com/?q=heart+attacks+daylight+savings&t=f...
- shaki-dora 9y agoYou're in luck! Variable-time seconds are among the best cures for heart arrhythmias.
- waqf 9y agoNot as big a problem as it sounds. "System time" used for scientific and engineering purposes should continue to use UTC and should ignore changes to civil time statutes. It becomes more complicated to translate between system time and civil time, but there are relatively few applications for which you really need to be able to do that conversion — and libraries that handle those cases are complicated already.
- bena 9y agoIt's a huge problem. Your "system time" proposal is already the way things are done. But people like to know when they did something based on their own clock. Already that one hour shift causes goddamn headaches in showing the proper time to the user for past events. Now instead of just figuring out if we're across one threshold or another and adjusting another hour, we have to figure out what time of what day it was and figure out what the offset was at that time? No. Just get rid of DST.
- squiggleblaz 9y agoNonsense. The headaches aren't caused by daylight savings. They're caused by incompetently programmed libraries and systems. If I travel to Indonesia for a week, I want my reminders that are set to occur at 4pm to occur at 4pm. But Google decides that they should happen at 4pm - time zone offset in my home location + time zone offset in my current location. It's insanity. Also, it's insanity that there aren't standard libraries to let me say "4pm". And that programmers think timestamps solve all problems. And that you can use a timestamp to represent a day. But these are all issues that need to be fixed even if we get rid of daylight savings. Deciding there are gradual drifts to standard time on a daily or weekly basis will cause some hassle. But it will not create a new class of problem that doesn't already exist and which doesn't already need to be fixed. And time is absolutely the kind of problem that needs to be solved with a few standard libraries, rather than every two bit programmer thinking "i can add two hours to this number, it's a piece of cake".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mkempe 9y agoWe now have the technology to accurately, and simply, keep solar time wherever we are, instead of using and manipulating archaic time zones. Edit: The original, 19th-century impetus for time zones (vs solar time) was to reliably print and manage train schedules across longer East-West railroads. With powerful computers and satellite positioning cheaply available to everybody, we could overcome this now-obsolete hack.
- gpvos 9y agoYes, let's just go back to solar time per city.
- matte_black 9y agoUTC everywhere, done.
- birdmanjeremy 9y agoThis is such a terrible idea.
- space_fountain 9y agoWhy? Vary opening hours now the time. Makes sense to me.
- bunderbunder 9y agoYou'd end up with the official calendar day either flipping in the middle of the day, or at a different time in every locale.
- birdmanjeremy 9y agoThis is a really good, simple, reason I had not even thought of. Thanks!
- squiggleblaz 9y agoAn alternative is just to count seconds. Be as precise as you need (m? k? M?). A little like unix timestamps, except without the rule that says "there's 86400 of them in a day no matter how many seconds there were in that day". And then let "Sunday", "Monday" etc become simply approximate terms. And I never have any idea what day of the month it is so I don't care. (Birthdays and public holidays are set based some recurring feature of the count.) A refinement of this uses a time period that is approximately 100,000th of a day so then people can easily notice the day. In practice we might use hectokiloperiods instead of periods. Someone will invite a less woeful name. Nothing about telling time will be particular familiar. Doesn't mean it won't work. But I suspect it'll be awful. I'm fine with daylight savings and all the rest of it. Except days of months. Can't we just say "Monday, third week of June"? or "Wednesday, 39th week"?
- bahmboo 9y agoThe dramatic shift is in northern locales but not so much in southern ones
- cheald 9y agoArizona doesn't observe DST and hasn't since 1968. It works great, and the rest of the country should follow suit, IMO. We're no longer a nation of farmers whose work depends on daylight.
- bena 9y agoIt was never about the farmers. It was always about saving fuel during wartime. Farmers dislike DST.
- dvtv75 9y agoIf I ever get a time machine and meet George Hudson, I will punch him squarely in the face. He wanted some time after work to look at insects, and because of that we have DST. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Hudson_(entomologist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Hudson_(entomologist)
- squiggleblaz 9y agoThat's unreasonable. Lots of people advocate for bad ideas. But George Hudson was never in any politically powerful position. It took others to introduce daylight savings. Notwithstanding, I am pleased we have daylight savings. It makes me happy and seems like an appropriate and proportionate response to the variation in length of the day.
- blang 9y agoFrom what I understand farmers hate DST more than anyone. They tend to wake up at dawn and shifting the time an hour gives them an hour less time until the rest of the area wakes.
- gowld 9y agoWhy do farmers care when other people wake up?
- deleted 9y ago
- peteey 9y agoFlorida is trying to act early. Ending daylight saving time is becoming popular throughout the US. Florida's tourism market would reap more gains if we fixed the clocks with an extra hour of sunlight in the evenings.