4 ms·
The essential Agatha (IMHO): The Murder of Roger Ackroyd Murder on the Orient Express Curtain Can't tell you why without spoiling it though. You have to re
by lisper 9y ago
The essential Agatha (IMHO):
The Murder of Roger Ackroyd
Murder on the Orient Express
Curtain
Can't tell you why without spoiling it though. You have to read them.
- jacobkg 9y agoI would add "And Then There Were None" Haven't actually read Curtain, I will now immediately go buy it!
- lisper 9y agoOh yeah, that one too. I didn't put it on my list because, ironically, I never read it. I saw the play when I was a kid so I never bothered to read the book.
- jjess 9y agoActually, original title by Agatha Christie was "Ten Little Niggers" [1]. I didn't read the book, but I really liked the movie [2] (there is eng subs). People in reviews say it's closest and probably best adaptation. IMO, it's excellent. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_Then_There_Were_None https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_Then_There_Were_None [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uoTDsuSgPBw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uoTDsuSgPBw
- armandososa 9y agoWhy the downvotes? Is this an automated flagging system for the n-word?
- dang 9y agoNo. Please don't break the site guidelines by commenting about downvotes. If you feel like a comment has been unfairly downvoted, give it a corrective upvote and move on. That's what others did in this case, and the comment now has a positive score. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- emodendroket 9y agoWhile that is true I can't see why it's relevant. You're not going to find it under that title except maybe at an antique book seller.
- baud147258 9y agoIn France, the original title is still used ("10 petits nègres"). I read the book, but I did not really enjoyed it. But it was a long time ago, I might have been to Young. Or maybe it was the style, which was very different from what I was used to at the time (mostly Ellis Peters)
- thewhitetulip 9y ago> "And Then There Were None" This is a fascinating book indeed.
- dannylandau 9y agoWhat happened to 10 little Indians (or then there were none). I guess they changed the title for political correctness, unless I'm missing something? In any case, greatest mystery novel of all time.
- lisper 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16547452 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16547452
- dang 9y agoAlso the best selling, proving that the mass market sometimes gets art right. It's Agatha at her most brilliant, ruthless not only in story but in style. The English is as hard and bare as possible. IIRC it's almost all dialog and minimal dialog at that. But you don't notice because the story is such a drug. It stands apart from her other books by having no familiar characters and being completely sealed. A perfect idea, perfectly executed. I wonder if Nabokov ever read it.
- ghaff 9y agoIt was released in the US as And Then There Were None because the original UK title was, shall we say, significantly more offensive to a US audience than Ten Little Indians would have been. It's not exactly a case of "political correctness." Later, it went through various renaming iterations in the UK. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_Then_There_Were_None https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_Then_There_Were_None
- taeric 9y agoI'll have to see curtain to my list, then. I'll second the first two. Very fun novels. Haven't seen the new movie. Guessing it is ok, but different. At best.
- ghaff 9y ago>Haven't seen the new movie. Guessing it is ok, but different. At best. I assume you mean Murder on the Orient Express? IMO, it was "OK." Perfectly serviceable and, had there not been an earlier film version, I'd have said it was perfectly fine if nothing outstanding. But I found basically nothing that I thought was better than the 70s version and a number of things that weren't as good. If I were to watch one, I'd watch the older version even today.
- ubernostrum 9y agoI watched the Branagh film on a recent flight. It's... OK, I guess. I'd recommend anyone who wants to see it read the book first. The twist is preserved, but in the film doesn't work quite as well. The basic problem (for those who are curious) is that the book takes you there through a couple iterations of Poirot interviewing the passengers, and showing exactly how he teases out each little piece of information that finally causes the truth to pop out at the end. The film, constrained by running-time concerns, can't do that, so several things that are separate and gradual revelations in the book are part of one big reveal. A lot of the fun of the book (for me, at least) is the series of small shocks as he goes through the initial set of interviews and comes away with nothing, then figures out the pieces of the puzzle, confronts other people with them in later interviews, and explains how he worked them out from previous clues. That gives the eventual solution of the murder an entirely different feel. There's also the usual amount of gratuitous deviation from the source in adding a bit of action and fiddling with characters, which also detracts a bit. The worst of it is that the moment when Poirot's solution is finally confirmed -- which is done in the book with a wonderful single sentence uttered by one passenger -- was changed entirely and became much more cruel than the book, in a way that deviates from how Christie usually presents Poirot's character.
- ghaff 9y ago
- CocaKoala 9y agoWhile I vastly prefer hardboiled fiction from Chandler and Hammett to the classic Detective Stories, "The Murder of Roger Akroyd" is a brilliant work that I highly recommend to anybody who likes mysteries or detective fiction.
- dang 9y agoOne obscure one that I remember enjoying and thinking was underrated was "Dumb Witness".
- diiaann 9y agoI think I've read every single Poirot, my favorites are: Murder on the Orient Express Death on the Nile Appointment with Death Cat Among Pigeons
- KC8ZKF 9y agoAfter you read "The Murder of Roger Ackroyd", I recommend "Who Killed Roger Ackroyd?" by Pierre Bayard. (spoiler alert: Please don't Google this book until you have read the Christie.) Bayard writes "revisionist readings" of popular mysteries, in which he exonerates the killers. He mixes in a fair amount of literary criticism. I have a hard time deciding how serious he is.