4 ms·
man, i'm actually a huge fan of barbara ehrenreich (especially nickel-and-dimed), but i feel like i could write an article like this about any subject. for inst
by igor47 9y ago
man, i'm actually a huge fan of barbara ehrenreich (especially nickel-and-dimed), but i feel like i could write an article like this about any subject. for instance, here the subject is some people who are trying to be more healthy and take care of themselves. but it's made sinister through some sprinkling of conventional villains (humorless gym owners, corporations with fitness programs), a caricature (people tracking their workouts on clipboards) and some topical/social-justice tie-in (people who cannot afford gyms, headphones that remove you from normal interaction).
i can do this as easily for, say, education. you thought it was about people trying to learn stuff, but it's actually about drones doing rote memorization in ivory towers (which the urban poor can ill-afford), all for the benefit of soul-sucking corporations which will use that knowledge to destroy the world, even while the system oppresses those same students through massive loan debt.
or, how about programming? you thought it was about having fun creating stuff that people find useful, but it's actually about pencil-necked dweebs who got abused in high school and are now taking their revenge on the world through will-sapping social networks, even while the government lets them steal your private data consequence-free and lets them get so rich they all buy teslas (which the urban poor can ill-afford)
someone give me a topic, any topic! i can make it so sinister and hateful you'll soon be too afraid/cynical to do anything more than cower in your basement -- which, you thought it was just cowering in your basement, but it's actually about sociopathic loners hiding from the world, probably polishing assault weapons and stockpiling canned goods (which the urban poor can ill-afford) while forgoing their sacred duty to vote, thus allowing republicans and corporations to pillage the world
this really brings home for me why kim stanley robinson avoids writing dystopias.
- cal5k 9y agoMy thoughts exactly. And she probably knows perfectly well what she’s doing - she professes to take pride in her numbers - but has a journalistic imperative to write things that people will read. I often wonder how much controversy is directly the result of bored/hungry journalists duking it out in a highly competitive arena of ideas.
- mistersquid 9y agoYou offer your view/counterview narratives as skeptical trial balloons but I think you needn't be so skeptical. That is, interpretation of any phenomenon--fitness, education, programming, etc.--can be done enthusiastically or critically, as an encomium or a critique. (There are other modes, but I'm focusing on these two here.) Being able to do both is central to understanding that interpretation or judgement is not an objective act of reception but a guided act of perception. Without the skeptical mood, your narratives reveal that none of the acts of fitness, education, and programming are unalloyed goods or unmitigated problems. Rather, they are things that can be perceived differently depending on what one takes into account. Knowing this enables us to make decisions with greater information and, hopefully, deeper wisdom, even as it complicates what from a more limited perspective may seem straightforward. EDIT: add "more" in last sentence.