3 ms·
I just looked up the IoT button. $20, non-replaceable battery, not shipping to Canada. I don't have the skill or resources to assemble it in a nice form facto
by Waterluvian 9y ago
I just looked up the IoT button. $20, non-replaceable battery, not shipping to Canada.
I don't have the skill or resources to assemble it in a nice form factor, but how are there not dozens of cheap Chinese alternatives? An ESP8266 is like $5 and the rest of the parts are probably less than a dollar.
I guess it's just a bit surprising that I cannot find a cheap alternative to buy a dozen of.
- stevekemp 9y agoMy approach was to buy a bunch of 433Mhz radio-based "alarm buttons" from Aliexpress. Then I could wire up a simple radio-receiver to an ESP8266 device to handle the presses. Or of course you could use an SDR-receiver on a PC to do something more complex: https://blog.steve.fi/creating_an_iot_button__the_smart_way.html https://blog.steve.fi/creating_an_iot_button__the_smart_way.... https://blog.steve.fi/decoding_433mhz_transmissions_with_software_defined_radio.html https://blog.steve.fi/decoding_433mhz_transmissions_with_sof...
- murukesh_s 9y agoWondering the same, you probably don't even need a Chinese supplier given how cheap ESP8366 is, you can just assemble a device on a order basis..
- fludlight 9y agoThe Amazon button probably has higher build quality than anything you can replicate or buy for $5+1. That's probably overkill for most applications aimed at adult users, but it's worth it here. Is that cheap Chinese alternative toddler-survivable? Will the enclosure break and will delicious shiny metal sharps fall out? Is it reasonable water resistant? Is it coated in cheap lead paint that will come off when (not if) your toddler chews on it it?
- gregorymichael 9y agoAnd what's the developer experience?
- Waterluvian 9y agoHas the Amazon button been validated for any of those things? Ignoring for a moment that we're just assuming product quality of the Amazon product, that's not really my point. For prototyping and hacking, how am I not able to source $5 or $10 wifi buttons with a replaceable battery?
- rajacombinator 9y ago$6 products from China can be really good quality. I mean, after all, Amazon no doubt gets these buttons made for less than $1 in China themselves.
- Jaruzel 9y agoYou could probably also do this with a small form factor Arduino, a bluetooth module, and a push-to-make button. With the added bonus that the parts could be re-purposed once potty training is over.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoI was thinking a Raspberry Pi W is practically a similar enough form factor for this as well. Some HN'ers might even have one or two of these laying around doing nothing better, so it may work out for them :)
- dave84 9y agoI found this [0] on AliExpress, four buttons in one casing with a rechargeable battery. Haven't ordered it yet though. [0] https://www.aliexpress.com/item/RAK413AS-UART-serial-port-AT-commands-low-power-consumption-WiFi-module/32814812323.html https://www.aliexpress.com/item/RAK413AS-UART-serial-port-AT...