3 ms·
If we lived in a market economy, the market would find the most efficient use for each parcel. We don't. We live in a centrally planned economy with respect to
by closeparen 9y ago
If we lived in a market economy, the market would find the most efficient use for each parcel. We don't. We live in a centrally planned economy with respect to real estate, and the central planners have got their priorities backwards.
Your framing of the residents of high-density housing as not "stakeholders" or "the community" is a common NIMBY talking point, but the condo/apartment dwellers whose humanity you choose to deny are not less deserving of space than you. If the "well-capitalized developers" want to help people like me (who were born too late to own city land) fight for the right to occupy space, I'll take it.
- Spooky23 9y agoSure we do. It’s much more efficient to have some engineer pulling down crazy money to buy existing housing stock or move in with 6 roommates as compared to ripping down and replacing buildings. It just sucks for everyone when there are thousands of those engineers sucking the oxygen out of the city. You could say the same things about the $2000/mo trailer parks in South Dakota when gas booms. I live 4,000 miles away. My humanity doesn’t require that I have an apartment on 5th Avenue. Instead, I own a home where high quality housing runs around $100/ft. Fundamentally, the reason you don’t live in Cleveland or Buffalo is that aerospace and other industries left and moved to California 80 years ago, largely because it was cheap to buy an Orange grove. Capital and the investment culture of tech is why SFO is the way it is. Until that changes and Google Omaha starts impacting demand, you are stuck. Markets are about control. Not fairness, not what is right. If you don’t control the votes, and don’t control the land, you don’t have a stake.
- pcwalton 9y agoThe fact that only engineers and similarly well-off individuals can afford to buy property in the Bay Area is because of NIMBYs. More NIMBYism will only make the problem worse. If you prevent wealthy people from buying new homes, they'll just buy old ones instead. This isn't a theoretical concern. In fact, it's precisely what has been happening throughout the SF Bay Area.