5 ms·
This is just pathetic. You buy a piece of hardware that could trivially keep working for 5-8 years, and it becomes actively dangerous to use, not just for the o
by saurik 9y ago
This is just pathetic. You buy a piece of hardware that could trivially keep working for 5-8 years, and it becomes actively dangerous to use, not just for the owner but to everyone else (think botnets), after 3 years because the vendor stops giving security updates for its software? This should be illegal.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoI am annoyed that my Nexus 6P isn't getting support longer, sure, though there's always LineageOS[1]. I'd say the lack of an SD card slot and user-hostile, hard-to-replace batteries make the 5-8 year lifespan much harder to really imagine, though. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LineageOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LineageOS
- amyjess 9y agoOh, it's not the battery that'll shorten the lifespan of the 5X and the 6P. It's the CPU. I've already had to replace my 5X under warranty twice. The second time was because of the bootloop problem, which will happen to every single device equipped with the Snapdragon 808 eventually. My phone is basically living on borrowed time. And honestly, the next time it dies, I'm done with high-end devices. Having had to replace my phone twice in under two years has convinced me that I should treat my phones as if they were disposable, and so I'm going to buy my next phone at "disposable" prices. My next phone will probably be a Moto E4 or something in a similar price range (and I'd be willing to buy a $50 Chinese shitphone if only I could find one with AOSP and not some shitty custom UI).
- ce4 9y agoYou don't want the cheapest. Better something nice like a Xiaomi Mi A1. It is part of the Android One program (clutter free stock Android, timely updates) and doesnt cost a fortune.
- amyjess 9y agoI saw their webpage, and this jumped out at me: > full metal body Metal bodies fuck with my synesthesia—the feeling of metal on my fingers makes me ill—so that's a total dealbreaker. It has to be plastic.
- ce4 9y agoI can relate to that. My SO has it too, her auditory and tactile senses being affected. Q: A nice PU bumper doesn't help either?
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoIt looks like it can be rooted with Magisk, which makes it pretty appealing (at least if Xiaomi post factory images you can flash yourself).
- floatboth 9y agoApparently you can just disable the big cores and it will boot: https://www.xda-developers.com/nexus-5x-bootloop-fix-boot-phone/ https://www.xda-developers.com/nexus-5x-bootloop-fix-boot-ph... But mine's running perfectly so far. I even slightly overclocked the big cores. Changed to underclocked right now :D
- amyjess 9y agoI tried that when my last phone died. It didn't work. From what I saw trawling the XDA forums, there's a small percentage of bootloop victims who have all cores affected and not just the big ones, and I was part of that unlucky few.
- x0x0 9y agobuy an iphone. Vote with your wallet.
- ashleyn 9y agoCompounding the issue, maybe not for Google's devices but certainly others', is locking the bootloader so you can't even install an aftermarket ROM derived from open-source projects that are up to date security-wise. I won't name names, but one particularly egregious offender's initials are VZW.
- msla 9y ago> You buy a piece of hardware that could trivially keep working for 5-8 years, and it becomes actively dangerous to use, not just for the owner but to everyone else (think botnets), after 3 years because the vendor stops giving security updates for its software? This should be illegal. The simple way to make it illegal to produce potential botnet-hosts is to force manufacturers to remotely brick all hardware they no longer support.
- kllrnohj 9y ago> after 3 years because the vendor stops giving security updates for its software? This should be illegal. Feature updates stopped, security updates did not. The phones are still receiving monthly security patches and will continue to do so. Google did not stop those.
- Notre1 9y agoFrom the article: > The Nexus 6P and 5X launched with an update policy of two years for major OS updates and three years for security updates
- mjrpes 9y agoSecurity updates "are not guaranteed" after 3 years. Source: https://support.google.com/nexus/answer/4457705 https://support.google.com/nexus/answer/4457705
- netsharc 9y agoWhy do I have a feeling... that their next move will be... to sandbox everything. Everything goes through Google's servers. They'll advertise it as a universal firewall that will protect you 24/7. "Having continously updated software means no more outdated software!". And then using software that has known exploits (so old versions of Android/iOS) will be illegal... And then they will censor comparisons of Winnie the Pooh with the dear leader...
- fny 9y agoBefore you say it should be strictly illegal, consider a few consequences: - You're going to end up paying for that support in the cost of the phone or through annual licensing anyway. Would you really prefer that vs buying a new phone with latest gizmos vs buying a second-hand phone with semi-latest gizmos? - You've just created a moat for larger companies who can absorb the costs of maintaining older systems. The only issue I see here is the bot-net threat. That's a negative externality that no one's responsible for currently, and we can definitely be more creative about the policy than forcing people to support old tech. Maybe we force users to run software without known vulnerabilities? Perhaps then people would then demand more open technologies, but perhaps it'll further entrench the disposable tech paradigm. Maybe we just force companies to open source unmaintained software? Maybe we do this in tandem with above? Maybe we only penalize companies and organizations with a certain sized user base? The possibility space is really massive, and we technologists really need to sit down and think through the ramifications of each proposal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bitmapbrother 9y agoIs it also dangerous to use your TV, router or any other electronic device that hasn't received a single update since it left the factory? Should the sale of those devices also be illegal? How many updates has the software and firmware in your car received? Shouldn't it be illegal to be on the road in a car with obsolete software? Yet, according to you it's pathetic and should be illegal to use a smartphone that's only received 2 years of OS updates and 3 years of security updates. >You buy a piece of hardware that could trivially keep working for 5-8 years, and it becomes actively dangerous to use Dangerous to use? In case you weren't aware, the majority of the damage inflicted on consumers and businesses is perpetrated by IOT botnets and infected Windows computers.