3 ms·
Sure, that's for CF, but my question still stands for all the other heritable diseases.
by StavrosK 9y ago
Sure, that's for CF, but my question still stands for all the other heritable diseases.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoUh, no. All other heritable diseases are either homozygous recessive or they are passed via a single dominant gene. In neither case is there a 5 percent chance of passing it on. All recessive disorders follow the exact same math outlined above. This is genetics 101.
- StavrosK 9y agoAre you being intentionally obtuse? I am asking if you (and the GP) are okay with people not being able to mate if they have hereditary diseases that they can pass on to their children. CF, heart disease, cancer, whatever, it doesn't change my point.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAre you being intentionally obtuse? No, but you are being intentionally insulting in violation of HN guidelines and also moving the goal posts. I already stated above my diagnosis appears to be no barrier whatsoever to getting romantically involved with someone. Except from my end, as I have chosen to be celibate for medical reasons for a lot of years. I am 100 percent okay with someone like me being able to screen out carriers. Because I have CF, it is entirely up to the father's genetic contribution as to the outcome. I am also 100 percent okay with having some means to have a potentially awkward conversation up front. There are, in fact, worse things in life than sleeping alone.
- propman 9y agoI think the OP you responded to is being intentionally obtuse, you have made your point clear repeatedly. If you are aware you have CF gene and are also aware your partner does too, then you will not mate with them and instead find another mate. Some diseases can be eliminated like this. I also have a condition similar to you and there is no way I'm letting another child suffer with that, so I'm not going to ever mate with a woman who carries that gene.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI think the value in knowing upfront is you just avoid getting attached to begin with and you go bond with someone who doesn't introduce such big scary questions to the relationship. It is much easier to walk away before you get attached, no hard feelings. It is only when you fall in love first, have already invested substantial time into the relationship and then find out you both carry genes for something horrifying that it winds up being an agonizing question.
- dang 9y ago> Are you being intentionally obtuse? That's not ok here, as I'm sure you know. Please re-read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and post civilly or not at all, regardless of how someone else is being.
- ddorian43 9y agoI think I've read it's for bipolar:10% if only father, 50% if both parents.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAnd I am guessing that's not a case where they have identified specific genes. Please correct me if I am wrong. But I am not aware of bipolar genes being a thing. There is a difference between hand wavy "runs in the family, but we don't really know how it works" and a bona fide genetic disorder whose alleles have been mapped to some degree or another. Edit: To be perfectly clear, if it is not genetic and merely tends to run in families, it may be due to a variety of nongenetic factors, such as diet and lifestyle. Smoking also tends to run in families. Smoking is not a genetic disorder, though it significantly impacts health. If it is not genetic, it's heritability is not going to show up on your 23 and me profile. Fretting that it will basically means you don't know what you are talking about.
- ddorian43 9y agoYou are right, no genes. They are doing a study for depression + bipolar: https://www.23andme.com/depression-bipolar/ https://www.23andme.com/depression-bipolar/
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThere is a disease that was thought to be genetic, but was ultimately traced to ritual cannibalism spreading an infection. Relatives would eat the dead and what body part you got depended upon how closely related you were. This caused the disease to very much mimic a genetic disorder in its pattern of dispersal throughout the family. "Runs in families" needs to be very clearly distinguished from genetic disorders per se. The former suggests correlation with an as yet unidentified cause or causes, as there may be various contributing factors. The latter is a case of identified cause. Easy enough to confuse if your own life does not depend upon it, but absolutely not the same thing.