5 ms·
I did this too myself in 2013 with roughly the same numbers (initial body weight ~92kg losing 20kg in 7 weeks most of it body mass). Also I didn't take suppleme
by DyslexicAtheist 9y ago
I did this too myself in 2013 with roughly the same numbers (initial body weight ~92kg losing 20kg in 7 weeks most of it body mass). Also I didn't take supplements and cut down to tap water only (no food or soups or anything). Reintroducing my body to food was challenging to say the least.
I had prior experience doing such a diet once before (for 21 days a year earlier) knowing 8 weeks could be realistic for me to maintain at the time. I stopped a week early because even I boiled the tap water, the residual chlorine left over wasn't properly broken down by my body (food helps with that normally) and caused strong reactions every time I tried to drink (nausea even vomiting in final week). So not being able to hydrate myself I needed to stop very abruptly.
After I reintroduced my body to food I ended up in hospital a week later due to kidney stones (presumably a side effect of the starvation diet and flushing them out)
The hunger goes away after the 3rd/4th day and I was even able to go for a small run every other day until week 5. My motivation for it was neither religious nor to loose weight (although I had 10kg too much compared to my ideal shape 5 years before). People thought I was crazy for doing it (and I didn't tell anyone about it while it happened and also refused to discuss it with my doctor). I wanted to see how my body (and mind) reacts to extreme pressure like that. Also I felt experienced enough at the time to do this I would not recommend pushing too far into the extreme especially if it's your first time. Also worth noting that my weight never bounced back and I managed to maintain my ideal even after 5 years later (only gained 5kg mostly bodymass I lost not so much the fat).
My mental abilities (creativity, concentration, focus) were incredible especially until week 5. What I learned is as the body prepares for starvation it also releases huge amounts of energy that is stored up. Feels like having super powers. The body makes these reserves available so we can give it a final push for hunting or finding food (when homo sapiens is out in nature trying to survive I guess). It's probably why fasting is such a big thing in every religion.
- RobertRoberts 9y ago>..the residual chlorine left over wasn't properly broken down by my body When I fast, regular water tastes terrible, I can only drink distilled water. And for those that feel like arguing about distilled water, there's a series of arguments in my account on this topic already.
- Tepix 9y agoPurified water lacks minerals and ions such as calcium that play key roles in biological functions such as in nervous system homeostasis, and are normally found in potable water.
- RobertRoberts 9y agoI went through this whole discussion here before. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16434164 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16434164 My unanswered questions on distilled water: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16449541 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16449541 Edit: for clarity.
- goldenkey 9y agoCalcium isn't going to magically go into your distilled water and "remineralize" it - because most minerals aren't air gases. Distilled water pulls minerals from cells and causes apoptosis. Its just simple science of osmosis. Its not a big deal if you arent fasting, because most people get their minerals from solid food anyways.
- RobertRoberts 9y ago>Calcium isn't going to magically go into your distilled water and "remineralize" it... Fair enough. >Distilled water pulls minerals from cells and causes apoptosis. Does it do this because it's acidic? >...most people get their minerals from solid food anyways. Are you saying that because distilled water is acidic, and doesn't have minerals, it will destroy our bodies when fasting?
- pvaldes 9y agoNot, is for osmotic pressure. Cells are burst by that water. Is a simplification, but is a "mechanical damage" Any strong acid able to "dissolve tissues" will kill cells of course (causing apoptosis), but is not the only way. Distilled water is not so acid. Your questions are too over-specialized, too vague or too complex to be answered in a few lines. I can understand the lack of motivation and answers. How much electrolytes are there in a single "bite" of "any particular food"... is an example of question impossible to answer. A mouthful is a variable and undefined amount of matter, and "any particular food" has an almost infinite range.
- Jaruzel 9y ago> My mental abilities (creativity, concentration, focus) were incredible especially until week 5. How long did it take from the onset of the fasting, for your mental abilities to show improvement?
- DyslexicAtheist 9y agoOnce I overcame the initial hunger feeling of the first days it became noticeable. It then increased peaking in week 3 to 5 but present even until the final days. In the last days I became aware that every day I continued it was another day where my mind "won" against my body, and this scared me increasingly because I was no longer sure if I was still listening objectively to my body or if I was trying to prove something just for the sake of it. (e.g. "you came already that far now don't give up" -> this reasoning worked well for doing marathons sports but felt was dangerous to apply here). It was like my body telling me that it would no longer support my BS, ... but not via a hunger feeling as in initial days but I became so weak that walking more than few meters required a rest. Even speaking for more than 10 mins was tedious.
- saiya-jin 9y agoInteresting that it works for you, but any good doctor with >10 years of experience will tell you these are quite dangerous experiments to perform. Your body might stop giving you proper feedback so you might feel stuff is OK although you are heading for some organ failure and possibly quite sudden collapse and death (or lifelong health issues). You note the potential danger of mind pushing the body beyond - this threshold is unique to each of us, and what makes one OK might kill another one. To anybody else inspired by this 'experiment' - if you have the need for this (and don't want to reach some obscure goals in more traditional and proven ways), consult with your doctor. If he/she isn't knowledgeable in these matters, find another one. And consult regularly during experiment, ie blood/urine/heart checks will reveal about real state of your body much more than some 'body emotions' you might or might not feel (that comes from guy who listens to his body very intensively, but I understand the limits and potential traps of this feedback channel).
- twelve40 9y agoWow, did you feel weak? Were you able to work? During smaller fasts I've done I just felt super-weak and it affected my work.