8 ms·
Lessons from Spotify
- TekMol 9y agoThe authors central point seems to be that Spoitify is at the mercy of the record labels. Because the labels have the music. And that Spotify can't cut them out because they don't have enough users to attract artists: Notice how little power Spotify and Apple Music have; neither has a sufficient user base to attract suppliers (artists) But he does not explain his reasoning behind it. How big is their user base? Why is that not big enough? And how big would it have to be to attract artists?
- Cenk 9y agoWhat about back catalogs, though? Only the labels can provide those. Edit: Just remembered that Spotify may already be doing something like this[0] for certain areas where name recognition and back catalog don’t matter. A very clever approach, if they commissioned more tracks like these and filled their playlists with them, and concentrated on growing the areas of their user base that listen to those kinds of playlists, they could decrease their dependence on the record labels. [0]: https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/12/15961416/spotify-fake-artist-controversy-mystery-tracks https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/12/15961416/spotify-fake-art...
- ehnto 9y agoMy understanding was the vast majority of listens come from popular artists, and those listening to niche artists (of which there are tens of thousands) are the minority (~10%). But on researching this comment it would seem I may be way off base https://insights.spotify.com/no/2017/11/02/listening-diversity-spotify/ https://insights.spotify.com/no/2017/11/02/listening-diversi.... I really hope that is the case. I have more than a hundred artists in my saved list and a huge spread of genres and styles. I enjoy Spotify constantly for giving me some of these insights. I am just as likely to get a suggestion for an artist with 1000 followers versus someone with 500,000 thousand. The algorithm doesn't seem to give much weight to popularity and I love that. Popularity just isn't a strong indicator for quality music and people have been musing over that point for centuries. I think for many, music is just background noise or social fodder. Used solely for those ends then popularity matters. Otherwise, it's a useless metric and you are just as likely to find a genius with 200 followers as you are a vapid repeater box with 500,000. The hurdles serve as enough of a barrier for people posting just garbage to the platform, but they don't seem to hinder those who are creative but unpopular.
- StellarTabi 9y agoI'm hoping they double down on non-mainstream music, because that's what I'm using it for.
- eitland 9y ago> I think for many, music is just background noise... That's me 90% of the time. So names doesn't matter much AND I'd actually be happy if the artists got paid better, directly and without feeding the middle men in todays music industry.
- dyeje 9y agoAs a someone who used to do music semi professionally, I'm intrigued by this statement. I've never considered signing directly to a distributor. The major problems I see are, no artist wants to be locked to one platform and all the artist management folks Spotify would need to hire.
- TekMol 9y agoWhy would Spotify lock in the artist? It's enough for them to attain a license to play the songs. Why would that need management folks? Wouldn't a simple signup form be enough?
- jakevn 9y agoSpotify wouldn't lock in the artist, but labels do. If the label demands full rights to a song/album, you would not be able to sign for the label since you've already granted rights to Spotify.
- dyeje 9y agoTo me, they were suggesting that Spotify could replace labels if they had 'enough users'. Currently, band to record label relationships are exclusive (i.e. I can't release an album with both Label X and Label Y). Also, labels do a lot more than just getting your music on platforms. If Spotify wanted to replace the label, they would need to provide those services instead.
- TekMol 9y agoWhich services do record labels provide?
- dragonwriter 9y agoFinancing, networking/matchmaking between different kinds of talent that go into making records, and promotion, just off the top of my head.
- dyeje 9y ago
- anentropic 9y ago> neither has a sufficient user base to attract suppliers maybe it means 'exclusively'... i.e. it's not the absolute size of user base that matters but relative as long as there is no clear winner, artists would not want to sign up exclusively to one of the services
- anentropic 9y agoalso, if the record labels are keeping royalty rates 'high' (most artists would say they are pitifully low...) and are therefore acting in this case, through their own self-interest, as collective bargaining agents for artists (or at least, rights-holders) then anything that gives Spotify more power and profitability is presumably even worse for artists
- oflannabhra 9y agoIf Spotify were to pull a Netflix and begin signing artists, this would put it in conflict with its current supplier gateways, other labels. Unlike Netflix however, Spotify does not have enough of a market share to prevent the labels from pulling out.
- simias 9y agoOn top of that I don't think streaming music and videos is completely the same thing. I think for video new content is vastly more valuable than the back catalog, keeping a steady stream of fresh exclusives might be enough to justify a Netflix subscription. Meanwhile I'd say that maybe 2/3rds of my playlists are tracks from the past decade or older. Having only access to a subset of the music being produced today is not really enough for me to justify paying 10 euros a month. When I hear some music that I like on the radio I fully expect to be able to find it on Spotify and most of the time I'm right. If suddenly I have to use 3 different streaming services to access all the music I like then it'll be back to pirating for me. How do you even compile a playlist in these conditions? I really don't think that "pulling a Netflix" would make any sense for Spotify at all, and it would be a terrible thing for the users.
- EADGBE 9y agoAlso, royalties pay so little it's in the artists' best interest to put their music everywhere in hopes of a streaming revenue.
- fasteddie 9y agoOn the contrary, a ton of licensors have pulled out of Netflix. Its just that their content is good and at a large enough scale that it doesnt matter. Netflix was lucky to build its in-house production muscle before a lot of the licensors wised up and started building their own platforms.
- WisNorCan 9y agoPeople often use Netflix as a parallel to reason about Spotify and circumventing labels. But it is a bad comparison. Start with the consumer and work back. Consumers expect their music streaming service to have any song they are looking for. For video they don’t have the same expectation. Music has a greater element of “I want to listen to this particular song/album because it is my favorite”. Video is more about “I want to find something new to watch”. That fundamentally changes the value of having a complete catalog in music and puts Spotify in a weaker spot relative to Netflix.
- nerdponx 9y agoFor video they don’t have the same expectation. I think this has more to do with the economics of pirating movies versus music. When Netflix started, people were not used to torrenting (or Napster-ing, or Kazaa-ing, etc) movies. They were already at the mercy of Blockbuster, so being at the mercy of Netflix instead wasn't that big a deal. Pirating movies is more popular today, but people are still generally OK with having a limited movie selection. Whereas by the time iTunes Music rolled around, people were already comfortable with having the whole world of music at their fingertips. You can't undo something like that easily. So the only way forward has been to try to have everything. Perhaps the most interesting part about all this is that there was never (to my knowledge) such a thing as a store where you could rent records, tapes, or CDs -- Blockbuster for music.
- csytan 9y agoMusic also has much more replay-ability than movies.
- kakarot 9y ago> When Netflix started, people were not used to torrenting (or Napster-ing, or Kazaa-ing, etc) movies Can you provide a source for this that adjusts for the increase in worldwide internet use as well as bandwidth? When Netflix started, it was an overnight DVD delivery company, not directly competing with online movie piracy. Pirating movies in 1997 meant making large sacrifices over quality and convenience, not because people "weren't used to it". By the time Netflix entered the online movie streaming market to compete with piracy, the DMCA had been in effect for years. The world was very used to filesharing before the DMCA went into effect. And Blockbuster was already suffering poorly not just because of Netflix but because of a general shift in how people consume their movies. > Whereas by the time iTunes Music rolled around, people were already comfortable with having the whole world of music at their fingertips Through YouTube? Because otherwise I don't know of a truly comprehensive legal streaming service. Unless you're referring to filesharing? > Perhaps the most interesting part about all this is that there was never (to my knowledge) such a thing as a store where you could rent records, tapes, or CDs -- Blockbuster for music. Music-ripping tools were ubiquitous at the time (everyone had a CD drive), movie ripping tools were not nearly as popular. It didn't economically make sense.
- theptip 9y agoThere's possibly a bit of assumed knowledge in Ben Thompson's posts; he analyzes web companies through the lens of his Aggregation Theory. If you're not familiar with that, then it's possible that some of his arguments seem unfounded. [1] It perhaps sounds borderline tautological, but I think the reasoning under Aggregation theory is simply: if they could attract suppliers directly, they would have, and therefore because they haven't, they can't. I think this is reasonable where Aggregation theory holds, since being an Aggregator is an incredibly strong position in the market. To make a reductio ad absurdum example, as a musician, I believe you could currently just upload your recordings to Spotify, and skip the record label, in the same way that Youtube video producers upload their content directly. (Youtube is an example of a true Aggregator in Thompson's terminology.) However it seems quite clear that the Spotify-only approach wouldn't be sensible, because Spotify doesn't get you onto radio, tv commercials, and all the other channels that a record label has available. And Spotify revenue alone is less than Spotify-plus-record label. (e.g. see Taylor Swift, who gets (by a very swift Google search) $160m in revenue [2], vs. $2m paid by Spotify [3] (and split between her and her record label). Obviously some of that revenue comes from non-music revenue, but the album sales numbers suggest that she's netting at least tens of millions per year. [1]: https://stratechery.com/2015/aggregation-theory/ https://stratechery.com/2015/aggregation-theory/ [2]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackomalleygreenburg/2016/07/11/taylor-swift-is-the-worlds-top-earning-celebrity-with-170-million-in-2016/#455ff4f0747a https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackomalleygreenburg/2016/07/11... [3]: http://www.businessinsider.com/how-much-taylor-swift-earned-from-spotify-2014-11 http://www.businessinsider.com/how-much-taylor-swift-earned-...
- dalbasal 9y agoThis is a little tangental, but tangental to a couple of the themes here... One tangent is that I'm totally dissapointed with the dominant "content aggregators" like kindle, netflix, spotify, apple and such. Amazon wrapped up the ebook market quick. But, even though it's a revolutionary change in medium, very little changed. The book publishing industry was ripe for change. Physical publishing gradually got less expensive and less risky. From physical typesetting to short run modern printing. ebooks bring that capital cost down to $0. In response, publishers maintained their "venture capital" status with advances (money upfront to authors) and (supposedly) "marketing," the impression that a publisher can make a book sell. The point on publishers' marketing importance is dubious, especially in the context of amazon & ebooks. Advances, editing and the remaining jobs publishers do... The value/cost does not add up to 80-90% of the revenue. Typical royalty rates (5%-20%) are absurd. Amazon could have disrupted this, easily. It would have completeley changed the industry, and made writing a viable living for many more people, producing many more books. Also, mediums. Magazines famously spawned whole new formats and genres. So did things like paperbacks, pamphlets and other medium changes. Serials and shorts stories. Comic books and gossip collumns. The internet gave us blogs, tweets, infographics and PG essays. Ebooks gave us digital versions of paper books. The impact has been minimal. It is as if amazon did their very best to revolutionize books, but change as little as possible. Spotify did something similar, maintaining and reinforcing the norms of artist-label dynamics, even though they are completely unsuited to the modern industry. My second tanget is a point on the cost that does scale linearly: customer acquisition costs. This generally means FB & Google. They started as free discovery (customer acquisition from the customers' perspective) and became paid customer acquisition tools. Today, they are mostly paid customer acquisition tools. This means (a) that these guys charge a toll on certain sectors and (b) that ability to pay this toll is a major factor of success. It sucks to be in a market with head-t-head competition. These markets are efficient (especially on adwords) and the price of acuiring a customer tends to stabilze near marginal revenue per customer. IE, whatever your margin is on customer, it goes mostly to google. If you earn less per customer (per impression, more accurately) than the competition, these channels are closed to you. This results in a uniformity of business models. Examples are many, but think of all the subscription food delivery, maid services, laundry, etc. If you are offering one-off housecleaning and your competition is selling subscriptions, they will probably outbid you on adwords. You will need to change to a subscription model to stay on adwords. Free discovery channels (eg, HN) have (had?) a totally different dynamic then the paid ones. I think this is an important thing to realize, if you're starting a something these days.
- bernardlunn 9y agoBen Thompson is an original thinker, usually worth reading
- 1337biz 9y agoIs there anyone similar to Thompson who has such an interesting take on business topics? I have been looking for a while but this is really hard to find!
- julian_digital 9y agoHave a look at Benedict Evans' articles: https://www.ben-evans.com/ https://www.ben-evans.com/
- lambda_lover 9y agoMore finance than business, but I really enjoy Matt Levine (he writes for Bloomberg). Even though his articles are technically finance there's enough tech and business analysis in there that you don't have to be a finance nerd to find good content. And he publishes Money Stuff most weekdays! https://www.bloomberg.com/view/topics/money-stuff https://www.bloomberg.com/view/topics/money-stuff
- exolymph 9y agoMatt Levine is also funny as hell, his columns are worth it for that alone.
- macintux 9y agoIn addition to the other suggestions, Horace Dediu does a nice job with technology firm analysis (as he says, using Apple as a lens). http://www.asymco.com/ http://www.asymco.com/ I admit I've been paying less attention over the last couple of years, but historically his content has been well worth reading. I was fortunate to catch one of his talks in person in Chicago, was quite interesting.
- 1337biz 9y agoDidn't know about that one. Thank you for bringing it up. Very interesting perspective!
- thehnguy 9y agoBen Thompson delivers again. I love reading this guy’s stuff. I’m not saying it’s earth shattering, but it’s accessible, well thought out, and leave feeling much more informed.
- shostack 9y agoHis exponent podcast is excellent as well. Just wish it was available on Google Play Music which it is not for some odd reason.
- Distant_horizon 9y agoSpotify's ad studio (and sales team) deserve more acknowledgement. I don't pay for a Premium account, but I'm a daily user. I find the ads tolerable, the voices relevant. And they dont interfere with my enjoyment of the platform. In contrast, the ridiculous ads on Pandora is what sent me to Spotify. I can only assume Pandora has low inventory, because I'm getting ads for a tractor company 30 miles away. I'm a Sr dev, listening to Drake, and I don't have a lawn or a farm.
- dullgiulio 9y agoAs far as I have understood, that's not how it works economically. Spotify is trying hard to make free users upgrade to premium, while enlarging the user base. I don't think they have any interest in playing real ads (except some music-related ones that maybe keep the labels a bit more quiet); that's the reason you get tolerable ads. But in the longer term, Spotify might decide to kill the free service (or just make it a timed trial.)
- earenndil 9y ago> Spotify might decide to kill the free service (or just make it a timed trial.) I doubt this will happen. A lot of teenagers right now have only have a free spotify subscription because they don't have any money, and spotify probably wants to keep them as subscribers so in the future they do become customers.
- kn0where 9y agoCount me as a single data point for the example of a teenager switching to paid Spotify as a college student (albeit discounted to half-price). When I graduate I'll probably keep paying, at the full $10/month. Apple Music is tempting for Siri integration, and Amazon and Google are certainly alternatives, but I'd rather stick with the cross-platform "underdog" that doesn't lock me into using iTunes. Also, screw Apple Music and Tidal for "exclusives."
- earenndil 9y ago
- thisisit 9y ago> Making matters worse, the U.S. Copyright Royalty Board just increased the amount to be paid out to songwriters; Spotify said the change isn’t material, but it certainly isn’t in the right direction either. I can be wrong but wouldn't something like this affect Spotify's bottom line in short term already? That said, the situation might be even worse. As pointed by the top post from an earlier Spotify IPO discussion, record companies might squeeze Spotify even more if it starts becoming profitable: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16063502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16063502
- daryltan2007 9y agoIt’s an interesting article. I think it overplays the power of the record labels though. If Spotify increases its user base substantially enough, then bargaining power goes to them in the Long run. Record labels can’t make money selling directly to the consumer anymore. Secondly, I don’t think the cost is a problem. if it IPOs, the proceeds will be used to fund (my guesss) customer acquisition which would be in line with their strategy of incurring larger costs now in return for future gain.
- Sammi 9y agoWhat can Spotify do if labels pull their catalog? It needs their music. Labels on the other hand have other places to go. Labels have options, Spotify doesn't. It's not hard to see who has more bargaining power.
- subpar 9y agoFor another (less business, more aesthetic) perspective on Spotify's impact on how we listen to and make music, check out: https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-problem-with-muzak-pelly https://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-problem-with-muzak-pelly
- MBlume 9y agoI think this might understate the problems Spotify has. Their earnings reports are public and they are, as the author says, at the mercy of the record labels. If Spotify has an unusually profitable quarter, the labels are simply going to take that as a sign that they set their fees too low, and they're going to rectify that mistake. It doesn't matter what costs they cut, it doesn't matter how they increase their profits, the labels are going to see themselves as entitled to that surplus.
- philipodonnell 9y agoThere are other examples (however imperfect) where this dynamic exists without it having a continuously negative effect on margins. Apple/iTunes doesn't seem to be called out as having a ton of risk in this area despite similar dynamics. Cable companies/satellite TV/radio for other industry examples. Not saying it isn't a risk, just that there are accepted strategies for protecting profits as a distribution channel.
- w0m 9y agoThose companies are all markedly larger and pull revenue from other places also. what % of iTunes profit today comes from Music vs (movies/books/app/etc)? Spotify is uniquely vulnerable on that front.
- 2aa07e2 9y agoIndeed. I read a great comment somehow related to this on Quora [1]. How can possibly Spotify diversify its income though? [1] https://www.quora.com/Why-do-people-buy-merchandise-of-YouTubers/answer/Matthew-Joseph-Andrews https://www.quora.com/Why-do-people-buy-merchandise-of-YouTu...
- philipodonnell 9y agoVideo? I feel like they have a reputation for being good about paying artists, there's a need for a Youtube replacement that lets video creators act more like record labels for their own content instead of being passive participants in the Youtube ecosystem and subject to their whims.
- jayzee 9y agoSpotify vs netflix - People very very infrequently watch the same movie/tv show twice. - People very very frequently listen to the same song therefore - The past is important for songs since at any point in time there are more songs in the past that you want to listen than new songs that have been just released - The future is more important for movies since you are looking fwd to watching something new therefore Netflix >>> Spotify
- soared 9y ago> People very very infrequently watch the same movie/tv show twice. While probably true now, this will change over time. Most people I know (mid/low 20s) use netflix as a replacement for the radio - putting on The Office / parks and rec just as background noise while doing other things. Those shows have been on repeat in my house everyday for a few years.