10 ms·
The forgetting curve explains why humans struggle to memorize
- megamindbrian2 9y agoI worked on an app based on this timeline like flashcards, it reset when you get a card wrong. Https://www.studysauce.com
- fao_ 9y agoWhat's the difference between this app and something like Anki or Tinycards?
- jonbarker 9y agoI've been looking for an (optionally OCR enabled) spaced repetition software package that allows me to take pictures of flashcards, and then load those into a standard spaced repetition algorithm, then render those either in a browser or an ios app. Anki supposedly does this but in my experience it's been hard to get up and running. Maybe something that just works with something like evernote or onenote would do the trick.
- throwaway675309 9y agoHow is your app different than the huge number of SRS-based flashcard apps that are already out there? Particularly the grand-daddy of many of them, SuperMemo which based its SRS scheduled system off of Ebbinghaus.
- mattmanser 9y agoIf you're interested in improving your learning, I can't recommend the free course "Learning how to learn" enough: https://www.coursera.org/learn/learning-how-to-learn https://www.coursera.org/learn/learning-how-to-learn It includes a section about this. I've also found many of the lessons applicable to other parts of my life.
- DomreiRoam 9y agoAnother free course made by the same team: https://www.coursera.org/learn/mindshift https://www.coursera.org/learn/mindshift This course is more focused on how/what to learn to boost your career. I liked both courses; they take 2-3 hours per week for 4 week.
- spodek 9y ago> forgetfulness doesn’t always occur (Princess Leia’s prison cell block number: AA-23) Sure, when it's the start of the Fibonacci sequence.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoThanks, now I'll never be able to unsee or forget that. But you do make a good point about the importance of linking/patterns in memory.
- taeric 9y agoAnd naming them.
- markshead 9y agoOur memory is a cache and each timed repetition increasingly delays the purge date of a particular memory.
- mlevental 9y agocitation?
- badosu 9y agoIt's an analogy for the reinforcing characteristic of neuronal connections, would be perfectly adequate if not for the continuum vs discrete difference in the reinforcement mechanism.
- kylerpalmer 9y agoI don't know about the brain acting like a cache, but synaptic pathway weighting is thought to be modified by how often neurons on either side of it fire near the same time. This is called spike timing dependent plasticity (STDP). The seminal paper for this is: http://www.jneurosci.org/content/18/24/10464.long http://www.jneurosci.org/content/18/24/10464.long
- markshead 9y agoI was just saying that curves of how much is forgotten seem to look similar to a caching mechanism.
- gugagore 9y agoThis seems like it could be true for memories of facts, or something you can recite, like lyrics of a song. However for other kinds of memories, such as remembering a situation or a picture, I have heard (I'd appreciate a reference) that the recall process of long-term memory is slightly destructive, and that the memory must be re-encoded into long-term memory. That suggests that recalling a memory repeatedly could accelerate it's deterioration.
- markshead 9y ago
- dqpb 9y ago>An unhelpful but common metaphor is that of the brain-as-computer, or computer-as-brain. The two things are often presented as working the same way. A brain “stores” memories like files on a hard drive, and software uses “neural networks” to learn like the human mind does. But the reality of learning is different. The computer won’t forget where the file is, and the neural network can only learn what it’s told to. So many flaws packed into one paragraph. >brain-as-computer, or computer-as-brain That would be two different metaphors, not one >A brain “stores” memories like files on a hard drive Nobody thinks this >The computer won’t forget where the file is Brains don't forget because they can't find the file... >neural network can only learn what it’s told to The power of neural networks is that they discover patterns on their own. Thats the whole f*ing point of neural networks.
- killjoywashere 9y ago> A brain “stores” memories like files on a hard drive > Nobody thinks this Ahhh... I don't know. That was certainly a fiction that a number bosses where happy to foist on my generation back in the day. It makes for a very convenient basis to blame the junior for virtually anything.
- boomboomsubban 9y ago>Brains don't forget because they can't find the file... They sort of do. The act of remembering alters the connections to other information made. Later, when trying to recall something again, the original connections may no longer work leaving you unable to find the information. >The power of neural networks is that they discover patterns on their own. Thats the whole f*ing point of neural networks. They can only find patterns in what they're told to.
- dqpb 9y ago> They can only find patterns in what they're told to. I disagree. If you feed a bunch of images into a CNN, it doesn't just learn flower, cat, etc. It learns more fundamental things such as edges, textures, patterns. see: https://distill.pub/2018/building-blocks/ https://distill.pub/2018/building-blocks/ Moreover, you can use simple reward signals, such as "progress forward", to learn complex locomotion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hx_bgoTF7bs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hx_bgoTF7bs If you still think these represent "find[ing] patterns in what they're told to", I would argue you only think that because the scale of these experiments is so small.
- supertramp_ 9y agoI truly believe the learning/memorizing process is different for each person. For example I've been driving my car for more than a year and I still can't remember right away in which side of the car the gas tank is located at. What I do remember is that in every car, there is an arrow on the side of the gauge which indicates where the gas tank is at.
- overcast 9y agoYou're ahead of most people then, because I would say the vast majority have no idea that arrow even exists(sometimes it doesn't).
- cgore 9y agoMy old 1978 Chrysler Cordoba has it behind the license plate in the back, so you can fill up from either side, and so it doesn't interfere with the lines of the car. I think they stopped doing it because rear-end collisions are so common though :(
- ajmurmann 9y agoI think there are lots of factors that can make it easier to remember certain facts. Building associations with existing knowledge helps a lot especially when attaching it to something that triggers emotions. Tying spacial information also is very powerful at least when you can access the information via the spacial association. I recently learned a lot of Kanji vis SRS and tried different techniques to beat the memory curve. For example mind palaces worked incredibly well for remembering a ton of new Kanji in order. However, when they came up out of order I frequently couldn't remember them or only remember where in my mind palaces they belong, but not their meaning. A better structured mind palaces could have probably helped. I think you might be able to remember the arrow in the car because you spend so much more time behind the steering wheel than filling up the car and have a easier time putting the arrow in the context of the controls you look at frequently. It's much easier to connect to existing memory.
- jtbayly 9y agoI solved that problem by refusing to buy cars where the gas tank is on the other side of the car from me.
- acd 9y agoThe human brain could work the same as memristors. Memristors gets harder to charge as they get full. Ie in the analogy that a young brain can easily learn things but it gets harder to learn things the older the person as the brain is full of information. One also observes the same in AI that the AI learns more in the first evolutions. Also the same in Spaced repetition such as Anki and Memrise. Anki and Memrise software must some how know of the forgetting curve. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaced_repetition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaced_repetition Memristor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor Memristors mimic human brain https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1264640 https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1264640
- closed 9y ago> the analogy that a young brain can easily learn things but it gets harder to learn things the older the person as the brain is full of information. I'm not sure this is true in general. Older people have rich semantic connections that, if they can leverage them, allow them to learn things quickly. But those connections can also work against them (e.g. learning to drive on the other side of the road you get to keep 90% of what you learned, but also battle against a strong, pre-learned bias).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tsumnia 9y agoIn Ebbinghaus' original work, it is simply about memorizing syllables. However, that is only a small percentage of learning harder skills like computer science (learning syntax), language (learning words), or even acting (learning lines). The next steps would be to synthesize (Bloom's taxonomy) the newly acquired knowledge in some way to facilitate higher levels of learning (CS - problem-solving, language - conversational fluency, acting - character work). I think this is where Bloom's taxonomy (and the like) can help with decreasing the decay effect. The mental effort requirements for memorizing are considerably lower than those of levels like synthesis. In that case, factual information can be lost (specific API commands), but more important elements are retained (when/why/how to make API calls).
- mannykannot 9y agoThe sort of learning and remembering that is a part of understanding something seems even further removed from Ebbinghaus' exercises with syllables. It feels that when I am doing this sort of memorization, I am building some sort of model (which also gets remembered, or perhaps it is more accurate to say the model is the memory), and the model gets used in retrieving relevant facts. It seems much easier for me to remember an arcane fact if it led to an important or surprising insight when I was first presented with it.
- tsumnia 9y ago> seems much easier for me to remember an arcane fact if it led to an important or surprising insight That's where I think Bloom's can step in. Memorization is the first step, but then its about recalling and applying the mental model. As you traverse the levels, you eventually reach things like problem-solving and evaluating. Ebbinghaus discusses spaced repetition, but I wonder if spaced repetition in conjunction with Bloom's taxonomy is a better approach for higher level learning than JUST spaced memorization.
- TangoTrotFox 9y agoI'm surprised this didn't hit on relational memory. In the latest edition of stupid human tricks, people are often surprised when strong chess players, or myself, can easily repeat the moves of a game, from scratch, after playing - even substantial amounts of time later. It's all about the relational aspect. Chess games are easy because they tell a story in a strong player's head, and so to repeat the game you just tell the story in your head again. That's why if you do forget a game, just being told what the first move or two was is often enough to recall the rest of the game - kind of like being told the first sound of a word you're trying to remember. This is also why chess players can see a position and remember 'Ooo, that's from Reti-Alekhine' or whatever. You see games and the people playing become part of the story. It's like reading a page from a book and being able to say what book it was. On top of that it's also quite often an extremely important page, making such a demonstration even more trivial. There have also been a lot of studies testing this stuff. For instance, one briefly showed strong players a position that might actually occur in a regular game and asked them to recreate the position. And they did extremely well, whereas casual players did awfully. However, the interesting thing is that when asked to do this for positions with the pieces on random squares, strong players did not do substantially better than casual players. This has been attributed to pattern recognition, but in my opinion it's more about the story being told even on a single move - the ideas and possibilities. Again the difference between trying to repeat the words from a page of book as opposed to trying to repeat random words.
- franciscop 9y agoThe best resource I have ever found on the topic is this, which digs really deep in the topic: - https://www.gwern.net/Spaced%20repetition https://www.gwern.net/Spaced%20repetition That, combined with Frequency Lists (another really cool topic), is what inspired me to create my own learning webapp: - https://core.cards/ https://core.cards/ Note: it's for me to learn, so login is a bit broken and you have to try to do it twice for it to work if you want to test it out.