4 ms·
You’re not changing the world
- gouggoug 9y agoThis reminded me of a newsletter I received from angelList once which title read: "Startups are here to save the world" [0] I un-subscribed. [0] https://angel.co/newsletters/startups-are-here-to-save-the-world-102317 https://angel.co/newsletters/startups-are-here-to-save-the-w...
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoIt's still unclear to me what DHH's goals are for these pieces. And look, some of them do end up changing the world. So, if you as a founder have the desire to reshape the world in the way you want it, then you should not try because the probability of success is low? That doesn't make sense. Is the goal to have people lower their expectations? Ok, that's at least a psycho-social argument for contentment, but are they preaching that people should embrace mindfulness? Generally DHH and Fried like to antagonize the idea of moonshot startups with audacious plans and goals stated as such. Sure, some of them are silly and over the top and worth a bit of ribbing, however it's been years now and (having been on the receiving end of one of their rants) it seems entirely unfocused with no prescription for WHO exactly should be trying to do moonshots that actually do "change the world." After all they admit that it is possible to do, so why should people not try? Make no mistake, they are trying to influence people - like we all are - by writing these posts. What's the purpose of them if none of it matters?
- fragsworth 9y agoI feel like you didn't read anything in the article. The point is that you don't advertise it unless you're full of shit. It's a bullshit marketing/hiring tactic. If you really want to change the world, you make a thing, and focus on the thing, not on how you're "changing the world".
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI suppose you could assume a portion of that argument from the paragraph on companies that have "changed the world" not setting out to. However a lesson like "don't fake it till you make it" wasn't the takeaway. I interpret the last paragraph: "Set out to do good work. Set out to be fair in your dealings with customers, employees, and reality. Leave a lasting impressions on the people you touch, and worry less (or not at all!) about changing the world. Chances are you won’t, and if you do, it’s not going to be because you said you would." as: You shouldn't try to make a huge impact because just saying you would won't get you there. Which by the way DHH is wrong about what Jack Dorsey wanted Twitter to be. A few of his early quotes "My goal is to simplify complexity. I just want to build stuff that really simplifies our base human interaction." "We get to design what we want to see in the world rather than doing what other people think should be done." Doesn't get much more "changing the world" language than that.
- rimliu 9y ago> Doesn't get much more "changing the world" > language than that. Actually it does. If he said "We want to change the world" that would be much more like it. What he says there is "be the change you want to see".
- rileyphone 9y agoHe isn't saying you shouldn't try to make an impact, just to acknowledge that what your doing is only going to really effect a subset of people. DHH himself has made a huge impact, by virtue of RoR, but this only changed the world for some thousands of developers. Maybe you can make the argument that this "trickles down" to the rest of the world, but all in all, your best chance at making impact comes from vastly improving the lives of what turns out to be a very small part of humanity rather than aiming for it all.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoacknowledge that what your doing is only going to really effect a subset of people. That's a self fulfilling prophecy though, is it not? If you aren't somewhat delusional (aka optimistic) about the scale of what you set out to do, then the probability of major outcome - is going to be reduced. Basically, if you set small local goals then the chances that you'll even desire a global goal - let alone reach them - are likely an order of magnitude smaller than possible. Using his example, had Zuckerburg followed this advice he would have sold to yahoo having optimized locally. Instead he said, no I want to change the world (aka literally connect the world) so I am going to try and do that.
- askafriend 9y agoI think their main goal is to serve as a counterbalance to the prevailing voices in the industry and to show people that there are various definitions of success - not just the definition that TechCrunch and the VC circles elevate. I welcome their voice. I think it’s a nice counterbalance. We need both kinds of voices in the room.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI think that's fair, however the tone seems to be more aggressive than simply saying "hey there are other options." It's more "there is no place for this ecosystem and you're broken if you play in it." For example just from this post alone: These people have "delusions of grandeur" and "congitive dissonance" are making an "existential cry for help."
- toomuchtodo 9y ago“The amount of energy necessary to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it.”
- badcede 9y agoTheir "main goal" is self-promotion, same as the material they put down. Which they need, the way dung beetles need dung.
- askafriend 9y agoI don't think they have much to gain by advocating for this kind of stuff so publicly. They're already incredibly well known for Basecamp, Ruby on Rails, and various other things. That's why I'm inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt that they've demonstrated they deserve (in my view). But who knows, maybe they are indeed psychopathic attention seekers like you suggest. It's impossible for us to prove it one way or another, so I largely find that an irrelevant detail. I generally agree with the general spirit of what they're advocating for even if sometimes they don't quite hit the mark.
- ksec 9y agoNone of the Founders, Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Larry, or Mark decide to change the world from the first place. They changed the world as a consequence of their success, not their Goal. It will mostly mid way through their success did they realize they really could "shape" the world for the better. Now a days every single bloody ( mostly American )company, not only just Startup, decide they should have a mission statement to change the world. And if you are not in this dream, you shouldn't be working for this company. DHH is merely stating the obvious truth. You really aren't changing the world or you dont have to and that is ok. But in the Silicon Valley world of absolute optimism, stating such boring truth is consider pessimistic.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoNone of the Founders, Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Larry, or Mark decide to change the world from the first place. I don't actually believe this. Maybe notch was the only one that this could really be true for. All the people you mentioned in those positions have an obsessive drive for success/power - which defacto implies molding the world to how you want it to be. While it might be true that they didn't know the exact path that they were on was going to be the thing, they had an inkling which they put a shitload of effort into and followed the trend/power curve. That's how all conquerors work. You know the general landscape, but not the exact path, so you can accurately say "well I knew microcomputers were going to be huge, I just didn't expect it was going to be through DOS." That sounds a lot like "I wasn't planning on being a huge success, it just happened." Otherwise you sound like a megalomaniac blowhard. Musk seems to be the only one who has stated his intention to "change the world" but dodged any real criticism other thank jokes about him being a supervillain.
- ksec 9y agoThey wanted huge success, sure. But changing the world wasn't their intent. It was mere consequences. Steve wanted to build best computer. Bill wanted a PC in every household.
- AndrewKemendo 9y ago
- badcede 9y agoIt's just his usual troll. They've been blowing that note for ten years and will never change. Sing the third, just sing the third: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVTzT3FmxhI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVTzT3FmxhI. Amusing how he talks about "the Twitter mob" and "their" pitchforks as if "they" were someone else, though.
- rileyphone 9y agoThe takeaway here is that our efforts aren't meaningless, just that they won't be noticed in the context of "the world". Progress on the grand scale isn't necessarily brought about by giants; their contributions, while having weight, are dubious in value. Focus is the most valuable thing, as some of the greatest influences in the average individuals life come from a source shared by few others (in the grand scale), whether it be a religious congregation, a nice barbeque joint, or this very forum.
- AstralStorm 9y agoMost important progress recently came from giant corporations promoting a thing. That thing was electricity, with electric lighting at the forefront. Second example was IBM and computing. (earlier than you probably think...) Next Intel and its manufacturing. Xerox was the corporation behind fast printing. Sony behind most of portable music and video recording... The Internet is the main counterexample. The otger counterexamples almost always used the effects of scale created by the previous giants. (Apple, Microsoft, Google or Facebook - using both reduced price internet, computer hardware and hole after dotcom boom.)
- neya 9y agoDo you know who's the perfect example for the post? These guys: >“Asana’s mission is to help humanity thrive by enabling all teams to work together effortlessly.“ Underline: >help humanity thrive Let that sink in. This post has long been coming. Someone had to write this. On an unrelated note, If you start your own company, please, PLEASE don't write BS for your mission statements, vision, etc. They're supposed to mean something. It will otherwise contribute to a lot of negative things, including trust issues and poor employee morale. Write something you truly believe in.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoWhat exactly is the problem with Asana having that as a mission statement? I'm not arguing that it's good or bad, but I don't quite see how it "contribute[s] to a lot of negative things, including trust issues and poor employee morale" I think the argument you're making is that the Asana statement was written cynically and they don't really believe that. I think it's impossible to truly know, but I know a lot of founders who really do believe in their mission statements.
- neya 9y agoWhat I mean is, that mission statement is going to be hanging around in their company somewhere. Every time an employee looks at that, he's going to think "Am I really helping humanity thrive with my little python script I write here daily? No." I know I and many others like me would think so. Contrast this with someone like Sony. > "At Sony, our mission is to be a company that inspires and fulfills your curiosity. ground-breaking new excitement and entertainment in ways that only Sony can. Everything we do, is to move you emotionally." The products they release resonate with their mission statements. Have you used Asana? I recommend you give it a try, once you try it, you'll realize how exaggerated their mission statement is. This thread is a good read: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16271279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16271279
- pspeter3 9y agoWhat do you think their mission statement should be? Do you also think it really affects day to day work
- wruza 9y agoThe same way I often can’t get what company’s product really does, since its frontpage is full of [img] we work hard for you, [img] we are into the future, [img] enable amazing experience, [img] stay in touch with more marketing bullshit. Close tab, next search result. Oh, ${utilnamefrom1990s}, this is what I’m looking for.