2 ms·
The patchworks of demographics, identity, media narrative, alliances, and horse-trading that determine government representation and policy are extremely comple
by closeparen 9y ago
The patchworks of demographics, identity, media narrative, alliances, and horse-trading that determine government representation and policy are extremely complex and require immense energy to influence in the smallest of ways.
They are vanishingly unlikely to budge for your pet technocratic issue. Doing surgeries correctly is not, in any meaningful sense, up for a vote, nor is anyone going to win elected office on a doing-surgeries-correctly platform.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoBasic societal infrastructure (in this case, universal healthcare) is not a pet technocratic issue. When did we become a first world country in name only? The irony of such levels of defeatism in a forum that proclaims opportunity is at every turn is astounding. Hope is not a strategy, but chances of success are not zero.
- closeparen 9y agoThe Indian Health Service exists. The sexy ideological and identitarian battle over whether the federal government should provide health care to Native Americans is already won. But democracy fundamentally lacks an accountability mechanism for pesky little details like the quality of the service provided.