2 ms·
universally acknowledged that the Tet Offensive was militarily a disaster Does it really make sense to try to distinguish military success from the political c
by wahern 9y ago
universally acknowledged that the Tet Offensive was militarily a disaster
Does it really make sense to try to distinguish military success from the political consequences? The notion that those things are gainfully distinguishable seems horribly flawed and can be found at the root of our foreign policy and military blunders.
It's sort of like talking about how technology A is better than technology B without giving any consideration to market viability, path dependency, etc. Someone who appreciates and emphasizes the latter will almost always see greater success than someone who focuses on the "best" technology. What's worse is when someone bitterly complains about how their startup failed even though they had the better technology. Not only did they fail in the market, but they don't even understand why they failed, which is that realistically there's no objective "better" technology independent from market dynamics. Likewise, there can exist no objective military "success" if the political consequences result in the campaign ultimately crumbling.
Another way to put it is that given the American strategic posture, the only to have seen success in the Tet Offensive would have been to have been more prepared and taken many fewer casualties such that the public would have never wavered in its support. That may seem an unfair benchmark, but war isn't fair. If you're going to win a war, you have to understand how wars are won. You not only go to war with the army you have instead of the army you wish you had, you go to war with the public support you have, not the public support you wish you had. If the public is fickle, you better make sure you account for that. Otherwise you'll fail.