3 ms·
Your response presumes a particular philosophical position. When you call life "an artificial categorization that humans use because it is useful to them", you
by skissane 9y ago
Your response presumes a particular philosophical position. When you call life "an artificial categorization that humans use because it is useful to them", you are espousing the nominalist solution to the problem of the universals, and applying that to biology. Even while attacking the philosophy of biology you are actually engaging in it.
Nominalism may be "obvious" to you, but it isn't obvious to everyone. Just because someone thinks something is "obvious" it does not automatically follow that it is true. Have you given serious thought to nominalism's alternatives, such as moderate realism (Aristotelian, Thomistic or Scotistic); or Platonism?
- nonbel 9y agoThere isn't any deeper philosophy behind what I said, it has nothing to do with how things "really are". Just go categorize some stuff and see what happens. Is a bottle cap a "coin"? In some cases, sure that could be. In others, not at all.