6 ms·
There is a significant segment of American society that believes that if you are poor you must have done something to deserve it, like not work hard enough. Be
by lisper 9y ago
There is a significant segment of American society that believes that if you are poor you must have done something to deserve it, like not work hard enough. Because of this, to help poor people is to subsidize (and hence encourage) laziness, and that is unacceptable. On the other hand, we can't just shoot all the poor people (though we can shoot some of them, as long as they're black and threatening) and we can't just have them loitering in the streets because that's bad for business. So the best we can do it run them out of town on a rail. Out of sight, not our problem any more, that's good enough. We don't need a long-term solution, we just need to stave off disaster long enough for Jesus to return, and that will be Real Soon Now.
Sadly, this is not an exaggeration. Tens of millions of Americans really do believe all of the above.
- dang 9y agoPlease keep generic ideological flamewars well away from HN, and religious flamewars well awayer. Scorched earth is not interesting. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16531067 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16531067 and marked it off-topic.
- lisper 9y agoSorry about that. I didn't think I was crossing the line. Will be more careful in the future.
- dang 9y agoThanks!
- lisper 9y agoBTW, can you please clarify for me exactly what it was about my comment that crossed the line? Was it the actual content, or just the editorialized phraseology ("real soon now"). Because it is simply a fact that a significant fraction of American society really does believe that there is no need to address any long term problems because the Second Coming is imminent. If I had phrased it like that, would that have been OK?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Justsignedup 9y agoI am fairly well off I'd say... Then I was thinking "What happens if tomorrow I get injured and cannot work for 12 months". - I lose my place of living because I can't afford the bills - I move into my parent's house - My family loses their health insurance entirely. - I have to pay for COBRA... but I don't have a job... - I may need to take out loans to just get by for some time till I can get my health back in order. Yeah we have ZERO social safety nets.
- tensor_rank_0 9y agocan you explain why you don't consider medicare, food stamps, and section 8 housing to be social safety nets?
- Something1234 9y agoBecause there can be very high qualifications for some of them? Medicare is not applied uniformly, and you might get a random price for what you get. Medicaid is a social safety net, but that's a last ditch thing and very few providers take it. I'm not sure what it would take to qualify for section 8, but I think it has a long waiting list and some high qualifications like having just about nothing.
- allthenews 9y agoMore white men die being shot by police, per violent crime rate, than black men. Please stop spreading convenient lies. This isn't about poor black people being shot for racist sport. This is about a disproportionate number of violent criminals being confronted by police. I'm not even sure why you felt compelled to bring it up. https://www.dailywire.com/news/7264/5-statistics-you-need-know-about-cops-killing-aaron-bandler https://www.dailywire.com/news/7264/5-statistics-you-need-kn... By the way, the first 3 pages on google for searching "white police deaths" yielded exclusively results discussing disproportionate black deaths per capita, ignoring crime rate. I had to go to duckduckgo to find a single source which discussed the truth. Before you accuse me of confirmation bias, take a look at the actual statistics, please.
- lisper 9y agoI was describing the mental state of a segment of American society. The particular segment I'm referring to often has views that are detached from facts.
- jackhack 9y agoNo, you were demonstrating a classic strawman argument. A bigoted strawman argument, at that. When you find yourself in a hole, stop digging.
- lisper 9y agoNo, I was not advancing a straw man. A straw man is an intentional mis-statement of an opponent's argument (e.g. "We can't be descended from moneys because there are still monkeys"). That's not what I was doing. I was making a straightforward claim about what is believed by a significant portion of American society. That claim might be wrong, but it's not a straw man.
- tdb7893 9y agoThe article you linked cherry picks statistics for metropolitan areas (it seems to lump the poor and African American parts of New York with the richer are more white sections) and the article even mentions that unarmed black men are much more likely to be shot and their argument for why that is seems largely anecdotal so the statistics seem less clear than what you linked would imply
- ythn 9y agoOn the other hand, tens of millions of Americans also take the polar opposite stance: Nobody is responsible for anything. If anyone is in a bad circumstance (health, money, job, housing, debt, drugs, addiction, abortion, sex, crime) it was not their fault; it can't be. It was therefore a failure of the system, and therefore the system needs to fix it. Either they didn't get the proper mental health care they needed, physical health care, or education, or <insert system failure>.
- lucideer 9y agoI have never encountered an American who thinks this, in person, or online. I'm sure plenty of Americans that I have not encountered do think this, but they are in a negligible, near-non-existent minority.
- ythn 9y agoWell, look around more, it's everywhere. Just this week: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/my-brain-made-me-do-it-is-becoming-a-more-common-criminal-defense/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/my-brain-made-me-... The liberal philosophy in general is that people don't need to be responsible for anything, ever: - Irresponsible sex? Fix it with a free abortion - Irresponsible diet? Fix it with free healthcare - Irresponsible drug use? Fix it with free rehab - Committed a crime? Must be a mental issue, fix it with free mental healthcare. The liberal mindset is to fix every societal issue with free services, free money, free _____, personal responsibility be darned. Cut off your own arm because you have body integrity identity disorder? The gov't should pay for a prosthetic and therapy!
- lucideer 9y agoI don't see anyone in that article who holds the views you describe. There aren't even any opinions mentioned in the article, liberal or otherwise. Did you share the wrong link? It's an article about criminals trying to game the system in court: the disingenuous insanity plea has been a feature of Hollywood court dramas and other movies forever. There's nothing new here. Here is a nice quote from the article though: > “This is such a fraught area, and it’s prone to hype and overstatement,”
- doesnt_know 9y agoI think you ruined your point at the end there by implying this attitude is unique to those that are religious. It definitely isn't and the "fuck poor" sentiment runs deep throughout every part of western culture.
- openasocket 9y agoThe sentiment is hardly unique to western culture either. Off the top of my head the Hindu Caste System seems like a pretty good example of a system that excuses the mistreatment of the poor.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- newfoundglory 9y agoI think the difference is that the caste system relies on the poor being there, it doesn't imagine that they should all disappear.
- aryehof 9y agoThroughout "western culture"? No, I contend that such a sentiment is particularly prevalent in the USA. Countries in Europe, Canada and Australia among others, do not share such a view.
- felipelemos 9y agoJust to remember that we have a whole lot of countries in America that are not any of those you cited, and they all share western culture too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lisper 9y agoYes, that's true. But there really is a shocking percentage of Americans who really do believe that no long term thinking is needed because the Second Coming is imminent.