3 ms·
It is illegal, yes, but the reality is that it's not enforced. The letter of the law is irrelevant -- the law is what the police enforce. Certainly, there is n
by munificent 9y ago
It is illegal, yes, but the reality is that it's not enforced. The letter of the law is irrelevant -- the law is what the police enforce.
Certainly, there is no practical way to enforce not littering. Are you going to have undercover cops patrolling around waiting for someone to drop something on the ground?
I live in a formerly-quiet neighborhood in Seattle. When my kids were 4 and 6, I had to teach them what a used needle looks like and to never ever touch one because trash like that started showing up on our street corner near parked RVs.
1. There are definitely some people living in vehicles that are not part of the drug trade as consumers and producers, and I'm very sympathetic to their plight, and supportive of them living in their vehicles if that's all they can afford.
2. There are definitely people living in vehicles that are drug addicts. I'm sympathetic to their plight, but it doesn't seem like letting them live without treatment is good for them or the surrounding community. This is a profoundly hard problem — how as a society do we deal with people whose addiction prevents them from making good life choices and upholding the social contract? How much agency should someone have when they use that agency to harm themselves and others?
3. There are definitely people living in vehicles that are drug producers and sellers. They should go to jail.
People who have strong opinions on this seem to believe only one of those categories exists, and then imagine solutions that deny the existence of the others. That's not practical. My experience from my street is that there are all three kinds, though unfortunately not many in the first group.
I care about the rights and life of people in these dire straits, but I also care about my own rights and those of my family. I'd like my children to be able to play in the yard without worrying about them rolling onto a dirty needle. I'd like my wife to be able to garden without finding trash and sewage in the bushes.
Even if someone is 100% supportive of letting people experiencing homelessness get by however they can, I hope they understand that it's not biologically safe for humans to live in areas without sewage and trash infrastructure. That's how you get cholera, hepatitis, etc.
- brudgers 9y agoThe social contract is between the individuals (collectively) and the sovereign. Invoking the social contract is contrary to any complaint about non-enforcement because signing on means the sovereign can do whatever is necessary to keep the peace. In exchange, the individual agrees to go along with everything except the loss of their own life.
- munificent 9y agoSorry, maybe "social contract" isn't the right term. I just meant the work any person is expected to do in order to be a good citizen and a good neighbor.
- brudgers 9y agoGood or bad citizenship seems orthogonal to the situation described...though political rhetoric over the last forty years has encouraged people to identify as tax payers and consumers rather than citizens and to conflate shopping with civic participation. On the other hand, survival is rarely genteel.
- tensor_rank_0 9y ago> the sovereign can do whatever is necessary to keep the peace. In exchange, the individual agrees to go along with everything except the loss of their own life. wow, how widely is this belief held? is there a name for it?
- brudgers 9y agoThe Social Contract is an idea originating in the political philosophy of Thomas Hobbs. Leviathan in particular. Leviathan is in the public domain: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_(Hobbes_book)#External_links https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_(Hobbes_book)#Extern...
- tensor_rank_0 9y agoI took a quick glance, many of Hobbes' principle values do not seem to be widely held today.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIt's the Hobbesian view of the social contract, which is often contrasted with the Lockean view of the same subject which underpins both the US system in particular and arguably Western liberal democracy more generally. It's not a particularly popular model, even though it was influential in developing views that remain popular today.