4 ms·
Rights are mainly seen in the US as negative rights. The Bill of Rights Constitutional amendments are all proscriptions on government behavior. A right to life
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Rights are mainly seen in the US as negative rights. The Bill of Rights Constitutional amendments are all proscriptions on government behavior. A right to life means that I must not kill you. If however, you are choking to death, there is no obligation for me to help you.
I think negative rights are the way to go. Once you start having positive rights, then you place obligations on others which ultimately require force or the threat of force to make people do something. In addition, positive rights has a tendency to keep on growing - for example a right to Internet access. The downside of that is that rights then do not become something that is stable across time and space but just a synonym for something someone arbitrarily decided to call a right.
- burkaman 9y agoOk, so the right to housing would mean the government can't deprive you of a home.
- thesimon 9y ago>If however, you are choking to death, there is no obligation for me to help you. TIL: There is no concept of "Duty to rescue" in most Common Law countries such as the US. Seems really strange. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_to_rescue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_to_rescue)
- masonic 9y agoRights are mainly seen in the US as negative rights. What you call "negative rights" I would call "limiting government's powers to those specifically granted it by Constitution or by law.".
- kevin_thibedeau 9y ago> The Bill of Rights Constitutional amendments are all proscriptions on government behavior. Which the government conveniently forgets.
- abritinthebay 9y agoI'd argue that it's the citizens who forget (often thinking that the Bill of Rights Constitutional amendments are positive rights). The government is quite aware - and works within the framework established for it. It's up to us as citizens to challenge it (or remove it) if we feel it isn't abiding by the rules. Sadly, most of the populace can't even be bothered to vote, let alone stay engaged on these issues.
- jdoliner 9y agoOne of the many pitfalls you run into when the institution enforcing your rights and the institution being enforced against happen to be one and the same.
- stretchwithme 9y agoI agree. It is the best approach. Your right to not be killed doesn't require that I supply you with anything, except protection of your rights from those that would violate them. I see rights as those things that most people would not give up in order to have their rights protected by society. The right not to be hit for no reason is valued by most people. But having a right to hit anybody you want is not more highly valued by most people, as it also means you will be hit a lot. That doesn't mean people shouldn't help each other or accept help or participate in mutual aid associations. But such voluntary aid has CONDITIONS. You have to be a decent person to get it. A right to help doesn't require good behavior. And compulsory help is not practical either. Eventually, costs of providing it rise until quality has to be sacrificed and options have to be limited and often the opportunity cost of the free help is greater than the cost of paying for it yourself.
- appleflaxen 9y ago> I see rights as those things that most people would not give up in order to have their rights protected by society. Do you see this as the same as the golden rule?
- eganist 9y ago> If however, you are choking to death, there is no obligation for me to help you. Mandatory reporting laws throw a crimp in this logic--for various sorts of crimes, some or all people may be obligated to report these crimes depending on state/federal laws as well as their profession. At least 18 states have no restrictions on profession, meaning anyone suspecting crimes such as child abuse is obligated to report. https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubPDFs/manda.pdf#Page=1&view=Fit https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubPDFs/manda.pdf#Page=1&view=F... Enforceability isn't something I'd know. Just making a point that we have plenty of cases where people are obligated to go out of their way to save someone else's life.