3 ms·
The thing that really bothers me is future-dated copyrights. For example, buying a textbook and the copyright date on the title page is 2012. How is that not il
by Alex3917 16y ago
The thing that really bothers me is future-dated copyrights. For example, buying a textbook and the copyright date on the title page is 2012. How is that not illegal?
edit: If I were just to scan them and host them all online would I be doing anything that could be considered infringement? Because as I read it, what they are saying is that this textbook is considered public domain for another two years.
- patio11 16y agoYour reading is incorrect. In the United States (and most other signatories to the international copyright treaty whose name escapes me at 1 AM), copyright attaches automatically to any creative expression. Works in general default to copyright, not to the public domain. The copyright notice, symbol, and date are advisory only, not magical runes with exotic legal effects. (Registration of copyrights gives you extra bonuses, but it isn't necessary to invoke copyright protection.) Yes, taking them and hosting them would be infringement. So would republishing this comment, which has no date or copyright symbol but is copyrighted by virtue of existing. The usual rules about fair comment, etc, apply, and courts would hold that I've certainly given PG et al implied license to retain and display the comment as a consequence of writing it here. I am not a lawyer, but I'm not wrong, either.
- Alex3917 16y agoI realize that the copyright date is only advisory, but if you're future-dating your work then what should that be seen as advising? Since future-dating your work is essentially stealing from the public domain, I think that any future-dated works should be legally seen as advising that anyone is free to copy and redistribute that work until the future date. That seems like fair compensation to me.
- randallsquared 16y agoSince future-dating your work is essentially stealing from the public domain [...] I think you're under the impression that copyrights expire at some point, which isn't really the case any more in the US for corporate-owned copyrights, right?
- Alex3917 16y agoRegardless, when I purchase a textbook I am buying the right to copy and redistribute that textbook after X date. By future-dating the work the publisher is taking away something that I have paid for, which seems like it shouldn't be legal.
- randallsquared 16y agoSince Congress can and has retroactively changed the length of copyright repeatedly, I don't think that there's any presumption that you are buying a right to copy after a given time, or at all. Since I'm against copyright in the first place, this argument about textbook copyright is rather academic to me. So to speak.
- dctoedt 16y ago> the international copyright treaty whose name escapes me You're probably thinking of the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention_for_the_Protection_of_Literary_and_Artistic_Works http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention_for_the_Protec...