4 ms·
Super-summary: companies are getting sued for putting expired patent numbers on their products. Previously, for a maximum of $500; last december, a ruling allo
by Groxx 16y ago
Super-summary: companies are getting sued for putting expired patent numbers on their products. Previously, for a maximum of $500; last december, a ruling allowed up to $500 per offense (with potential(?) speculation that this implies per individual item produced). And for some reason this includes retailers, not just producers, though I don't understand how.
I'll count this a good thing, though $500 per item on the shelf is excessive. As long as those patent numbers are on a product, people won't be as likely to do anything similar for fear of patent violation.
If the retailers are also held accountable, I feel sorry for them. That's a redonkulous amount of fact-checking they'd have to do, especially since some patent numbers are inside the items, on the motor housing.
- Qz 16y agoWhere did it say retailers were responsible also?
- rjett 16y agoI assumed since Walmart stores was named as a defendant that other retailers could be named as well. As far as I know, Walmart doesn't do any manufacturing, even with their Great Value brand (citation needed).
- sophacles 16y agoWhat would be most reasonable is "brand owner". Not manufacturer or retailer (unless they are the same as brand owner). The owner of the brand is the one who sends the designs for manufacture, including the patent number labels. The manufacturer just executes on that.
- Groxx 16y ago>Raymond E. Stauffer was shopping at a New Jersey mall when he noticed something peculiar about the bow ties on display at Brooks Brothers: They were labeled with old patent numbers. Mr. Stauffer, who calls himself a "sharp-dressed man," also happens to be a patent lawyer. He sued Brooks Brothers Inc. in federal court, claiming it broke the law by marking its adjustable bow ties with patents that expired in the 1950s. He figured the retailer would have to pay a nominal amount for violating a law that bars companies from marking products with erroneous patent numbers. Opening paragraphs, among mentioning other retailers elsewhere (though those seemed to be referring to those retailers' own products).
- Qz 16y agoI think its just a misleading choice of words. Article writers will often substitute a descriptive word for a proper name to avoid being overly repetitive - "the retailer" was probably just a reference to Brooks Brothers.
- Groxx 16y agoMost definitely a possibility. I thought it seemed a bit strange, in any case.
- DougBTX 16y agoAs long as those patent numbers are on a product, people won't be as likely to do anything similar for fear of patent violation. I don't buy that. At the very least you'll want to look up the title of the patent before getting scared off, which is an easy google request. And those patent documents all have issuing dates - if the data is 50 years ago, why worry? What really gets me about the article are the claims about misleading customers. Unless I'm mistaken, customers don't care about patents. The numbers are only there so that if there is an infringement case, the patent owners can get more cash. The chilling effects of patents still stand, as you can never know if some product you think you just invented is covered, even a little bit, by some obscure patent. And they are all obscure, because it triples your damages if there is evidence you've read the relevant patents. But now I'm just ranting. At least these guys have a product to write the patent number on.
- notahacker 16y agoAnyone seriously considering "doing something similar" is going to look into exactly what the patent covers, where, and for how long. There are plenty of databases to search for that information and plenty of professionals to help them do so. At worst, an expired patent might be considered inaccurate advertising that fools a few consumers into thinking a product won't have any generic alternatives available. Not sure it's a $500 per violation level of misleading though... I'm not really sure how anyone other than the lawyers attempting to extort money (and representing only themselves) benefits in any way. The companies that suffer the most will be those that have genuinely tried to protect innovative product designs they've actually implemented, rather than those with secret arsenals of vague and broad business process patents that are mainly conceived as an excuse to sue the successful.