3 ms·
I learn great many things in this forum. If you find my comment below as an effort of trolling, it is not. I wanted to ask this question every time I see this i
by elifive 9y ago
I learn great many things in this forum. If you find my comment below as an effort of trolling, it is not. I wanted to ask this question every time I see this idea of
> how vaccines and tech are decreasing population.
If it is statistically and empirically true, then it probably is true.If people smarter than me by any measure agree with it, then it probably is true after,all.
That said:
I don't doubt that, it works in a first world nation.
But third world , at least India is a different thing, people like to have two kids around here, because it looks whole some. It doesn't matter what the financial situation is , people like to have at least two kids in India(I don't have any metric for it,just a casual observation).
What if people see their kids don't die out of diseases and could take food ,education,electricity,clean water and clean air and a good public transport for granted and now want to make more babies?
The decrease of population if you pump these resources seems counter intuitive to me.
I am not suggesting if Bill Gates should pull out of Africa, I am just not getting the logic here.
- te_chris 9y agoI don't have stats for this, but I don't think it's families with 2 kids that are causing a population explosion. That's literally just an even replacement for the parents (assuming 2 people who don't remarry before death).
- brownbat 9y agoHans Rosling tackles that question better than anyone in What Stops Population Growth: https://youtu.be/ZnexjTCBksw https://youtu.be/ZnexjTCBksw His first TED talk on the best data you've ever seen is also worth watching. It's an important question, but our understanding of what causes population spikes, and how people respond to improved wealth and health in a country, can make us a little more optimistic.
- pjc50 9y agoIt definitely works that way in poor countries; the "poster child" is right next to India in Bangladesh: https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21565617-bangladesh-has-dysfunctional-politics-and-stunted-private-sector-yet-it-has-been-surprisingly https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21565617-bangladesh-... It turns out that educated women with more other options almost always want to have fewer children. This should not be surprising; they don't call childbirth "labour" for nothing.