6 ms·
From your second article: > There is some evidence that the bivalent and quadrivalent vaccines already provide some protection against additional strains of HP
by nostrademons 9y ago
From your second article:
> There is some evidence that the bivalent and quadrivalent vaccines already provide some protection against additional strains of HPV. A recent paper in Clinical and Vaccine Immunology reporting on the clinical trial for Cervarix reported that the vaccine is more than 96 percent effective against disease associated with strains 16 and 18, and more than 50 percent effective against diseases associated with any HPV strain.
There are network effects in disease transmission. In order to catch a disease, not only do you have to be susceptible, but you have to catch it from someone. If you cut the risk of contracting HPV by 90%, then not only has the chance of a vaccinated person contracting the disease gone down by 90%, but the chance that an unvaccinated person will come in contact with a carrier goes down by 90%. Eliminate all the most prevalent strains and provide some protection against the remainder, and you can cut the virus's ability to replicate itself below the threshold needed to sustain itself in the population. Same reason that anti-vaxxers can get away without vaccinating their kids for measles as long as they don't come in contact with too many other unvaccinated people.
- masonic 9y ago(Cervarix) is more than 96 percent effective against disease associated with strains 16 and 18 ... but those are the two strains that Cervarix is specifically designed to prevent against! In other words, that's admitting to a 4% failure rate where not only did the HPV infections occur despite those subjects being vaccinated, but they proceeded to cause disease (aside from the HPV presence itself).
- chris_wot 9y agoNo, it didn’t cause the disease.
- tedsanders 9y agoI assumed the tetravalent vaccine only worked against the four named strains. If it's semi-effective against all strains, then I see how eradication is possible. Thank you for the clarification. Edit: Wait, the article does not say the vaccine is semi-effective against all strains. It says the vaccine is semi-effective against cervical cancer caused by all strains. My confusion is not removed.
- ejstronge 9y agoI'm not clear on the distinction that you're drawing - cervical cancer is almost always caused by HPV. What were you alluding to?
- nostrademons 9y agoI would assume that the vaccine couldn't be semi-effective against cervical cancer caused by all strains without it being effective against all strains, since your first link says 95%+ of cervical cancer is caused by HPV and there's no known mechanism for the vaccine to act directly against cervical cancer without first acting against the HPV virus.
- tedsanders 9y agoI apologize for the ambiguity of my prior comment. To illustrate what I'm thinking: Suppose cervical cancer is caused by two strains, 1 and 2, which are equally present in the population. A vaccine works 100% against strain 1 and 0% against strain 2. That vaccine is 50% effective against all strains causing cancer, despite having 0 power to eradicate strain 2. Therefore, it's not clear to me that being 'semi-effective against all strains' implies 'semi-effective against each strain.' I am now looking for sources that say Gardasil is semi-effective against each strain of HPV. Edit: Reading this source[1] I see that Gardasil protects against strains 31/33/45/51 (grouped) with 33%-51% effectiveness. Still can't find conclusive evidence that Gardasil protects against each strain. [1] http://cvi.asm.org/content/early/2015/01/29/CVI.00591-14.full.pdf+html http://cvi.asm.org/content/early/2015/01/29/CVI.00591-14.ful...
- nostrademons 9y agoI would assume that the context ("already provide some protection against additional strains of HPV") implies that it provides additional protection against additional, individual strains, but will grant that the wording doesn't conclusively say that and alternate interpretations are possible.
- 9y ago