6 ms·
> We all knew the $10 a month plan was not going to be profitably by itself. How is this kind of "growth hack" not simply dumping[1]? The only new development
by AlexandrB 9y ago
> We all knew the $10 a month plan was not going to be profitably by itself.
How is this kind of "growth hack" not simply dumping[1]? The only new development here is that dumping is no longer limited to large companies with large war chests thanks to the availability of venture capital.
The more interesting question is can healthy, truly profitable technology companies develop in an environment where they have to compete with startups that are ready and willing to undercut them by losing tons of investor money. I don't think the current status quo is good for the long term health of the valley.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy)
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> How is this kind of "growth hack" not simply dumping[1]? "Dumping" is bad because it harms unsubsidized competitors. (It also pits foreign governments against private companies.) I fail to see who MoviePass hurt except its own investors. > Can healthy, truly profitable technology companies develop in an environment where they have to compete with startups that are ready and willing to undercut them by losing tons of investor money Lyft seems to be doing fine.
- fleitz 9y agoAlso Facebook seems to be doing well against Twitter, though I've heard Twitter is also finally making money.
- Jasper_ 9y ago> I fail to see who MoviePass hurt except its own investors. Games on the iOS App Store are generally free (or 99 cents). It is not profitable to recoup your costs by selling the product, because consumers will not pay for an app that costs more money than $1. In order to sustain this environment, the industry has moved to selling data, ads, and other sort of nonsense. Let's suggest that MoviePass successfully "disrupts" the industry and then gets bought out or dies. What happens if this disruption permanently causes admissions revenue to go down, because consumers expect $10, and as such, movies to be substantially more unprofitable to make? This sort of long-term "environmental impact" never seems to come up as long as we can pile more ads and tracking on top to make up the difference in unreasonable business models.
- twostorytower 9y agoThey already got bought by Helios & Matheson: http://variety.com/2017/film/news/moviepass-1202527956/ http://variety.com/2017/film/news/moviepass-1202527956/
- tyfon 9y ago> because consumers will not pay for an app that costs more money than $1 I'm quite the opposite. If a game on the play store is low priced/free and contain the "in-app"-purchases label I run far away. It's a bit sad as some use this method as a demo with only a "full game" unlock in-app and I won't know. But I've been burned by that in the past, i.e. buy a full version without adds of a game and having the "full version" destroyed by adds a year later. I'm generally extremely wary of buying anything on the play store now and have resorted to only using mail, signal, firefox with ad-block and my public transportation ticket app.. And the PS4 apps
- mcintyre1994 9y agoNot sure if Play Store has the same thing, but the App Store lets you expand the IAPs if you scroll down, so you can see whether it's just a full game unlock or garbage ingame currencies.
- hueving 9y agoThe consumers that bought expensive games aren't the same ones that expect to pay 0.99$ for a game so the comparison doesn't really apply. In particular, people still pay $50 for a game.
- wolco 9y agoI paid more than amount in 80s for a nintendo game as I do now for that $50 game.
- ForHackernews 9y ago> as such, movies to be substantially more unprofitable to make? Then...there will be fewer and cheaper movies made, unless and until consumer demand makes it profitable to produce more again. This is like market economics 101, people.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>"Dumping" is bad because it harms unsubsidized competitors. (It also pits foreign governments against private companies.) I fail to see who MoviePass hurt except its own investors. Everyone who might have started a competing company but did the math to figure out they would have to charge more? >Lyft seems to be doing fine. Hasn't Lyft been spending billions of dollars without posting a profit just like Uber?
- Bartweiss 9y ago> might have started a competing company Point well taken, but in the case of MoviePass I'm not sure this is a bad thing? I can see how it's a long-term harm if a value-adding startup is shut out by a competitor which relies on burning investor money. But I really can't work out what value-added startup MoviePass could be displacing; effectively the only benefit for consumers is the artificially low pricing. It seems like "VC money pit" is the entire story for this one.
- rco8786 9y ago> Lyft seems to be doing fine By what measure? They have hundreds of millions in investor money and afaik aren’t turning any profit?
- fleitz 9y agoThey are only actually losing investor's money if the stock price drops...
- 013a 9y agoI don't think the environment will stay like this for long. Investors in MoviePass will likely not make their money back. Or maybe they'll break even on a sale of assets to some major theater chain, if everyone involved is smart. Afterward, future investors in companies like this will use MoviePass as another example for the fact the times when you could form a business mostly based on collecting user data is over. The stakes have changed, the goalposts have moved; Google/Facebook sized ingestion of user data is still very profitable, but now startups have to compete with that. So MoviePass knows which movies I go see and where I go before and after... Google knows where I am literally all the time. They really should have started from day 1 trying to play ball with the theater chains. Theaters always made most of their money on concessions; incentivize upsells into that and get subsidies on ticket prices from the chains. Instead, they burned every bridge with the theaters they could have hoped to make. They'll pay for it.
- thevardanian 9y agoPeople going to theaters is on the decline. If MoviePass reverses that trend they will have shown their value. I'm going to wager they're at a tipping point.
- AJ007 9y agoBut Moviepass’s investors won’t be the ones walking away with anything of value. The big theater chains & Disney were just delivered a product market fit for free. Better than free, because all of the Moviepass money went to them.
- sixothree 9y agoI received a MoviePass as a Christmas give. I've learned a few things. 1. I hadn't been to my local theaters in a long time. 2. I was surprised just how convenient it had become now that nobody else is visiting. 3. I am thoroughly enjoying this movie subscription service model combined with the lack of crowds at theaters.
- sharkweek 9y ago
- sdenton4 9y agoMy guess is that the plan was or is to demonstrate that a subscription model can fill mostly empty theatres, while providing theaters with more stable revenue than they currently experience. From there, the question is what to price the subscription at. It could be that revenue sharing on $10/mo with a couple added restrictions (No opening weekends) will provide theatres with more than they're currently making.