3 ms·
Ok, so has anyone done blind testing of this? Because "forensic science" is already full of snake oil and deliberately ignored bad science. Is this any differen
by olliej 9y ago
Ok, so has anyone done blind testing of this? Because "forensic science" is already full of snake oil and deliberately ignored bad science. Is this any different? He's one of the "few experts", is that because this science is new? or is it because it's not science?
- pilom 9y agoThe stats I've seen are somewhere around 85% of right handed people will tie a granny-knot one way and ~85% of left handed people will tie it the other way (assuming you know where they were standing, i.e. what their starting orientation was, when they tied it). People who tie correct square knots are more likely to know about knots in general and are thus less likely to care about starting orientation so the correlation is less strong but still more than 50/50. WRT the "knot only a butcher would know," I'm going to assume it was the surgeons knot because it is in a picture in the article and could actually be used correctly by both a butcher and binding a person. Only butchers and surgeons use that knot because it is used in cases when the rope/thread is extremely slippery as it makes it easier to keep the knot tight in those cases. No one else uses it though because it can come undone easier than a basic square knot if unbalanced as it is in the picture. So I believe that it could be an indicator that the perpetrator was the butcher. Overall, I'd say less good than DNA evidence, better than phrenology.
- hajile 9y agoI'm fairly knowledgeable about knots and rope (I used to know almost every knot in the Ashley book of knots and can still tie a couple hundred from memory). There may be some knowledge to gain from a knot, but hardly what is presented. Most people know an overhand, basic bow, reef/granny, slip knot, and half-hitch. They may cobble together a more advanced knot on accident, but that hardly proves experience. The use of climbing, fishing, or rescue knots could indicate something, but that's about the extent without going into pure guesswork. In the butcher example, the easiest explanation is that the knot came untied, so they added a couple extra wraps to keep it together and probably had no idea it was a different knot used in a particular field. Much more useful knowledge could be gained by the kind of rope, rope age, and wear patterns.
- LargeWu 9y agoNobody claimed it was science; it's just advanced pattern matching. I think it's very doubtful somebody would be convicted on the basis of this analysis alone. It seems like it's more useful as an investigative tool rather than something you can present as evidence in a trial.
- EggsOnToast 9y agoHe may not have claimed it, but when you stand in front of a jury and say something to the extent of "I'm an expert in knot analysis. This is the analytic system I employed to reach this particular conclusion" the implication to a jury of laymen is that you've employed a scientific method of some sort.
- wolfgke 9y ago> He may not have claimed it, but when you stand in front of a jury and say something to the extent of "I'm an expert in knot analysis. This is the analytic system I employed to reach this particular conclusion" the implication to a jury of laymen is that you've employed a scientific method of some sort. This is rather an argument against a jury of laymen.
- lukev 9y agoAnd yet that is what is mandated in the constitution.
- wolfgke 9y ago> And yet that is what is mandated in the constitution. I don't live in the USA and am not US citizen - many HN readers don't either :-)
- EggsOnToast 9y agoIt can be used as an argument against both. But that's irrelevant to a discussion about what the presentation of this evidence says to a jury.