3 ms·
I would argue that they're not necessarily exploiting "non-rich" as much as they're exploiting the poor. The people in power do everything they can to keep wag
by Sohcahtoa82 9y ago
I would argue that they're not necessarily exploiting "non-rich" as much as they're exploiting the poor.
The people in power do everything they can to keep wages down. Minimum wage doesn't keep up with inflation. Pensions went away in favor of the 401(k). Unions are losing their power. A manufacturing job used to buy you a house, car, and help you raise your 2.5 children. Now, it barely gets you an apartment and a bus pass.
But the real exploitation is how the rich have convinced the poor that it's not their fault. "It's those damn, dirty Mexicans stealing jobs!" Or telling them "Hey, we'll give you a pay raise if you give us some tax relief!" or that if they want the house, they need to get a real job or something like that. Manufacturing jobs are non-skilled and don't deserve anything over minimum wage!
Of course, it's all lies, but some people eat that shit up like candy. That's the exploitation. They're fucking the poor and successfully directing the blame somewhere else.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> A manufacturing job used to buy you a house, car, and help you raise your 2.5 children. There was maybe a very brief historical moment when that was true, but I don't think it was ever the case; industrial capitalism has always been strongly grounded in the economic insecurity of the working class.
- ancap 9y ago>The people in power do everything they can to keep wages down. Wages are set by the market through supply and demand
- mjevans 9y agoSo infect those poor people with memes that encourage having tons of kids so that there's a lot more poor people to compete for less and less jobs (as automation moves the means of production to family owned land / equity holdings)?
- sokoloff 9y agoI'm not convinced that memes are the primary force driving the inverse relationship between wealth/income and birthrate.
- Sohcahtoa82 9y agoIn white collar work, sure. But the low-skill, minimum wage jobs? No. Those wages are effectively set by the government. Every time an employer hires someone at minimum wage, they're really saying "I would pay you less if I legally could." And that's where the rich are making sure minimum wage stays low.
- ancap 9y agoFew things hurt the poor, in particular unskilled minorities, like minimum wage. Those people are effectively outlawed from the labor market because their marginal productivity doesn't make the cut. This is why there is often exceptions in minimum wage laws when it comes to hiring youth and the disabled. This is also why you've seen labor unions lobbying for a $15/hr minimum wage, with exemptions for those in the union.
- Sohcahtoa82 9y ago> Few things hurt the poor, in particular unskilled minorities, like minimum wage. Those people are effectively outlawed from the labor market because their marginal productivity doesn't make the cut. Hogwash. Are you sincerely arguing that an hour of work doesn't produce $9-15 (or whatever the minimum wage is, plus other overhead) of revenue for the company they work for?
- sokoloff 9y agoThe relevant hurdle for an hour of labor is not the marginal revenue but rather the contribution margin (marginal revenue minus [non-labor] variable costs) of that hour.
- ancap 9y agoI'm not sure what's so hard to believe about that. It's not even a controversial statement. Are you suggesting that if labor were cheaper the market would not consume more of it?
- 9y ago
- malvosenior 9y ago> Manufacturing jobs are non-skilled and don't deserve anything over minimum wage! Why is that a lie? If literally anyone can do the job and the potential supply for that job includes nearly everyone in the labor market, why would we expect that role to pay more than the bare minimum? At the end of the day people get paid as much as it would cost to replace them.
- Sohcahtoa82 9y agoKeep in mind the context of another sentence earlier in my post: > A manufacturing job used to buy you a house, car, and help you raise your 2.5 children. Now, it barely gets you an apartment and a bus pass. The message was more about the lower buying power of a manufacturing job and minimum wage of today versus a few decades ago.
- malvosenior 9y agoThat a manufacturing job used to provide a middle class lifestyle was an anomaly based on the US being in an extraordinary position post two World Wars that devastated the rest of the globe and enriched this country. Globalization has normalized labor rates to what they’re really worth. The twentieth century consumerist lifestyle is definitely not sustainable when given to every living human on earth.