5 ms·
Is it time to take the Hyperloop seriously? No
- curtis 9y agoI don't think we're obligated to take Hyperloop seriously until there is a large-scale demonstration system up and running. On the other hand, I don't think we can fully discount it as long as so many people (with funding!) are actively working on it.
- barnabes 9y agoRight. In addition to that, I was simply going to write "make it not fail". In the plane example, what the author doesn't mention is that there are many mechanical failures, or human errors on a plane that lead to, well, death of 100% of its passengers. Yet we still fly. So in this respect I see the Hyperloop as being very similar to air travel: make it not fail.
- lisper 9y ago> there are many mechanical failures, or human errors on a plane that lead to, well, death of 100% of its passengers That's true, but there are very few failures that lead the entire system to grind to a halt.
- tdb7893 9y agoWeather creates a whole mess with tons of missed connections and cancelled flights that can take up a a couple days to sort out. This means that air travel in entire states grinds to a halt a couple of times each year.
- lisper 9y agoFair enough, but in the meantime passengers are not trapped aboard airplanes (which are considerably more comfortable than hyperloop pods). On a few rare occasions passengers have been trapped on airplanes for several hours. This was considered unacceptable and led to major changes in policy.
- eridius 9y agoPassengers still get trapped for hours on airplanes sitting on tarmacs. I feel like there's a couple of stories about that per year, and that's just what gets reported in the media.
- lisper 9y agoNo, they don't, not any more. https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/tarmac-delays-airline-passenger-rights-33011.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/tarmac-delays-airlin... Even back in the day when it did happen, it was because of policy, not physical constraints.
- ricardobeat 9y agoThree, or two, hours still counts as 'trapped for hours'. Airplanes are not comfortable at all, and no hyperloop pods actually exist - that statement makes no sense.
- lisper 9y agoExcept that airplanes are designed to be occupied for hours. In particular, airplanes have bathrooms.
- eridius 9y agoAIUI airplanes just sitting on the tarmac don't have AC (because they're not running their engines).
- lisper 9y agoAIUI? (But this is another good point: a failed hyperloop also won't have A/C. That will be a potentially life-threatening problem in Dubai, where the first hyperloop is likely to be built. Summer temperatures there regularly reach 45C.)
- hndamien 9y agoDeath is a pretty grinding halt for me.
- curtis 9y agoI'm skeptical whether Hyperloop as described in Musk's original paper is practical. On the other hand, I think it's possible that some variant which is clearly Hyperloop-inspired might actually be feasible. You can probably make the case that we're already in Hyperloop-inspired territory, since as far as I can tell everyone working on Hyperloop has dispensed with air-bearings and moved to maglev for levitation.
- lisper 9y agoYes, but it's still in an evacuated metal tube. That's a severe constraint. BTW, going to maglev completely blows the original economic model out of the water. The whole point of the original hyperloop was that the track was going to be cheap because it was just a welded metal tube. Now it's a welded metal tube with a maglev track inside. That's no longer cheap. In fact, it's a reinvention of maglev in a way that makes it even more expensive. If maglev wasn't economically viable before you put it in a tube (and it wasn't) it won't be economically viable after.
- gnode 9y agoI don't see any reason why using maglev means the track has to be anything clever. There are methods where the vehicle contains the only active part, and the track can simply be a metal strip, such as servo-levitation (varying the strength of an electromagnet on board the vehicle with feedback), induced current levitation, or by using a rotating set of fixed magnets.
- lisper 9y agoI must confess I'm not up on the details of maglev technology (which is why it's not central to my argument). I have to wonder, though, if maglev is so cheap and easy why hasn't it been deployed more already?
- gnode 9y agoWhile the cost of passive maglev track isn't huge, conventional rail networks which you'd be competing with already exist, so typically would only be justifiable for new networks. Safety is another large concern; it's easy to make a fail-deadly maglev train. While maglev trains are the fastest, safety keeps them an emerging technology.
- stcredzero 9y agoThe fundamental problem is that the hyperloop track is a cascading single point of failure. So, pretty much like highway-speed transit on highways. One breakdown, and huge stretches of highway slow to a crawl or to a halt. The same goes for the US air travel system, except it takes the weather disruption of a major hub to get the cascading failures.
- wellboy 9y agoTrains?
- KnightOfWords 9y agoTrains fail more gracefully than hyperloop - they have enough room to stand up in, toilets and exits.
- walrus01 9y agoon a highway, if you get stuck in traffic moving 0 km/h or your vehicle's energy/propulsion system fails utterly, there is no risk of suffocating to death.
- blackrock 9y agoTechnically, I think the Hyperloop can work. Economically, to make it profitable, then I am not certain it can work in the United States. The Hyperloop is running in a vacuum tube. * We have the ability to evacuate air from a tube, to low air pressure levels. * We have the ability to build space craft that can operate in a vacuum. * We have the ability to build a maglev, to propel the pod. * We have the ability to build nuclear power plants, to energize the maglevs. I don't think solar or wind will create enough electricity to meet production usage demands. Given all that, it's now starting to sound like an economical non-starter. The United States just doesn't have enough people to make this work economically. It sounds cheaper to just go with a maglev. And you can get up to 300 to 400 mph if you push it. This is almost comparable to an airplane, but more comfortable. And the volume of people you transport can be a lot higher. And all the Hyperloop plans are regional. One for Houston. One for Chicago. One for Virginia. This means that each location is fiscally responsible for themselves. But for some locations, then there is not enough people to economically sustain it. A national system may work, as it will allow some lines to be profitable, and this will balance out the lines that are not profitable. So the entire national system may eke out an operating profit. And then, there is all the land rights that you have to buy up. Just look at how expensive the California high speed rail project is costing. And all the tunneling and bridging that must be done. And the designs only show two tracks running in parallel, but I think they actually need 3 tracks, in the event one track breaks down. This adds to the costs, but I don't see anyone suggesting this, or even thinking about it. And they need to design contingencies in the event something breaks down. Americans do not like new technology things that kill people. One disaster may kill the entire project. And, what about the science of the sonic boom, as the pod crosses the sound barrier. Given this is propelled through a vacuum tube, at lower air pressure levels, then will a sonic boom be generated? All of this is now starting to sound really expensive. All this research is going to cost a lot of money. No company can really afford that, except maybe Apple. The US government is not interested in footing the R&D bill. Then again, I could be completely wrong. And once again, Elon pulls a rabbit out of a hat, and comes to the rescue.
- wellboy 9y agoYou just completely made things up. All the things you listed amount to 10x less costs than the bullet trains. You can have a look at hyperloop costs.
- zimmen 9y agoIf we would always think about “what could go wrong” and decide whether to go forward based on that we still wouldn’t use fire today.... in order to make something safe we need to make it work first. No guts, no glory.
- xfactor973 9y agoThis may seem stupid but couldn’t you just reverse the stuck pods back to the station the departed from?
- maxerickson 9y agoBe sure to take your Boring Company™ flamethrower on any hyperloop trips that transit an underground section, in case the mole people attack.