7 ms·
Where are all the films about poor Americans?
- polotics 9y agoYes! Personally I'm waiting for Winter's bone 2, where Jennifer Lawrence does sign up for 'stan.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SoylentOrange 9y agoSome recent examples: - Florida project - 3 billboards outside Ebbing Missouri - La La Land (to a degree) - Manchester by the Sea - Straight Outta Compton - Creed 2015 and more recent, set in the USA, nominated for awards at Oscars, protagonist is poor
- mdpye 9y ago"Protagonist is poor" doesn't come close to what they are advocating. From the article: Take The Same Kind of Different As Me, a movie that presents itself as being about a homeless black man, but is most interested in a rich white couple and the way their volunteerism at a soup kitchen saves their marriage, and their souls. The protagonist being a caricature of a poor person doesn't make the film an insightful or interesting examination of poverty. Or even about poverty. That takes much more. It's more or a challenge, more of a risk, and when done well (see Florida Project) a much greater potential reward.
- CoolGuySteve 9y agoI, Tonya as well. The plot is mainly driven by classism against Tonya Harding. It seems poverty actually had a pretty solid representation at the Oscars this year.
- thirdsun 9y agoI'd like to add American Honey: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3721936/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3721936/
- dluan 9y agoLast year's Palme dOr at Cannes was the British film I, Daniel Blake. It was a fantastic gut punch for how even well-intentioned technology is leaving behind parts of society. My partner and I had a very heated 2 hour discussion after watching it.
- ben_jones 9y agoHow much commercially successful technology is well intentioned? Does Google's philanthropy make up for its advertising? Facebook's? Is the iPhone well intentioned? I feel like many big corps do some good as an offset to their mostly bad, with a net negative gain.
- dluan 9y agoWatch the film I, Daniel Blake, because my comment is kind of dependent on that. The movie does such a good job portraying how change is inevitable. From an American pov, I've always admired how the UK has stuff like Gov.uk, a real at-the-forefront use of technology to make government more transparent and efficient, not to mention cool. It has always seemed functional and user-oriented. And, it's lightyears ahead of anything we have in the US to centralize or standardize basic stuff like paper forms. But then in the movie, you see a guy that you probably know try to run a mouse up a computer screen to complete an unemployment form, by physically placing the mouse on the screen. And then get frustrated when he's not allowed help, but then asks 3 different young people walking by to help him navigate the form, before the form times out and he loses all his data. Like, even if the developers and designers of the website tried with all their effort to make their page accessible and even more user friendly, what can be done? The enemy isn't the government for trying to modernize, and it's not poor people who may or may not have gotten stuck in time for whatever reason. The enemy is just change, where you don't realize these stories exist. So to bring it back to the OP - there is a real value in seeing and hearing these stories.
- ben_jones 9y agoCould the problem be the UX? Would a touch interface have been a solution? The screen is divided into four contrasting squares, tap the one that describes what you are trying to do. Sign your name with your finger, etc. I don't think we should caste problems into a grey zone that nobody is responsible for (change). I think we should approach problems from different angles until we find a solution.
- rusk 9y agoThough not a film, Breaking Bad has I think been exemplary in its treatment of this subject. By and large now it’s a topic that sees much more treatment in TV than in movies. “Boyhood” comes to mind.
- saudioger 9y agoExcept most of Boyhood was emotional drivel for people who want to see poor people from a distance and believe everything always turns out fine in the end through hard work. Better watch out, that kid from a broken home might break the rules once, but cool white-savior mom is all he needs (she also managed to free the gardener from wage slavery by giving him a nice pep talk). These are totally real things that happen without any long-term psychological damage worth mentioning.
- rusk 9y agoFair enough, that's one way of looking at it. I was personally more struck by how the boys socioeconomic status forced upon him this unpredictable, drifting lifestyle, without opportunity for putting down roots and develop deep relationships. At the end where he doesn't have a home to go back to. I think that this is viewed predominantly as "kind of normal" in the USA and it's really sad. I don't think it's healthy. No man is an island we need roots and community to make us whole. It's interesting that you should pick on the "poor white saviour mom" when it's clear she is the only strong character in the film besides the boy. She is the only person looking out for his interests, and that too is sad.
- saudioger 9y agoOf course, I understand your take and it's fine... I just grew up with a very similar life situation and feel as though the movie glamorized it to the point where it almost becomes dismissive.
- bdavisx 9y agoI don't think any of the main characters in Breaking Bad lived in poverty; even the secondary ones didn't for the most part. If WW had died w/o becoming a drug kingpin, he would have left his family in poverty, but they didn't live in poverty before.
- allthenews 9y agoWhen did people lose sight of the fact that the primary purpose of film on the silver screen is entertainment? Where do authors like OP get the idea that I want to go to the movies to have politics shoved down my throat? And that there is some kind of obligation for those in charge to forgo their primary motivations of artistic expression and/or profit in the interest of some totally arbitrary target of "representation" of every combination of color, gender, and socioeconomic status? Not to mention, this kind of thinly veiled political grandstanding in the context of film review is almost always cherry picking. There have been plenty of films examining poverty from numerous perspectives. The fact that they are not en vogue now does not speak of some kind of crisis-just like people clamoured over Black Panther as the first positive representation of blacks on screen, while conveniently ignoring decades of black cinema. Outrage is the kind of thing, in my opinion, that is trivial to find, if you look hard enough.
- Leader2light 9y agoCould not agree more! For me, its actually created a backlash to the point I hate everything about diversity. China may win in the end because of purely this issue.
- hadsed 9y agoIt is incredible that you cite artistic expression for your case. It is likely the money making side that makes it difficult to do anything truly new because the predominantly affluent (and yes, white) masses may be skittish about it. You should think about its broader impact on society, because while you have the time and resources to complain about not being entertained enough (incredible in this age of over entertainment!) there are people's stories not being told precisely because you would prefer entertainment to something that challenges your views on what is even entertaining. Not only that, but who says these movies can't be entertaining??
- meri_dian 9y agoBut that's the point he's trying to make. A movie about poverty will probably not be a pleasant movie to watch. So don't shove it down people's throats. Also, the masses are not "predominately affluent", so not sure why you'd choose to describe them like that. The "white" part is unnecessary as well but that's a whole different discussion.
- tdees40 9y agoWendy and Lucy! Also, TV is better: Atlanta and the Wire are great about poverty.
- mrec 9y agoI second the Wendy and Lucy rec. I saw it not long after first reading Scalzi's Being Poor [1] and it really made everything concrete. It's a tough sell in some ways - "girl loses dog, girl finds dog, the end" - but oh-so-worth-it. [1] https://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/ https://whatever.scalzi.com/2005/09/03/being-poor/
- nofinator 9y ago+1 for Atlanta and The Wire as eye-opening depictions of daily life in poverty. But even in TV, these examples are the exception to the rule, sadly. The only other successful show I can think of is Rosanne, which means we're averaging about one a decade.
- meri_dian 9y agoThe premise of this article is wrong. There are many movies about people who aren't rich. The stories may not revolve around their poverty, the poverty may not be an integral part of the story, but the characters are still clearly working class. That said, people don't go to the movies to be lectured about poverty. They go for an escape. Poverty is sad, so there isn't a huge appetite for movies "about poverty".
- unexpected 9y agoI agree with you. Three Billboards was exactly this type of film. Not sure why it was not mentioned in the article.
- dluan 9y agoThree Billboards was not about poverty. It took place in a rural area.
- Bartweiss 9y ago> between 1902 and 2015, of all the films made in the US, only 299 of them were in some way significantly concerned with issues of poverty and homelessness. I think the author is fundamentally wrong about this claim, just like he's wrong about the number of recent movies dealing with poverty. I haven't paid the $35 to read his prior work that he's citing, but nothing in the abstract suggests that it's a comprehensive list of films about poverty. It's simply an analysis of 300 films on the topic he considers particularly important. And, honestly, it fails the laugh test. Of tens of thousands of American films, many made during the Great Depression, many made in the 70s and 80s, a total of 300 deal with poverty? Either 'all' is simply untrue in that claim, or 'significantly concerned' is so narrow that 8 Mile wouldn't count because "it's about rap, not poverty".
- olivermarks 9y agoHollywood has always been all about escapism. In the 1930's - the golden era of film - most of the offerings were aspirational and inspiring, not Grapes of Wrath gloom and doom, which was a lot of people's actual daily experience. There's a reason the mainstream entertainment doesn't make non fantasy films - it's because they are a for profit business and there's no money in it. The recent Churchill film, which was very loosely based on reality and flat out wrong in many areas was all about triumph over adversity etc. There's a good argument to made about fantasy films supposedly depicting actual historical events and people distorting mass reality. That's where my beef is with hollywood...
- stevenwoo 9y agoEnforcement of the Hays Code was responsible for weird trends in the movie industry for a long time, starting in the 1930's - American movie makers actually made successful movies about darker subjects and had more women in leading roles until that point. https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=93301189 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=933011...
- olivermarks 9y agoI'm cynical enough to think any publicity is good publicity, whether it was the 'moral quagmires' of the 30's that resulted in the Hays Code or the current hysteria about predatory sex monsters, which is very reminiscent of the 30's IMO. All about rear ends on seats, whatever it takes to keep the punters buying tickets, popcorn and drinks (the latter two being immensely profitable...)
- jetcata 9y agoRequiem for a Dream is one I can think of. Very dark though.
- jellicle 9y agoMudbound - https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/nov/16/mudbound-review-powerful-tale-from-jim-crow-america-has-real-sinew https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/nov/16/mudbound-review... - is a very good film about poverty, among other things. It doesn't smack you in the face and say "I'M A FILM ABOUT POVERTY", which seems to be the Guardian writer's requirement for inclusion on his list, but it is.
- nafizh 9y ago'The Wire', though not a movie, was implicitly about American poverty in a drug ecosystem, and predominantly black.
- throwawaylyfty 9y agoLadybird won at the oscars. That’s about poor people.
- nereye 9y agoLady Bird was nominated for several awards but did not actually win any Oscars, FWIW. See, e.g., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/90th_Academy_Awards#Notable_nominations_and_winners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/90th_Academy_Awards#Notable_no....
- geodel 9y agoWell poverty is dispersed and does not compete well with identity politics which gives opportunities of political grandstanding to actors/directors and generate profits for studios.
- leg100 9y agoFor me, an entertaining film says something about reality, life, something meaningful, and done so in such a way it makes the most of what you can do with that medium. I wouldn't expect anything other from an entertaining novel, say. Of course the crap coming out of Hollywood does say something about reality, that there is no hope left other than wish fulfilment, to hope that a saviour will come and save us all in the form of a superhero; or that the only hope for yourself is to get rich or for fortune to be bestowed upon you; or something else utterly implausible. But I've heard that story a million times, it's dull.
- Antimachides 9y agoI really liked The Florida Project. I spent time in motels as a child because my mom was an addict. The film is very genuine.
- smashingfiasco 9y agoTry Flint Town.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe author seems, I have to say, deeply confused; about politics, art in general, and film in particular—he seems he mostly wants realistic, descriptive, non-documentary films without a traditional story arc depicting life in American poverty; even without the poverty part this just isn't something that anybody, really, is interested in from film—but most critically about his own thesis. It's clear he is unhappy with something about portrayal of poverty in film, but he starts off complaining that there is not enough of such portrayal, making what seems to be a quantitative complaint, but then spins out of control with contradictory criticisms of qualitative features of the portrayal. This is most stark in his complaints about I am Another You where he initially blames it for being too focused on explanation rather than description and then blames it for failing to dig deep enough to explain why mental illness leads more easily to homelessness in the US compared to the rest of the West. > If policymakers in DC (and in cities and state capitals around the country) had the Raineys in mind when making poverty policy, rather than the stubborn, racist myth of the “welfare queen”, they might produce smarter proposals that are more attuned to what poor Americans actually want and need. Policy makers don't generally base policy on what they see in movies, and don't generally have the racist myth of the “welfare queen” in mind when making policy that effects the poor, they instead have a very clear picture of the expressed interests of the people they are interested in serving (who are often chosen, much as the story goes with the choice to rob banks, “becsuse that's where the money is”), which very often don't include the poor regardless of their lifestyle. The “welfare queen” is an image policy makers (and policy entrepreneurs) invented to sell the policy, not a real concern at which it is directed.
- stevenwoo 9y agoSlightly off topic but there was a documentary about a lower middle class woman in the Bay Area who chose to adopt children that would otherwise never been adopted called My Flesh and Blood (2003). I would never have thought this could have been an interesting story but it really pulled me in even back then as a younger person. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0342804 http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0342804
- wand3r 9y agoThis article demands that an entire industry conform to the author's own personal opinions on how society is and that educating people about this author's belief is the most important thing in the industry. The character's in a host of movies aren't poor enough, stereotypical enough, don't escape poverty the right way or poverty isn't the single most thematic event in the storyline. I even agree with the author that conceptually government assistance & social services is important; it just isn't going to make for an exciting core piece of entertainment. While the author nitpicks that no movie goes far enough I would look at it like making progress. The analogy for me is giving a child vegetables. You don't try and force feed raw vegetables to a child as the primary meal because nutrients are important. Instead, you cook it into a balanced (and hopefully better tasting) meal so it can be easily digested. Yes this analogy has flaws; but I am contrasting the author's craving for essentially a social services documentary with actual reality & entertainment.
- WheelsAtLarge 9y agoIf you're poor and even if you are not, the last thing you want to see in a film is more poor people. I for one like to go to movies to escape my reality. That's what happened to movies about poor people. No, I did not read the article. Sometimes, the title hits me the wrong way and I have to make my point.