3 ms·
1. Whatever your opinion on gun laws is, no marketplace should be forced to allow listing guns - or any other category of products - on it. Shopping is more a m
by vkou 9y ago
1. Whatever your opinion on gun laws is, no marketplace should be forced to allow listing guns - or any other category of products - on it. Shopping is more a marketplace then search is.
2. What happens when the channels in question violate the ToS (Sandy Hook conspiracies often fall into this category)? Should no action be taken because they have a political slant?
You can certainly make an argument that internet platforms should be less like Facebook and YouTube and more like 4chan's /b board, but you need to at least acknowledge that there are tradeoffs with having a ToS that tolerates everything legal.
- jazzyk 9y agoImagine a few years ago, if Snowden had said on YouTube that there was a backdoor in every electronic device in the USA, he would surely have been banned as a lunatic spreading false propaganda against the US intelligence service.
- jamra 9y agoI really like this comment, so I gave you an upvote. I also struggle with this notion, but there was a famous case in the 70's of a Jewish lawyer defending Nazis' right to march. https://www.jta.org/2013/06/20/news-opinion/the-telegraph/nazis-marching-through-skokie https://www.jta.org/2013/06/20/news-opinion/the-telegraph/na... In an interview I saw with the lawyer, I remember him struggling with the morality of it, but his explanation was pretty amazing. He said something along the lines of: If you allow the encroachment of liberty in the name of silencing Nazis, one day soon, the Nazis will be using that same power against you. The lawyer's own family didn't understand his dedication to free speech. I personally found his reasoning to make sense. If you allow Google to sensor gun search results, one day, after a change in who's in power there, they may be censoring something that can harm society as a whole.
- vkou 9y agoThis response misses the point. Shopping is not search, and refusing to carry an item in your marketplace is not repression of free speech. Consider that Shopping does not carry something else controversial - pornography. Yet, you don't see conservatives get up in arms, demanding that Google start listing it on shopping. Odd, that. Google is not interested in making money from selling pornography. That's a decision it has made. They could also make a decision to only make money from selling Kosher food, and you'd have no leg to stand on when criticising that. A marketplace is not a town square. If a marketplace does not want to sell your product, it doesn't matter if the disagreement is political or economic. It's not censorship. Just because someone can sell guns in America does not mean you are compelled to help them. Just because you can participate in Nazi speech in America does not mean that it's a big controversy that Norderstrom or Goodwill refuses to carry Hitler Youth hoodies. Freedom of speech requires freedom from compelled speech.
- jazzyk 9y agoSeems like you are mixing up two things: 1. search results 2. sponsored ads/links and Google shopping marketplace, which appear separately. If Google chooses to not accept money from selling X, there will not be X items appearing in the sponsored links (2) section. But the search itself (1) has always been intended to return the most relevant information, based on the key words. Without any moral/political judgement, as long as it is legal.
- vkou 9y agoI'm not mixing those things up. People talking about Google search censorship are failing to note that: 1. Searching for guns and gun accessories in Google Search has, and continues to return relevant gun-related search results. 2. Searching for guns and gun accessories in Google Shopping[1] has had its search results reduced, hence the controversy. [1] Notice how all of the screencaps[2] posted on Zero Hedge/etc, are of people having the Shopping search tab open. [2] https://twitter.com/xavierdreyman/status/968272365741330433 https://twitter.com/xavierdreyman/status/968272365741330433
- jamra 9y agoI wasn’t posting my comment on Google in relation to shopping. There is a notion that Googles usefulness has made it a utility. If that utility chooses to censor, it’s worth discussing. The article I linked about Nazis are to explain the idea that censoring bad things can sometimes backfire. When you stop the bad people from assembling, how do you prevent the definition of bad to be changed in the future? As a matter of fact, my original comment was about the direction we are going in. With departments dedicated towards weeding out fake news, Google is ignoring its own bias. YouTube is targeting conservative ideas. The Sandy Hook conspiracy theories are perhaps an example of good censorship. At which point in the future will Google censor the next genocide?
- vkou 9y ago> There is a notion that Googles usefulness has made it a utility. This is a fantastic argument against Silicon Valley - that the institutions that it created have too much power. However, that is not the argument being made in this subthread. Having this argument requires consideration of the institutions that it replaced, and whether or not the concentration of so much market influence in a corporation is a good thing. That's the problem at hand, not the particular politics of such a corporation. > YouTube is targeting conservative ideas. The Sandy Hook conspiracy theories are perhaps an example of good censorship. At which point in the future will Google censor the next genocide? I am of the understanding that the problem Sandy Hook conspiracies is not their content, but their presentation - my understanding is that they libel, and accuse victims of the shooting of conspiracy and murder. This is, by many definitions, harassment, and is against the TOS. > The article I linked about Nazis are to explain the idea that censoring bad things can sometimes backfire. If we really want to go down that tangent, may I remind you that this strategy of dealing with Nazis backfired spectacularly in 1933? We allowed them to speak, and big surprise, that did not stop them from suppressing the speech of their opposition, as soon as they seized power. Not that anything else could be expected from a movement that is built on no foundation but violence. Tolerance is not a suicide pact. [1] [1] https://extranewsfeed.com/tolerance-is-not-a-moral-precept-1af7007d6376 https://extranewsfeed.com/tolerance-is-not-a-moral-precept-1...