9 ms·
Silicon Valley VCs tour the Midwest
- ggm 9y agoAt IETF Dallas 2015, I spoke to some people who had been west coast, now located there. They all said the primary driver for them was cost-of-living. Same salary could translate to a huge disposable income result, relocating. For the companies (this was mainly Datacenter and comms people) the RTT to east and west coast about equalizes. So, you can either have two DCs, one for each major population center, or you can have a bigger investment somewhere in the middle. Relocation expense against first year hire costs is pretty big. If you could shed $20k+ of excess cost to make somebody work for you, and get east-vs-west quality to a median line, and get reasonable land rent for DC and offices, wouldn't you talk to your CFO and board about it?
- austincheney 9y agoEvery time I read an article about VCs it is either about chasing trends or something bad. I guess this is what separates mature investors from corporate executives.
- dang 9y agoPerhaps it's what separates journalists writing about VCs.
- rmason 9y agoI remember Detroit when there weren't any VC's downtown and the startup scene was spread among the suburbs. Dan Gilbert set the Madison building as ground zero for a startup neighborhood. He even wanted that stretch of Woodward Avenue, Detroit's main street, renamed there as Webward Avenue. He filled the Madison with startups that he funded. When they outgrew it they moved to other building he owned nearby. Now that zone extends for ten or fifteen blocks, I know because I visit my friends down there regularly. One guys vision is all it took.
- karpodiem 9y agoDetroiter here (typing this in an apartment right off Grand Circus Park) Duo Security (in Ann Arbor) and Plex Systems (Troy) are the two 'Metro Detroit' anchors - pure software companies doing over $100 million+ in recurring SaaS revenue. I was thinking to myself - who is #3-5 for SaaS in Detroit?
- kayhi 9y agoBarracuda is right near 100 million
- tachyoff 9y agoDo they count even though they’re headquartered in Campbell, CA?
- tachyoff 9y agoIt has to be Quicken, right? They're the largest outfit I can think of. They’re obviously not primarily software, but I think they employ most of the tech workers downtown.
- SkyPuncher 9y agoNot really a household name, but Level Eleven (https://leveleleven.com/ https://leveleleven.com/) seems to be having great success.
- philipodonnell 9y agoI think its worth pointing out how important it is having that one investor willing to fund companies and move them to a startup neighborhood. Here in Jacksonville, FL we've seen 2-3 different attempts to create innovation districts downtown in the last five years, always led by entrepreneurial activists leveraging tax grants and "if you build it they will come" mentality. One collapsed after building an incubator and funding only small consumer products instead of the startups they promised and wasting a huge amount of money on overhead. One never got off the ground. Another launched to much fanfare and then went silent. I've been told political leadership are pretty sick and tired of hearing how entrepreneurship is going to save everyone. You get these excited people wanting to make a difference so they follow the playbook but without the key players and it fails. But I get shade for being the one saying not to do it because its wasting goodwill for when a real opportunity comes along, everyone who could act has already been burned by false promises based on little more than hope.
- swalsh 9y agoPaul Graham had this thesis that there was untapped potential by targeting young people. I've always believed that same principle could apply to the midwest. Where I grew up everyone wanted to be an entrepreneur. Not because it was hip, but because there were no good jobs (the town was built around a factory that closed down in the 80's). The exceptional talent moved to the coasts, but what's left is still pretty persistent, and given that the trends of technology have been to lower the barriers to entry in startups, "exceptional talent" isn't required. In fact what the midwest has is a plentiful supply of ambitious, and persistent people... which arguably is more valuable.
- sidlls 9y agoAlmost all the most successful SV companies don't require exceptional talent. Most of the "big names" have a tiny fraction of their engineering organization that has to be truly exceptional. The problem is that, at least based on my experience (I worked in the Midwest and the south east for over a decade ending a few years ago), the vast majority of "talent" in the midwest is below even the mediocre requirements of most SV/VC companies. No amount of persistence can overcome that.
- hylianwarrior 9y ago> The vast majority of "talent" in the midwest is below even the mediocre requirements of most SV/VC companies. The poor education systems out there are to blame, IMO.
- linkregister 9y agoI seriously doubt you've thought this comment through. University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, among others, are renowned for producing important research. NCSA Mosaic and LLVM are just two noteworthy technologies coming from research done at UIUC. Alumni have come to form Netscape, AMD, Oracle, and YouTube. UIUC is the most noteworthy of midwestern universities, but is hardly the only excellent education available to undergraduates and grad students.
- btrautsc 9y agoGoing through YC in 2014 and every single VC asked (and were perplexed) when we told them we were not moving our company to SF/ SV. That strategy was effectively read as our team signaling we weren't "going for it". It was joked about how we would have to do board meetings in SF because people wouldn't fly. I wonder if times have changed or rents just finally got too expensive for the younger tier of VCs.
- geerlingguy 9y agoMidwest, in this case, seems to equal Ohio and Michigan?
- danschumann 9y agoI live in Oshkosh, WI. We had Steve Case come to Green Bay last year, but it seemed mostly pomp, and he only invested in a single business that was a sure thing anyway. I've been developing animation software for 2 years, and am set on getting profitability without help, mostly because this is probably necessary anyway, but also because it'll send the message to other folks in town that they don't need an external 'go-ahead' to start a business that works. I think part of the reason VC money isn't working as well in the valley, is that people are more obsessed with raising money than they are with making their business work. There's a certain uncomfortable fatalism that comes when you take the mindset that no one is coming to save your business. Not now, not ever. It's the same feeling you get when you have a software bug, and you can't look up the answer on google, because you're so deep into your own territory, that the question wouldn't make sense to anyone else. I welcome money, and I welcome interest, however, I think some people just need to steel themselves and launch without help. Some people need money, and other people need to just do it. That goes for every area, but in the Midwest, sometimes we get this "we need to copy the big cities" mentality, and I want to stop that, since 99% of the time, no one is coming to the rescue, even if I'd like to see more companies coming in, and lowering that %.
- jldugger 9y ago> I think part of the reason VC money isn't working as well in the valley, is that people are more obsessed with raising money than they are with making their business work. The other question one has to ask as a VC is what distinguishes a given metro from the 50 other options, and it seems unlikely that a clear winner will emerge. Instead you'd likely get a peanut butter spread of investment and investors. The difference isn't that valley companies are less focused on funding rounds than outside the valley. It's that outside SV, when it comes to raise the series B, a startup has likely already fully tapped their local VC market. Any rational actor would at least prefer to have the option of taking VC money later, even if they intend to bootstrap. > Some people need money, and other people need to just do it. That goes for every area, but in the Midwest, sometimes we get this "we need to copy the big cities" mentality Well, startups still have to compete for talent. When you look at big cities, they have a lot of things working in their favor. They favor new immigrants by providing reliable public transit and walkable downtowns so a car and driver's license isn't mandatory. They have several major employers, which makes the social and individual impact of a layoff less severe. You're right that it's not something you can depend on, but these are also conditions a lone bootstrapping entrepreneur can't just will into existence. Even if you're successful, that success means more opportunities for growth and there will come a time when your needs and the political status quo conflict. Especially in college towns typically opposed to new development, happily leeching rents off heavily indebted students. That building proposal to hold 5,000 employees? Zoning not approved as out of character. The housing annex developers need to build housing for your new hires? Didn't pass the ballot measure. The public transit your H1-Bs need? Dismissed by the City Council.
- swervo2 9y agoHonestly, this story has been repeated multiple times in the New York Times and other publications. When you see that happening,it reeks of PR. The fingerprints are there - someone wants you to think that Silicon Valley VC are acting differently. Reading the article, more red flags. This is a whole lot of deliberate signaling and posturing. Smells like PR, walks like PR, flops around on the dock like freshly caught fake news PR. So why would prominent Silicon Valley VC engage highly placed PR services who can plant their self serving fake news into the New York Times (if you believe the New York Times is above this, I have very bad news for you)? Answer: Politics. These Bay Area VCs want one thing: Special government privileges from desperate middle American cities. Like Jeff Bezos, they want cities to beg for their money. Tax cuts, tax breaks, free real estate, special privileges, pork, tax incentives. These articles are becoming common because this is a campaign to influence local politicians in these states, prepare the groundwork for later stages in their campaign. Just reading this, it stinks so highly of signaling, the fakeness of the quotes are so over the top. The quotes have this fake “oh gee, we are just these crazy VCs who never thought of middle America before, what is a milk shake? How do I milk a cow?” Quality to them they cannot possibly be real. Who is going to pay for all the special privileges these VCs are going to get from state and local governments? Hint: Tax payers. The real title of this article should be: “Silicon Valley VCs identify dumb yokels in middle America willing to subsidize their future bullshit.” That’s the truth.
- IntronExon 9y agoAlternative theory: journalists are lazy, and if a story gets a decent response in one outlet, they all crap out a similar story until they reach a point of diminishing returns. As a bonus my theory doesn’t require tinfoil.
- mattnewton 9y agoBoth can be true: a good PR firm knows that journalists can be lazy[0] and how to amplify their efforts. [0] obligatory link to the submarine: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- walterbell 9y ago> When you invest in a San Francisco start-up, “you’re basically paying landlords, Twilio, and Amazon Web Services,” said Ms. Bannister of Founders Fund, referring to the companies that provide start-ups with messaging services and data hosting. There must be a few other companies missing from this list..
- sidlls 9y agoIt's a facile statement. A significant fraction, if not the majority by far, of most companies' expenditures is in salaries which go mostly to pay rent or mortgages in most places.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoWhich is what “landlords” means; not the company’s landlords. It’s far from facile.
- askafriend 9y agoI think the point was that it's not a phenomenon exclusive to San Francisco.
- sidlls 9y agoaskafriend's comment is correct: most companies, regardless of industry or location, spend a significant fraction of resources on salaries. The notion that "it pays landlords" isn't unique to the bay area or VC-funded companies, by far.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoI could have sworn "in most places" wasn't present when I replied, but I might be misremembering.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoSomehow I feel like NYTimes writers have mastered the art of "it-almost-sounds-sincere-but-nothing-like-skewering-with-an-undercurrent-of-sarcasm". The whole recounting of the "trappings of hipsterdom", the mentions of the vegan donuts and coal-infused kombucha, the portraying of VCs on a "safari". Granted, not so sure if the target is the hipster-posh VCs or the local yokels, but for this article I could appreciate a more straightforward style.
- jorblumesea 9y agoSV relies on dense loci of talent in order to function, Chicago is really the only city that has this. The melting pot of ideas, poaching, engineering etc is a huge reason for its success. While I understand SV is looking increasingly unattractive for cheap big bets, I don't think this will play out like these firms expect. It's not about the money, it's about the culture that SV cultivated. And while parts of it are toxic, other parts of it are enormously successful and notoriously hard to replicate. It also doesn't help that every state in the midwest has been slashing educational budgets and in some states has enacted almost a war on education. I think the attitude of "SV toxic culture" is ironic, after having grown up in the midwest and seen horrible racism, anti-intellecutalism, anti-free speech measures, and all others kinds of issues.
- lsc 9y ago>It also doesn't help that every state in the midwest has been slashing educational budgets and in some states has enacted almost a war on education. Yeah, uh, this is going to end badly; I left the central valley for the anti-intellectual culture. It's a long term problem, and I don't really see how you combat it. Educational funding, I think, might even be a trailing indicator of this; If your culture doesn't value learning... you have a much bigger problem than just underfunded schools.
- jeron 9y agoMaking higher education free would be a great start, but that's probably not happening anytime soon
- tachyoff 9y ago> The trip, which took place on a luxury bus outfitted with a supply of vegan doughnuts and coal-infused kombucha, was known as the "Comeback Cities Tour." I live in Detroit. It’s a city that has been pushed to the edge of oblivion... and then into oblivion for several decades. It's fantastic that thers investment, but at the same time, stuff like this feels so incredibly patronizing. "It's nicer than San Francisco!" Yes, there are, in fact, nice buildings outside of San Francisco, even in Detroit. Midwestern cities don't exist solely to make money, and I'm rather disturbed that they're seen more and more as nothing but investment vehicles. Detroit is 80% black. We didn’t even have working street lights until a few years ago (shout out to the Public Lighting Authority). I just look at San Francisco and the entire Bay Area, and I think to myself: "we don't want that here". Detroit isn't just cheap rent and exposed brick. It's grit and soul and pain and culture and 300+ years of history. I'm sure these investors got a lovely tour. Did they talk about the 1967 riots? Did they show them northwest Detroit, where entire city blocks are basically becoming urban prairie? Did they talk to the regular folks living and working in the city for generations? They’re lovely people, and they live here too. They're as much a part of Detroit as the Madison Building or New Center or Dan Gilbert or the rotting houses or the rich history.
- Kinnard 9y agoThing is (I'm a native, black, 3rd generation Detroiter, and a serial founder who has lived in the Bay Area) none of that (unless and until it does) has anything to do with starting startups or making startups succeed.
- Apocryphon 9y agoYou're right, but that's still sad.
- Kinnard 9y agoAnd impertinent. That's the thing: people want the side effects of startup success here but they don't care about successful startups or the things that make startups succeed. The Genius loci is huntin 'em and killin 'em here. I live it everyday. Maybe, just maybe a place like Detroit could overcome the premier network effects of the Valley if people here cared about startups. They don't. In some ways it's unfair but true. In the same way that people with families should not start startups. "This one is real. I wouldn't advise anyone with a family to start a startup. I'm not saying it's a bad idea, just that I don't want to take responsibility for advising it. I'm willing to take responsibility for telling 22 year olds to start startups. So what if they fail? They'll learn a lot, and that job at Microsoft will still be waiting for them if they need it. But I'm not prepared to cross moms." ~ http://paulgraham.com/notnot.html http://paulgraham.com/notnot.html Unfair. True.
- dmode 9y agoHow many of this “Silicon Valley comes to Midwest” article do we need ? It’s all feel good, but numbers don’t support it. And this PR move has been happening for 3-4 years at least. Just other day DoorDash raised $535mn and it is based in Palo Alto. SV startups continue to raise giant sums, grow businesses at global scale, and make their investors money.
- RickJWag 9y agoHaving seen recent hiring data, I think SV is not sustainable. Compare salaries to what you get for remote work (especially a timezone or two away.) It's only a matter of time. The numbers will catch up.
- xivzgrev 9y agoYou would be amazed at how much companies still value face to face collaboration even in this era of Slack etc. The salary deltas may be big yes but there's often a large premium on being in the office.
- e2e4 9y ago"When you invest in a San Francisco start-up, “you’re basically paying landlords, Twilio, and Amazon Web Services,” said Ms. Bannister of Founders Fund" Only the first part "landlord" it's affected by location.
- lsc 9y agoEh, for amazon? I think it is location dependent. The majority of your datacenter costs, if you want to run your own hardware rather than amazon? At first, those costs will be dominated by people, and this is why it makes sense to run on amazon until you're paying a quarter million or more a year. Sure, you can get part time sysadmins. Not that bad for planned work. But getting someone who will answer your pager? You pretty much have to hire someone full time and they need to be really dedicated. (being the only guy on pager is a rough experience.) If you can find someone with my skillset in, say, Cleveland? they don't have the option of super high paying local jobs where you get fed three times a day and don't have to carry a pager. The me in Cleveland is gonna work a lot cheaper. The problem, of course, is finding a me in Cleveland. I'm sure you can, but there just isn't the density there as there is here.
- sethherr 9y agoThis is the most amusing part of this whole article, as someone who moved from Chicago to the bay a year and a half ago. If midwesterners are hungry enough and good enough, they’ll move to the bay (or they’re already working remote for Bay Area salaries).
- lsc 9y agoFundamentally, I don't care how "hungry" my technical staff is. (I mean, I want to see to it that they are well fed, but if I'm hiring technical staff... their ability to "hustle" isn't something I am selecting for.) I know there are good technical people other places- I hired a few to work remote when I was doing my own thing, and in the last year, two of my friends have moved from here to cheaper pastures. it's just... well, the density of nerds here is incredible. If you can pay local rates, you will almost certainly be able to find someone who doesn't have to move. In the midwest, I think that most areas, there are very few local employers; if you want to jump jobs, you often have to move. That means that as an employer, if you want to hire someone on-site, a lot of times you need to talk someone into moving. I personally live within walking distance of internap, Intel, drobo, palo alto networks, EMC and tens of smaller companies that could hire me as a sysadmin or a network admin or even as my current specialty, an EDA administrator. A ten minute drive widens the field greatly. This density goes both ways; it means that an employee can easily find an employer without moving, and the other side of that is that an employer can easily find an employee. This means, I think, that people tend to work at jobs that they match with better, because there's a much smaller cost to switching to that other job that fits better.
- refurb 9y agoIs there really a lot going on in South Bend? Detroit I can believe, but some of those other cities made me think "there are other mid-west cities that would have been much better choices!"
- weerd 9y agoSeriously, I was really surprised to see Youngstown instead of say.. Columbus or Pittsburgh.
- xtracerx 9y agoIt says this trip was organized by a rep from north east ohio which is the only reason they went there. Akron and Youngstown don't have the talent to develop a website, much less support more than a few tiny startups.
- throwaway713 9y agoThere seems to be no evidence that startups are significantly growing anywhere outside of the already well-known tech cities. And the main reason is because most of the talent that really wants to work in cutting-edge tech takes the initiative and relocates there to be with all the other people that really want to work in tech (barring some people who are taking care of sick or aging relatives, etc.) I'm not saying another city couldn't eventually displace SV, but it would require a huge shift in network effects. Also, the cost of living argument is mostly nonsense. For large tech companies, even with spending $6,000 a month on an apartment, you still have a lot more left over after California taxes than the best tech employers in the Midwest or Southeast. When your total comp is 3x what you would make in an "affordable" city, does it really matter that rent is 1/3 of your income?
- closeparen 9y agoTech workers can afford bachelor lifestyles. But raising families they way we were raised would cost more like 9/3rds of our incomes.
- RickJWag 9y ago"...a city with more intellectual diversity" I'm stunned the NYT printed this. In fact, I'm surprised the NYT printed a lot of the article. I owe them another look.
- hacknat 9y agoI’m in a weird situation in that I started my education and career on the West Coast, but ended up on the Midwest a decade later for personal reasons. I do have to say that the business culture differences are astounding. Obviously I’m generalizing, but Midwest business culture is incredibly risk averse and VC money tends to flow to niche high research fields that the investor either came from or understands really well (e.g. Biotech). I’ve started to see some small changes with some funds looking to invest in “general” startups, but the capital is astonishingly weak. Honestly though, I’ve come to appreciate it (even though it can drive me batty - Midwest “nice” is a real thing and can be a severe hindrance to effective communication), as I think it forces a level of creativity and resiliency on me that I didn’t need in the West Coast. Finally the tech community out here is so small that people really genuinely seem to look out for one another and be genuinely interested in what other people are doing as you never know where the next job is going to come from.
- kriro 9y agoNot so thinly veiled Zillow product placement article.
- someguydave 9y agoSilicon Valley success is Midwestern success. I would wager that the majority of engineering talent working in the Bay Area was born and raised in the Midwest.
- iamleppert 9y agoI guess now that they have used up all the social capital in SF, they need to broaden their horizons and look for more people to make their slaves. I wonder what terms they’ll offer to some naive kid in Ohio? They could probably get away with a lot more and do exponentially more damage than what they have done here.
- xivzgrev 9y agoI think its great VCs are expanding their worldview. I think there are definitely good investment opps outside of SV. I think its a stretch to say SV is over. Yes living expenses and salaries are crazy but there is a success network here that is reinforcing. In order for SV to be over it would take a new annoited tech hub, like we saw SF do recently. Many companies and jobs moved up from SV to SF. Saying there are now 100 smaller tech hubs in the Midwest South etc does nothing to combat SVs network effect. It is still the densest (albeit most costly). So much of the new talent and entrepreneurs will naturally flock there to maximize their chance of success.
- droidist2 9y agoI love how they make it sound like the Midwest is another country, like they visited Mumbai or something.
- froindt 9y agoSad as it is, lots of people on the coasts perceive it that way. As an anecdote, I was born and raised in Iowa. My dad was on the board of a a non-profit which primarily operated out of the DC suburbs. As the only person from the Midwest on the board, he floated the idea of moving operations to Iowa. Everyone thought he was stupid to suggest such a thing. "Could we even find qualified people to hire in the Midwest?" They weren't doing any lobbying or hosting events, it was effectively just an administrative office. They moved to Iowa, paid a small fraction in rent, got more space, could afford to pay a similar wage giving the employees much more disposable income, and hired another person (I believe going from 3 to 4 employees).
- aphextron 9y ago>When you invest in a San Francisco start-up, “you’re basically paying landlords, Twilio, and Amazon Web Services,” said Ms. Bannister of Founders Fund, referring to the companies that provide start-ups with messaging services and data hosting. This is the most absurd realization. Literally 50% of your startup's funds will be sent directly to landlords if you locate in the bay area.