14 ms·
The Drugging of the American Boy (2014)
- castle-bravo 9y agoI don't have kids and I don't know anybody who has kids on ADHD medication, so I'm ignorant about this, but I have a hard time believing that people put their kids on stimulants without knowing what these drugs are and what they do; especially when it's possible to look up the Wikipedia article on Adderall and see that it's nothing but amphetamine. I'd be further surprised if none of these parents were interested enough to try out their kids' prescriptions on themselves; I would be. It's awfully cynical, but I think that a lot of parents have a good idea what they're giving to their kids and do it anyway because they think the stimulants will give them a competitive edge in school, college admissions, and ultimately lead to higher incomes. The cost of not drugging your kid might be that they don't fit in, are singled out for punishment by school staff, and end up handicapped by their negative experiences in school. It's a very tough decision, even if you know what's in those pills. I just wish the dosages were lower. Having tried a few of my friends' prescriptions over the years, I've found that even "low" doses get me high and then leave me with a hangover. I might be particularly sensitive (I get euphoric from taking 30mg of pseudoephedrine), but I'm a 180-pound adult. I can't imagine what an 18mg dose of methylphenidate does to a prepubescent boy. At worst, the 'high' from taking these drugs therapeutically should be subliminal.
- OutThisLife 9y agoYou have an interesting perspective but I think you're overestimating the average American parent. I'm around kids and their parents a lot, most don't do their due diligence - they just trust the authority figure of a doctor.
- watwut 9y agoThe again, when they don't trust the doctor, they are called stupid and all kind of things.
- limeblack 9y agoMy cousin on ADHD meds lives with his grandparents. They don't have email addresses and only own an iPhone after much convincing.
- rdtsc 9y agoIt was described to be like this by a mother who went through this: she watched her child struggle with homework, not being able to focus, getting bad grades, falling behind in reading and math. One of doctors suggested this "pill". She gave it to her son, and then that same night she watched him sit down and do homework like she's never seen him before. In that respect it was an easy decision. That was in the late-80s or early 90s. Her son became pretty successful and is doing quite well. She credits that success in part to the decision to give him those pills. It was not about a competitive edge, acing the SAT or going into Harvard, for them back then it was about not failing behind and ended up in remedial classes.
- goldenkey 9y agoA lot of times these kids are just slow...low IQ. Amphetamines increase IQ and general mental and physical performance temporarily. So the benefit is there but these parents should probably accept their childs aptitude rather than trying to augment it through hard stimulant drugs..
- jamra 9y agoStimulants don’t have the same effect on kids that they do in adults. They may even be downers. Well, that’s what my Uncle the doctor told me
- boomboomsubban 9y agoAre you sure he wasn't comparing "people with ADHD to people without" as opposed to "kids vs adults?"
- jamra 9y agoI am comparing kids vs adults, not people with ADD and without. Kids can react differently than adults. The source of that was my Uncle, which was confirmed by my children’s pediatrician. I don’t know the literature on it, though. It doesn’t seem like good advice to try it on yourself to check if it’s good enough for a child. That was the point I was trying to make
- boomboomsubban 9y agoThough I agree trying it yourself provides little useful information, your broader statement is still confusing. An individuals reaction to stimulants varies based on a large number of factors. Though age may be one of the factors, it is not a large enough one to say "children react differently than adults." If they did react differently, stimulants being common for both children and adults with ADHD wouldn't make sense. I mean no disrespect here, but might you have misremembered things doctors said about "your children" and changed it to all children? As people with ADHD do generally react differently to stimulants, with drowsiness being a common side effect.
- jamra 9y agoAs I stated, some children react differently. An example is with Benadryl. Some children get a lot of energy and have an opposite effect. With stimulants, I'm not sure if it's some or all children, however, my point was to apply a bit of skepticism towards trying medicine out on yourself as a filter for its efficacy on your child. Edit: Here is a link for an example. It may actually be stating that stimulants in children do not have a paradoxical effect. I'm too uninterested to research this, but would be interested in a professional's opinion. http://adhd.emedtv.com/adhd/adhd-myth-the-paradoxical-stimulant-effect.html http://adhd.emedtv.com/adhd/adhd-myth-the-paradoxical-stimul...
- oldcynic 9y ago> I just wish the dosages were lower Two things. First, the first 1-2 days of ADHD meds can have a dramatic effect that have you thinking "this can't be right". It's normal, expected, and goes away very quickly. You should be warned to expect it by the prescribing doctor. After 3 days or so you barely know you're taking them. Second, the dosage and effect on a non-ADHD person is entirely different to that an ADHD person will get. That's presuming it's the right med for them[0]. You will have a stimulating, speed, effect. An ADHD person (well most) will get little to no stimulation, and a calming effect, and might sit down to do their homework, or even just sit still for a couple of hours - for the first time ever. Amphetamines don't do that to normal neurology, thus you can't compare. The dosage is putting them closer to typical, but putting you far away from typical. If you were normal vision or long sighted and tried your friend's short sight prescription glasses you wouldn't wish their glasses were weaker, would you? Same principle. It's also common for one or other parent to discover they have it too after they have tried their child's meds. [0] Getting the right medication is a bit of a trial and error minefield, but should be a standard part of treatment. Not all doctors are as willing to switch medication or titrate dosage as they should be.
- EggsOnToast 9y agoThis is a pretty solid description of the situation. I take adderall at the moment and I've been on adhd meds since a little before highschool. College was funny when I went to parties because I'd see people taking stimulants (prescription and otherwise) for fun and all I could think was "Why would anyone want to party on this stuff?"
- oldcynic 9y agoIt's funny, the doctor brought that up after my diagnosis. If you've tried stimulants recreationally and they just didn't work, or if you just wanted to sit and chill, he saw that as a very strong indicator.
- empath75 9y agoThat’s so ridiculous. As someone who spent a lot of time in the rave scene— people respond to different dosages and settings in wildly different ways. Just because you did meth and wanted to chill and talk for a bit instead of go out dancing, that doesn’t mean you have adhd. You give ‘anybody’ speed and they’ll go on an apartment cleaning spree or just do homework on the right day, with the right dose.
- stagbeetle 9y agoI have ADHD and take mixed amphetamine salts so I'm not homeless. 18mg of methylphenidate is on the lower end of "middle" in terms of dosage. I can relate to the "drugged" feeling and euphoria and that's a common complaint (that they feel like they're wired or that the euphoria is gone after the first week!) within ADHD communities. However, it doesn't last after the "break-in period," where the side effects dwindle and so does the euphoria. All you're left with is focus in pill form. It also should be noted that amphetamines et al. affect neurotypicals (relatively) differently than those with dopamine/norepinepherine disorders. While neurotypicals commonly (from first and second-hand accounts) note that they feel high, those with ADHD feel like they're "normal." If that's too broad and indescriptive, then I point to the account of a small subset of people who only found out they had ADHD from experimenting with stimulants. They find their life no longer becomes a Sisyphean task and they can function like a normal person. Whereas neurotypicals might start picking at their skin or masturbating for hours, those with ADHD will finally clean their rooms or make that phone call they've been meaning to make for the past 2 years. As to your belief of the "well-meaning parent," I have to disagree. I have been around poor families, stable families, and rich families, but most parents don't have the first clue of what ADHD really is, even less what an "amphetamine" is. Or even how to use thoughtfully use Wikipedia and the internet to answer their questions, instead of differing their thinking to, seeming, authorities. It's akin to asking the box-spring salesman if your bed needs a box-spring. The box-spring salesman will tell you all of the benefits in easily digestible, and deftly crafted, sound-bites. And then you will accept his proclamations and move on with your life, believing he knows best. The same is done by the majority of people who are in contact with drugs and supplements. Even more so, parents who are too busy/exhausted/inflexible by virtue of the mental capacity degradation that comes with years of not having to use much thought to get by, i.e the bulk of parents. Most people do not do cost-benefit analysis, but a subset of "involved" parents will allow their children to be medicated (whether rightfully or wrongfully) to let them get a step-up over their peers. To this I agree, but I don't believe it's as common as your argument makes it out to be. To the statement after about "the cost of not drugging," I agree, but like with last statement, it's not common among parents. To the rest, I have to say, in my opinion, your statements reek of neurotypicalness. Atleast, not of someone that has a disability that separates them from other people. This is not an insult, but an elucidation on the disconnect between yourself and other people's mindsets. People are very common and predictable, but if you're among them you likely won't see how. One of these similarities is that they believe everyone thinks like them. For you, it might be a more rational approach. For someone else, it might be a more feelings-oriented approach, that mimics rationality by appealing to the homeostasis of one's emotional state. It's hard to tell where someone is going when you're all moving in the same direction. Now move yourself to outside the crowd. You can see all the little peculiarities of everyone's movement. Like a school of fish, they're all synchronized, but those peculiarities set them apart. With major disabilities, you're forced outside that school of fish, and destined to stare at everyone, instead of moving with them. Overtime, all the different combinations of moves have been played out. All the idiosyncrasies have been enumerated, and there is nothing left to deduce, but that most people are too wrapped up in going forward that they never step back and take a breather. To unplug from the global consciousness and just watch the synapses of other people fire. To peer take a look at someone similar so you can recognize your own shortcomings.
- liveoneggs 9y agoit starts like this: the teacher says "Billy is having a lot of trouble sitting still and paying attention. I think he might have ADHD. A lot of the other boys do and they've really improved since they started taking medicine for it." Now since the teacher got compliance from other parents your kid is not given much slack. A solution has been presented and you choose to take it or not. "Billy is still fidgeting in his chair all morning and lunch time is pushed back to 1:30pm this year because of staffing issues." "Billy is struggling with math. We do it every day at 12 and I think he's just worn out from fidgeting in his seat all morning. And you know on wednesday he started acting out and being loud." "I really think Billy has potential to do better. I hope you'll reconsider having him seen by someone to address his hyperactivity."
- matthewn 9y agoFrom 2014, though the AMP version linked to does not reflect this. https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a32858/drugging-of-the-american-boy-0414/ https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a32858/drugging-of-the...
- dang 9y agoWe changed the URL from https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/amp32858/drugging-of-the-american-boy-0414/?__twitter_impression=true https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/amp32858/drugging-of-t....
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> The children in the study—forty-four boys, four girls, all diagnosed with ADHD—were given varying doses of medication and behavioral therapy, and researchers monitored their episodes of "noncompliance" each day. When I read about studies like that I like to imagine two scientists in lab coats, one with a clipboard, the other with a complicated piece of equipment, looking at a kid throwing a wild tantrum: - Dr Smith, what does the Noncompliance-o-scope say? - It's off the charts, Dr Brown. Off. The. Charts. Except -alas- there's no such machine that can tell you how much, or when, a child is non-complying so I have never any idea what those studies are supposed to be, you know, actually measuring.
- wallace_f 9y agoI can think of examples of incredible teachers, but also of ones who reprimanded students for things as trivial as fact-checking them, or for statements which may, or may not, have intended political disagreement with them. Seeking perfect compliance is probably not even a desirable outcome. However, neither is drugging normal* children, but where there's profit opportunity there will be people lining up. *Normal meaning a significant portion of the population of children
- sova 9y agoI hate to laugh at such a scenario but you may want to consider standup comedy as a fallback.
- originalsimba 9y agoToo late!
- FlyingSideKick 9y agoI was diagnosed with ADHD as a child and given medication which made me feel numb and completely changed my personality. After a year or so my father decided to stop giving me the medication and I returned to normal which must’ve been hell for my teachers. Besides science classes, I received Ds in every class through my sophomore year. At the time I looked like a failure but today Id consider myself happy and successful as I’ve travelled the world, become a father and started a number of innovative businesses. ADD is a gift as it has enabled me to make creative connections that others simply don’t see. If you have kids please focus on their long-term well being. Please love your kids and support the things they find interest in. Getting good grades being well behaved in class aren’t everything are not necessarily an indicator of future success.
- stagbeetle 9y agoThis is a very good mindset, but not everyone holds out that long. I had the same experience and hated how the meds changed my personality. "It wasn't me. I'm not following my own personal destiny on meds. It's someone else." ADHD has some very neat pros, but without a proper support network and a good foundation, going without meds is hell. I recently finally gave in to my idealism (even now I don't want to call it that) and convinced myself that I have goals, and those goals can't wait another year for me to get things right. I've wasted enough years struggling for air. The first month was pretty bad, adjusting your family and friend's expectations. I even found myself avoiding conversation "until the meds wore off and I was me again." Few will understand any of the things in your post, but it will spark some thought in those that are susceptible.
- goldenkey 9y agoMost of ADHD's clinical symptoms are hilariously identical to having bad habits. Of course a dopaminergic pill is going to alter reward mechanisms in the brain and help a shitty snotnosed kid do things they would normally not do. But discipline and wisdom can also impart behavioral changes, and is much more lasting and real. Amphetamines are performance enhancing drugs for air force pilots to do 16 hour sorties. They are too hard a drug to give to a kid to bandaid over his impulsivity.
- BugsJustFindMe 9y agoThis article, like nearly every other article on the subject, is about _over_ diagnosis. Fine. But readers miss that overdiagnosis doesn't mean always wrong. And it's important to remember that. It's easy to dismiss the value of these medicines if you've never felt saved by them. It's hard to understand how painful and frustrating it is for a child to not be able to complete an exam because when he gets a few words into a question he has to start over from the beginning again and again and again and again and again because the words just keep slipping away from him. It's hard to explain that, no, extra time doesn't actually mean a special edge against other children who don't have the same problem. It's hard feeling really bad at subjects that you're actually really good at because you can't keep your thoughts together. It's hard to walk out of an exam room crying because you can feel yourself starting to lose your grip. It's hard as an adult to say "this saved my life" to another adult who doesn't understand it. But it's just weird when adults who are perfectly happy to drug themselves on the regular for no other reason than because it feels good are like "yeah, but..." when there are kids out there who will gladly take negative side effects over the alternative.
- sova 9y agoI worked at an after school program for youth and there were children fewer than ten years old being diagnosed with ADHD which I believe has "adult" in the name. I don't think age 10 or any age before then is a meaningful time to diagnose, but mom did not complain because he was more calm and less of a frantic chaotic child (one of three) while she worked full time. Quite sad, yet I see the temptation for parents as well.
- jfaat 9y agoThe A is for Attention, not Adult
- ycombinete 9y agoAttention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. No adult there.
- Bucephalus355 9y agoI was diagnosed with ADHD at 9 in the 3rd grade. My mother, who had a Masters in Early Childhood Education, brought me to a psychiatrist over the objections of my father. 25 years later I’m so glad she did and I’ve benefitted enormously. Ultimately I wound up with a combination of a stimulant medicine and a low dose anti-seizure medicine to take some of the edge off the stimulant (speaking fast, jumpy, etc). In the end, the experience has made me much more of a believer in psychiatry than psychotherapy. I never benefitted from that the few times psychiatrist I’ve had have requested me take it. If anything, going to confession / mass has helped more in the “non-medicine” stuff you can do.
- doitLP 9y agoWhen a full 20% of the population is diagnosed with a disorder, that's either a serious epidemic or there's something wrong with the term disorder. Teachers and parents want tractable kids...just sayin.
- ycombinete 9y agoOr, there is a serious case of over-diagnoses/prescription. Much like how antibiotics were being over-prescribed in Britain.
- arkades 9y agoThere’s a combination. Psych sets it’s cutoff for disease at traits that seriously hamper your ability to function successfully in life. It has a very tough time grappling with questions like, “what if the problem is with modern life, and not with the patient?” Which is why so much failed social policy ultimately ends up in the ED getting sedated into pliability.
- manjushri 9y agoPsychiatry has a long history of pseudoscientific mass diagnosis of undesireables. Slaves who wanted to escape had drapetomania[1]. The holocaust was conducted under psychiatric auspices [2]. Masturbation and alternate sexuality were insanity[3]. And now if you don't strictly adhere to impotent 19th century authoritarian teaching methods you are considered mentally ill. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drapetomania https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drapetomania [2]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/23511221/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/23511221/ [3]http://www.szasz.com/iol8.html http://www.szasz.com/iol8.html
- thomastjeffery 9y agoThe most frustrating thing about this subject (to me) is that it is all about doing education to children. If children weren't forced to sit in classrooms 7 hours a day, 5 days a week (or similar), ADHD, ADD, etc. would not get the negative focus it does. Just because education is A Good Thing™ does not mean we should ignore the detrimental effects of its implementation
- reificator 9y ago> Just because education is A Good Thing™ does not mean we should ignore the detrimental effects of its implementation I have long believed that education and schooling are not as linked as society pretends. Children aren't served by locking them in a room with barred windows for hours on end and telling them to pay attention and not fidget and do your work and go home and do several more hours of work and then repeat. Distraction is a part of being a child. There are productive distractions and unproductive ones, but the solution is not to pump children full of drugs. You're robbing them off their natural connection-making process, and of the chance to learn how to handle distractions as they grow up in a society of smartphones and advertisements. And all that is assuming that we're even trying to educate the kids while they're in school. https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament....
- thomastjeffery 9y agoThank you very much for the link. I've just gotten around to reading it, and it's wonderful. Those who do "education" to students are organized and powerful, and that is a serious problem. We as a society are being cheated out of learning by a mindless system. Maybe those of us who have been enlightened to that fact ought to organize ourselves.
- dbatten 9y agoFor anybody scrolling through... the Lockharts Lament link is worth the read!
- VLM 9y agoIts interesting that if you have legacy baggage and technical debt, you can't NOT lock kids in cages for a whole day and all that industrial era foolishness, which would actually be pretty valuable if we ever get sent back thru a one or two century time warp. We have the best 1850 education system money can buy; of course its useless in 2010s but whatever. At least for boys, if you grassroots up from first principles and implement what works pragmatically, rather than what we've always done or whats in the union contract, you end up with something like cub scouts or boy scouts. Given the wildly divergent goals of school and scouts, where school exists to perpetuate and expand the bureaucracy and scouts exists because organized screwing around provides more learning opportunities than disorganized screwing around, they will continue to diverge until they're unrecognizable. But at least in theory boys learn at both organizations. Much more at boy scouts than at school of course, but they are kinda similar. There exist merit badges in boy scouting for semi-academic topics like electricity or programming. The time investment has to be limited but its intellectually interesting to imagine that someday the only way to teach a boy geometry would be a boy scout geometry merit badge. Unimaginable amounts of time and money will be spent in schools on a line item named "geometry" but the legacy school system does not have any goal of teaching boys geometry so ironically thats the one thing boys will definitely not learn in geometry class, they'll have to go to scouts to learn. I have no personal experience with girl scouts because of their "no male leadership" rule, which is about as appropriate as the now removed "no gay leadership" rule in boy scouts; My lack of praising girl scouts is due to a lack of girl scout experience not implying its bad or wrong. Its possible, even likely, girl scouts is just as good for girls. I do find the ratio bizarre where per capita girl scouting is around ten times less popular than boy scouts, that might indicate a problem in girl scouting.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoCompare: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_examiner/2012/09/sex_selection_in_babies_through_pgd_americans_are_paying_to_have_daughters_rather_than_sons_.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_exa... > Many fertility doctors say that girls are the goal for 80 percent of gender selection patients. A study published in 2009 by the online journal Reproductive Biomedicine Online found Caucasian-Americans preferentially select females through PGD 70 percent of the time. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/14/well/family/the-fear-of-having-a-son.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/14/well/family/the-fear-of-h... > a 2010 study [] discovered, among other things, that adoptive American parents preferred girls to boys by nearly a third. [] Adoptive parents are even willing to pay an average of $16,000 more in finalization costs for a girl than a boy.
- antisthenes 9y agoI wasn't aware of these, frankly, very disturbing trends in American society. Thanks for bringing them to my attention.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoThis is one of those times where I'm going to ask about the downvotes.
- zakoud 9y agoYou got my upvote. Boys are treated so differently within their own family, daughters given more love, attention and protection than boys. And then you just have to look at the few lines in the article to know how far this problem goes: "but what's happened is, particularly in schools where most of the teachers are women, there's been a general girlification of elementary school, where any kind of disruptive behavior is sinful"
- telesilla 9y agoLet's just stick to the facts related to the argument. The article was not about comparing girls to boys except a small side-note about diagnosis ratios and the increasing expectation that children sit quietly at school. Your comment is a non-sequitur about boys being undesirable, which is not relevant to this particular discussion.
- dang 9y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7484204 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7484204
- ggg9990 9y agoGot hauled to the school psychologist in elementary school for calling my teacher an idiot. Was prescribed Ritalin. My parents told them absolutely not and I've had a great life without it. I'm sure there are some people who need these medications. But realize that the incentives of the system are to give you pills. It's not even as debauched as bribery or kickbacks -- it's simply that a person who studies psychoactive medications rather than parenting will, when asked to solve the problem of an unruly child, naturally come up with medications as the solution rather than alternative parenting.
- throwaway1748 9y agoWow, that's insane that a kid would ever be prescribed medication by a school doctor/nurse. That seems like a doctor's visit a parent should book & not just be informed afterwards that thier child was prescribed a dangerous stimulant like Ritalin.
- ggg9990 9y agoI think a doctor did come in but on school grounds. And there was a meeting with my parents where they told him to fuck himself. This was also 30 years ago
- peterwwillis 9y agoThis is not just about ADD/ADHD medication, or about "boyhood". This is about the unnecessary prescribing of psychoactive drugs with powerful side-effects to people who cannot consent. I am yet another person who, around 7, was prescribed strong stimulants. Yes, it turned me into a robot, and yes, I did better in school. For a while. Until finally I grew so bored of pointless academic striving that I completely gave up doing any school work. At the same time, I discovered the computer. When I first told my mother "I don't want to live anymore", she asked me, "Good lord, why would you want to kill yourself?!" We had just recently moved back to the states, to a place I didn't know or like, to a school I didn't like. My parents fought, partly over us. My brother despised me. Due to my medicated existence, I had no real emotional connection to anything. At fourteen, I didn't see much value in life. "I don't want to die," I said, "I just don't really want to keep on living. There's no meaning to life. It's just pain." Soon there was the anti-depressants, and when those didn't work, the anti-psychotics, and more stimulants. Sometimes I couldn't sleep for weeks. Sometimes I couldn't stay awake for months. I needed blood tests to make sure my kidneys weren't failing on new medications. I was kicked out of schools, and was unable to complete any work. The only thing I noticed about this time was the kids at public schools were somewhat nicer, and the work was somewhat harder. I remember reading Ray Bradbury's short story collection and thinking, wow, maybe there is something to life. Dropping out of high school and not attending college, I was pretty fortunate to have found a medium for my attention that was both intellectually and fiscally rewarding. I doubt the rest of the kids who endure chemical tinkering at the hands of unscrupulous "doctors" are as fortunate as I to make a good living after a normal mental/emotional childhood is taken away from them.
- forgotmypw 9y agoI had trouble in high school. I fell behind because I did not have glasses, and I didn't find the material motivating enough, and because things were kind of tumultuous at home, and so on. By the time my dad caught on, I was 3 months behind in Physics. So he sat me down after work, and we went through the material together. It took less than a week for me to catch up. It makes me wonder what a kid could accomplish with a little bit of individual attention. I am not the dumbest person in the world, but I am also far from the smartest. Compared to the rest of the class, I was probably about average.
- briatx 9y ago> It makes me wonder what a kid could accomplish with a little bit of individual attention. I thought the same thing as I read through these comments. Perhaps the attention deficit is not that of the child, but that of the parents/teachers.
- spodek 9y agoThe comments here don't seem to capture the importance of the "Boy" part. Imagine we were mostly drugging girls. The headlines and reactions would be greater. The story recalls how when Michelle Obama publicized #BringBackOurGirls, laudably promoting saving many innocent girls from kidnapping and worse, Boko Haram had been burning alive and hacking to death many innocent boys for years to little western outcry. We keep changing our culture from the world our emotional systems evolved to handle. Then we declare groups sick who can't handle the change, which happen to be boys mostly, and drug them. When we create problems for girls, we ask "what have we done?", recognize we're hurting them, and try to change the culture we created stop hurting them. We may take time, but we don't want to hurt them. When we create problems for boys, we say "we'll fix you," as if they were broken. If boys' behavior was adapted to a different world than sitting in rows for most of the day, why don't we change the culture we created to stop hurting them?
- moosekaka 9y agoWhy dont American mothers love their sons more? or at least the same as their daughters? (emphasis mothers because in America they have overwhelming influence on the childs upbringing). Heck, Howard Glasser himself shows that giving a boy more love is a viable method to manage a boys hyperactivity. I wonder how much a coincidence that the last three presidencies(first family) before Trump had no sons, only daughters and whether this influenced subtly our perception and bias towards daughters over sons.
- watwut 9y agoAll men killed by drones count as combatants.
- soundwave106 9y agoThe question I would have here is, what has changed in the last century or so that would make it that way? Regarding sitting in rows for most of the day, school methodologies I don't think have noticeably changed; at least, from what I see, it doesn't seem like a school in 1950 would be that much different than a school today. From my perspective, the root of this is more yet another case of medicine being over-sold well beyond their intended purpose. In this case, energetic boys are the ones that get caught in the cross fire. But this seems overall like a systemic problem of current medicine, well beyond ADHD medicine... ranging from the over-prescription of antibiotics, to the roots of the opioid addiction crisis. Our medical system just plain and simple seems to dish out too many pills, even when the chances of help is marginal. I'm guessing (to be fair) that many times this is due to patient demand, I just wish doctors would sometimes push back sometimes. People are looking for easy solutions to life's problems, and don't necessarily realize the whole picture that comes from medication (side effects and whatnot). Your child is energetic and a handle sometimes, right? That's often normal. You don't need to necessarily give your child powerful stimulants, what is essentially commercialized speed, to "cure" this, unless you are really sure of the diagnosis, in my opinion.
- bmj 9y agoIf you find this article interesting or compelling, please check out Boys Adrift[0]. You may not necessarily agree with all of Sax's conclusions, but if you have boys of your own, it should be required reading. [0] http://www.boysadrift.com/ http://www.boysadrift.com/
- freekh 9y agoI've always wondered if it is related to discipline not bring enforced as harshly. I'm NOT saying it was good to do that, just wondering if that is a cause...
- goldenkey 9y agoIts a mixture of slow/stupid kids (low IQ) and rebellious, impulsive kids. Personality and performance undesirables. Back in the older days, there were more manual labor and mechanized jobs that anyone could learn to do if they just followed instructions. These days, every parent wants their kid to goto an ivy league, and get a "smart job." So they put their kids on performance enhancing drugs. Stimulants like amphetamines alter the brains reward system - dopaminergic synapses. So the asshole kid becomes a little bit nicer because the potential energy to do harder and undesirable tasks is now decreased both mentally and physically. Thresholds changed. Speed of mental quickness and physical dexterity also improved..so the slow kid is now near average level intelligence because he is overclocked on stimulants. Better hope the parents give their kids a good liquid cooling system and feed them more, need a bigger PSU when your system is clocked so hot.
- Pulcinella 9y agoMuch of Glasser’s emotional problems seemed to be because he was abused as a child rather than because he has ADHD. Praising children for proper behavior instead of just punishing bad behavior is good and what schools are moving towards (search for PBIS) but it’s not the same as teaching coping skills to people with reduced executive functioning. Having ADHD isn’t the same as having emotional troubles to work through.
- ohf 9y agoI think this is a product the space we raise children in. Kids spend hours casually absorbed in phones, tablets, and consoles (basically the heroin of screen-based entertainment), and then we sit them in a room for eight hours. So they get restless. And we drug them. What's the right thing to do here? The only defense I have against "girls have tech, too; why aren't they on speed" is that boys spend more time on screens, which is just a casual hypothesis.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoWhat struck me about the article was the throwaway line: listened to your brief and vague report that he seemed to have trouble sitting still in kindergarten, Where I live, where my three boys went to kindergarten (barnehage her in Norway), pre-school is all about physical activity and socialisation. It's not like school, there are no lessons to sit still for; instead there are things to do, painting, cooking, laying tables, climbing frames, mud to be crawled in and puddles to splash. The children are of course expected to not be disruptive and the staff will work with the children to ensure that they behave well. The end result seems to be, on the whole, self-confident, well behaved children who can be taken anywhere with little or no risk that they will be disruptive. As far as I know the kinds of diagnoses that seem common in the US are rare here.
- EamonnMR 9y agoWhen we're giving something to one in fourteen people, it seems crazy that the healthcare system should be wasting money determining who should and who should not be allowed to have these drugs.