2 ms·
microwave/RF engineer here: I have seen speculation from people with 25+ years experience in my field that what was being experienced was not acoustic at all, b
by walrus01 9y ago
microwave/RF engineer here: I have seen speculation from people with 25+ years experience in my field that what was being experienced was not acoustic at all, but was some sort of SIGINT apparatus gone wrong, or millimeter wave at very high power and focused. Very curious what the results would have been if the US had carried a 4 to 120 GHz capable portable spectrum analyzer and set of horn antennas in a diplomatic bag to the locations where this was experienced, and done thorough scans of various power levels/frequencies in the millimeter wave frequencies.
quick edit: the weird part here is that DoS (department of state) has an entire division of people who specialize in TSCM (technical surveillance countermeasures). I would be surprised if most embassies did not have RF detection apparatus capable of up to the high millimeter wave frequencies on hand. These things are pretty pricey, $20,000 or so for a full setup, but compared to the anti-bugging budget of the DoS as a whole it's a tiny drop in the bucket.
- _greim_ 9y agoNot an expert at all, just curious; could this kind of radiation have caused the high-pitched sounds, or perception of sounds, as purely a side effect?
- walrus01 9y agonot the RF itself, no, but the effect of high powered millimeter-waves focused at a person's head could very possible have that effect on a neurological basis. It's not the sort of thing that has ever been voluntarily tested on humans (for obvious reasons), and if tested on animals, animals can't tell you if they're observing auditory hallucinations... Though the science behind avoiding high RF exposure is known and observed (ex: tower climbers don't want to hang around on the front side of a large sector antenna with high EIRP in the 2.5 GHz band). Would have to ask a MD that specializes in the brain.
- achileas 9y agoMight have better luck with a PhD neuroscientist, but my guess (as a lowly MS) would be that it's something we can't really experiment with because of ethical issues, as you mentioned. While I studied the auditory system in grad school, I wasn't until today aware of effects of RF on hearing, but there does seem to be an effect at fairly high exposures: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microwave_auditory_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microwave_auditory_effect
- walrus01 9y agoprobably the closest we could get to studying it would be to emplace a lot of instrumentation inside of a cadaver brain and focus the same power/frequency of microwave at it. kind of a messy process since to duplicate real world conditions you'd need to have the brain inside a skull...
- achileas 9y agoAnother issue is that you wouldn't have any sort of active responses that may induce or attenuate any effects of the radiation. An example from the auditory world is that for much of the history of auditory system research, it was thought that the cochlea was a passive system (with a little more nuance, the idea of an active cochlear mechanism was theorized but not confirmed). But that was because the technological limitations of the time only allowed experiments on dead cochleas (primarily by von Bekesy) - once otoacoustic emissions were first recorded (70s or early 80s) we finally had verification of the cochlear amplifier. More, if interested: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cochlear_amplifier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cochlear_amplifier