6 ms·
All of these are extremely important! Two life skills: * If you are without a doubt, you are wrong If you can't fathom the other side and where they're coming
by exabrial 9y ago
All of these are extremely important! Two life skills:
* If you are without a doubt, you are wrong
If you can't fathom the other side and where they're coming from, you, are in fact, biased beyond listening to facts, and are likely wrong.
* Words matter
As my grandma said, "If you don't have anything nice to say don't say anything at all."
- ars 9y ago> If you can't fathom the other side and where they're coming from, you, are in fact, biased beyond listening to facts, and are likely wrong. This one especially applies to politics. If you are one of those looking for "sanity", or "common sense", and can't imagine how the other side can possibly hold some position, then this applies to you.
- Karunamon 9y agoI’m not sure that’s accurate. People hold all manner of irrational political beliefs and there is value in recognizing that irrationality.
- tensor_rank_0 9y agoit's a lot easier to dismiss political ideas that you don't like by labeling them "irrational" than it is to open your mind to the reasons why a person might rationally disagree with you.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoYes, but there is also the real possibility that your beliefs are irrational as well. Everyone thinks they're right, and everyone has a train of thought that has led to that belief.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoA key test for rationality is prediction. If you believe that banning sex education in schools will decrease teen pregnancy, and it turns out that teen pregnancy rates actually increase when teens aren't educated, then your belief about sex education isn't rational. Many - possibly most - public policy decisions are open to this kind of testing. The fact that formal testing rarely happens, and that it's consistently ignored even when it does, suggests that politics itself is inherently pre-rational. Arguably it's then irrational to expect it to be rational - but that's a deeper problem that doesn't just apply to politics.
- zaarn 9y agoA rational thought may not be a predictive thought. Before people knew the earth was a globe, it was entirely rational to think everything that goes up goes down again. And for all testing you can do, ie, throwing an apple up, it'll come down again. It is entirely rational to conclude from the available evidence that everything falls down when thrown. But recently we've discovered that things you throw up hard enough may not fall down at all. Thusly, the rational thought was still rational but wrong. Predictability is important when you want to evaluate scientific models (ie, assume earth is flat, assume earth is round, assume earth is a mostly round potato all have different predictive quality, though the first ones are easier and sometimes sufficient)
- macintux 9y agoThere's almost always a reason for those "irrational" beliefs. I, like many, was appalled to hear the statistics on the number of people who believe news they didn't agree with was "fake news" regardless of its accuracy. Then I heard a counter-argument: in short they're applying the rubric "fake news" to biased news, which is a whole 'nother discussion I'd rather not dive into here. I don't think there are all that many truly irrational beliefs out there, political or otherwise. The world is a massively complex place, and I can't really blame people for letting con men tell them otherwise. (Ok, who am I kidding: yes I can blame them, but it does no good to assume everyone who disagrees with me is stupid or a victim.)
- zaphar 9y agoDo you know the reasons for their beliefs? Can you articulate them? If not then you are conflating your own beliefs with the standard for rationality. You will also be really ineffective at convincing them they are wrong. Not because they aren't smart enough but because you are unable to communicate effectively to them.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoWhat makes you think people understand the reasons for their own beliefs? How do you know the reasons they give you when asked are the correct ones? Why do you believe that challenging those statements respectfully will change their minds? The actual requirement for persuasion is a believable narrative with a bit of moral weight, and a random selection of standard persuasive tricks that politicians and lawyers have been deploying with outrageous success for millennia. Generally, being objectively correct is one of the least effective ways to change anyone's mind. You might have some hope in a scientific setting. But in popular debate, facts and rationality are almost completely powerless.
- zaphar 9y agoI don't know that challenging them respectfully will change their minds. After all what if they are right? I do know that not challenging them respectfully is unlikely to persuade anyone least of all yourself.
- jpeloquin 9y agoAnd irrationality is an intrinsic aspect of politics, not a problem to be solved. When two or more people agree on a desired end, rationality is relevant—rationality serves as a tool to find the most efficient way to meet the mutually desired end. But when people want mutually exclusive outcomes, application of reason can never satisfy both. In the absence of willingness to compromise their struggle must be founded upon emotional appeal, tribal identity, and power.
- creep 9y agoI agree. The best assumption that we can have about another human being is that they are rational. Most people are rational. Most people have reasons for their actions. Even addicts, even child molesters, even feminists. The point is to understand their reasons. If you disagree, that doesn't mean the other side is irrational. They could be wrong but they still have reasons. From that place of understanding, you can not only find empathy, but structure arguments in a way that is constructive based on that empathy and understanding.
- rdiddly 9y agoI think the sad fact of politics is that demonizing and misunderstanding the other side is quite deliberate and purposeful, and getting at the truth is the least important of concerns.
- mikeash 9y agoIt really depends on the topic, and there are times where trying to find sense in the other side’s position is the road to madness. If you’re debating the optimal sales tax rate, yes, being unable to comprehend the other side means you’re doing it wrong. If the topic is, say, wiping out people of a particular religion, not so much.
- zaarn 9y ago>wiping out people of a particular religion, not so much. As a nihilist I would disagree. The kind of people that want to do that have a much different set of morality and ethics. There is no objective moral framework that you can base claims for or against wiping out a particular religion. You can however use your own, personal, subjective moral framework and most people will probably have something vaguely compatible to it and agree with you that wiping out religions and it's people is bad.
- ouid 9y agohow strongly do you believe that first principle?
- marcoperaza 9y agoTo be truly without doubt is to not believe that any new information could possibly change your mind.
- mitchty 9y agoMy viewpoint on number one is simple: I'm always wrong Easier to move forward with that default assumption and try to prove I'm not as wrong as I thought and that "right" is the wrong attitude to hold.
- Retra 9y agoGenerally, every model is wrong about something. That the core difference between models and the things we model. Every description is an approximation of some sort. However, some things are tautological. Some things may be necessary in reality, even if they are not in any model. (I wake up each morning because I have no alternative, not because it is the 'right thing to do'.) Some things are very safe to assume because our human cultural context or our biological environment is stable over multiple generations of activity. And some things are true simply because assuming otherwise contradicts the assumptions needed for language to work effectively. And sometimes we do prove things, even if we lack any meaningful ability to prove what we'd like to the degree that we'd like. The point is, we're not always wrong in a linguistic sense. Any time you have a statement that is perfectly symmetrical and valid in every context, you do not have language which can be used to make decisions. It's only meaningful to be wrong if there are things you can be right about.
- ninkendo 9y agoHow do you improve your knowledge if every path forward is still wrong? (In ML terms, how do you apply gradient descent if every path forward is up?)
- 9y ago
- cryptoz 9y agoI am without a doubt that white nationalists and Nazis are wrong. Am I supposed to question myself here? Supposed to assume I'm wrong? Your line of thinking is very dangerous and not safe, it enables very bad people by making good people assume they are terrible people themselves.
- creep 9y ago> White nationalists are wrong White nationalists present some interesting problems, problems that are real and valid. Their lens is wrong (this problem exists, therefore I will interpret the problem in a way that I am superior and others are inferior). Your doubt should come from that understanding.
- HeyWolfey 9y agoOnly you can stop the very dangerous people! Consider the fact that you are a byproduct of the endless programming and propaganda behind the War on Terror. If you have no doubts on that subject, YOU are wrong.
- ninkendo 9y agoSo, I'm endlessly programmed, therefore nazis are good? You can critique the way we acquire information and use that to cast doubt on conclusions. But you definitely can not use those criticisms to add validity to any conclusions either. So I don't see how this world view does anybody any good. At some point, you see nazis, you say "those are bad", and you just know you're right about it. In that sense, morals are a true compass when faced with endless doubt that can creep in if you want to be maximally scientific about things.
- psyc 9y ago"Life is complicated and nobody wants to believe it. I suppose you might call it the infantilism of society. There is deep infantilism in the culture, in terms of the way they think, they can’t bear complexity. That you have to think, that there are gradations, nobody wants that. They want to be told, or they want to say: ‘This is good, this is bad’. Anything that in any way undermines that is not to be borne." - Stephen Fry No pressing need to point out the obvious criticisms. Fry was already roundly criticized up and down for saying it. But it has become my favorite quote about the way people talk about ideologies.
- appleshore 9y agoI disagree with the first statement. To me, it invokes concepts of relativism. Certainty in actions, when well prepared, has a magical and transformative effect on things. I am willing to entertain thought experiments about how I can be wrong but I know I am not about certain ideas and philosophies.
- dghf 9y ago> I know I am not about certain ideas and philosophies Can you give some examples?
- tensor_rank_0 9y agoI'm not the person you asked, but... any philosophy/belief system that is descriptive (as opposed to prescriptive/normative) will be _apodictically_certain_ to the extent that it is free from internal contradictions. in simple cases we can examine the ideas and be very confident that there are no internal contradictions. for example: given "A implies B" and "A" then we can conclude "B". essentially any time you formalize definitions to the point that a statement of equivalence becomes obvious as a tautology, then you have an idea you can be certain about.
- dghf 9y agoI have a layman's and not very well informed knowledge of philosophy, so at the risk of being savagely and justifiably owned: even in the example you give, doesn't one have to make the assumption that one's rules of reasoning are sound? I don't consider it as a serious proposition, but isn't there at least in principle the possibility that one is deluded, and that modus ponens is not universally valid, for reasons one is not capable of grasping?
- tensor_rank_0 9y agoI'm also an autodidact and my understanding is that radically agnostic epistemology (such as you suggest) is not very useful. the idea of a delusion presupposes that one could have a correct understanding of reality, at least in theory. the most basic assertion we can make about reality is identity, that is, a thing is itself. the purpose of a logical syllogism is to reduce an apparently complicated chain of identities to a tautology. [0] rejection of the principle of identity leaves one at the point where no further intersubjective dialogue is meaningful. which is why Avicenna said that anyone who denies the identity should be beaten until he acknowledges that "to be beaten" is not the same as "to not be beaten" and he should be burned until he acknowledges that "being burned" is not the same as "not being burned." [1] I'm very interested in any corrections, comments, or other replies. I'm also aware that there are other approaches to logic besides the aristotelian approach I have tried to convey above. an example of a non-aristotelian attempt at communicating would be e-prime [2]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syllogism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syllogism [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_noncontradiction#Avicenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_noncontradiction#Avicen... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Prime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Prime