4 ms·
> the Overton Window has shifted so far right that "left wing" in the mainstream now means "center" As a conservative, I'd claim the window has shifted in the
by mistermann 9y ago
> the Overton Window has shifted so far right that "left wing" in the mainstream now means "center"
As a conservative, I'd claim the window has shifted in the other direction, at least in some respects.
Are you able to give any examples that you see as evidence of a broad shift to the right?
- HillaryBriss 9y agomaybe i'm misperceiving this, but it seems that the left's criticism of US military action has diminished or been muted. in the 60's people on the left literally criticized US soldiers as they returned to the US from Vietnam. (the phrase "baby killers" comes to mind). you don't hear that sort of thing today. criticizing US soldiers is just not done. even Barbara Boxer touted her work with the "Wounded Warriors" project. Al Franken went on USO tours. it's just not ok to criticize US soldiers. on the contrary, we thank them for their service and try not to call into question what happened "over there." furthermore, when GW Bush argued for an invasion of Iraq in 2003, an awful lot of Democratic politicians got on board and voted to authorize it. i think they were afraid not to authorize it. later, drone attacks carried out by the Obama administration were more or less accepted too.
- musage 9y agoYeah, the remaining ideological battles seem to be mostly about how to frame and rationalize mass murder, and what distractions to bicker about. > in the 60's people on the left literally criticized US soldiers as they returned to the US from Vietnam Considering the draft, that seems more like beating on scape goats though. And if you read something like "Manufacturing Consent", at least in the major media, "left" or "right", the acceptable spectrum of opinion ranged (and ranges) from "let's kill gooks" to "maybe some regrettable mistakes were made in this fundamentally noble undertaking".
- spamizbad 9y agoIt might make sense to separate key social issue from the rest. The way the media frames matters of divorce, race, LGBTQ and gender have all moved leftward to varying degrees. But on issues like labor and capital the media definitely moved rightward. On foreign policy, the press definitely seems to favor conflict escalation over diplomacy, which can be viewed as a leftward or rightward bias depending on the situation. So today, the "center" in media is the socially-permissive, global intervention, capitalist perspective.
- mistermann 9y agoThis sounds pretty accurate to me, thanks.
- leetcrew 9y ago> As a conservative, I'd claim the window has shifted in the other direction i'd argue you're both right and the window has widened in both directions.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI'd go further. On many topics, the Overton Window shattered. Let me start with the idea of a "personal Overton Window". It's the positions that an individual thinks are within the realm of reasonable discourse. Then society's Overton Window is composed of a bunch of individual ones. So, 40 or 50 years ago, it was clear to about 95% of people that gays could not marry. Those 95% gave society a clear Overton Window on the topic. But today, maybe 30% of people still have gay marriage outside their personal Overton Window. Maybe 40% not only have gay marriage in their personal Overton Window, but it is outside their personal Overton Window to not be totally accepting of gay marriage. This means that 70% of the population excludes at least 30% of the population from their personal Overton Window. As a result, no societal Overton Window is possible - we're just left with a bunch of conflicting personal ones.
- mistermann 9y agoAn even better explanation, by far.