3 ms·
I was surprised the study was from MIT as there were pretty serious flaws. The bigger question is how it passed peer review when they ran the analysis and check
by prepend 9y ago
I was surprised the study was from MIT as there were pretty serious flaws. The bigger question is how it passed peer review when they ran the analysis and checked the methods.
The response from the lead author was pretty reasonable and I will camp on his response. I was expecting something defensive rather than “yeah, maybe, let me double check my work.”
- JorgeGT 9y agoThe answer is that it has not passed any peer review, it is a "working paper" only available to "associates" of MIT-CEEPR: http://ceepr.mit.edu/publications/working-papers/681 http://ceepr.mit.edu/publications/working-papers/681 If you read the back-cover of any of these CEEPR working papers, it includes a disclaimer stating that they have not passed any peer review: CEEPR releases Working Papers written by researchers from MIT and other academic institutions in order to enable timely consideration and reaction to energy and environmental policy research, but does not conduct a selection process or peer review prior to posting