5 ms·
I too work in German automotive software and I do think their point that German industry may not cope with the coming challenges is valid. From my point of vie
by weinzierl 9y ago
I too work in German automotive software and I do think their point that German industry may not cope with the coming challenges is valid.
From my point of view a big problem is that most decisions are still made by people with mechanical or electrical engineering backgrounds.
The whole culture values the German engineer a lot, the computer scientist or programmer not so much. I deliberately wrote computer scientist and programmer, because these are not even considered proper engineers here, even if the term software engineer is gaining popularity.
I suspect the situation is different for the big suppliers like Bosch, Conti and ZF. I think almost all of the ECU know-how (hardware and software) is in these companies whereas the car companies tend their - soon to be mostly useless - ICE know-how like the holy grail. If the suppliers make the right decisions now, they could be the big war profiteers.
BTW: ICE stands for internal combustion engine, for those just skimming the comments.
- kbwt 9y ago> computer scientist and programmer [...] are not even considered proper engineers here That is plain incorrect. Even though the exact details vary by state, pretty much anyone with a Bachelor's in Computer Science is an allowed to call themselves a proper "Ingenieur". See for example Ingenieurgesetz (IngG) of the Baden-Württemberg state: http://www.landesrecht-bw.de/jportal/portal/t/ox2/page/bsbawueprod.psml/action/portlets.jw.MainAction?p1=1&eventSubmit_doNavigate=searchInSubtreeTOC&showdoccase=1&doc.hl=0&doc.id=jlr-IngGBW2016pP1&doc.part=S&toc.poskey=#focuspoint http://www.landesrecht-bw.de/jportal/portal/t/ox2/page/bsbaw...
- weinzierl 9y agoI didn't claim that computer scientists are not allowed to call themselves engineers. I even said that the title software engineer is on the rise. What I said and what I stand by is that in my experience the typical German automotive middle manager still has the words Dipl.-Ing. on his degree certificate and looks down on anyone who hasn't, including computer scientists. And just to make clear where I am coming from, making all this claims: I do have a degree certificate with words Dipl.-Ing. on it and another one with the words Master and Informatics on it, so I know a bit of both worlds. When it comes to the IngG, even there it is not as clearly cut as it seems. The whole history of it is interesting but too involved for a short comment, so I will focus on the wording of the law: The law is very specific about the fact that it permits the title "Ingenieur" only to graduates of technical or natural scientific fields. Computer science, like mathematics, is considered a formal science which is neither technical nor a natural science.
- kbwt 9y ago> Master of Informatics Let me guess, your degree was actually in Computer Science and is "mistranslated" as Informatics by your University? Informatics degrees[1] actually exist in the US and are different from Computer Science degrees[2]. [1] https://ischool.uw.edu/programs/informatics https://ischool.uw.edu/programs/informatics [2] https://www.cs.washington.edu/academics/ugrad/courses/requirements https://www.cs.washington.edu/academics/ugrad/courses/requir...
- _0ffh 9y agoNah, it's probably just a "false friend" mistranslation (1): "Computer Science" translates as "Informatik" in German. So if you've got a German degree in "Informatik", it's what would be called "Computer Science" in anglophone countries. Ed. (1) by the poster
- kbwt 9y agoMy Informatik degree piece of paper has both German and English text, but the English says "Informatics" rather than "Computer Science".
- kbwt 9y ago> The law is very specific about the fact that it permits the title "Ingenieur" only to graduates of technical or natural scientific fields At least in the case of BW, Computer Science is clearly listed as one of the possible fields: "[...] wobei dieses Studium überwiegend von den Bereichen Mathematik, Informatik, Naturwissenschaften und Technik geprägt sein muss [...]"
- weinzierl 9y ago> "[...] wobei dieses Studium überwiegend von den Bereichen Mathematik, Informatik, Naturwissenschaften und Technik geprägt sein muss [...]" "dieses" refers to "Studium in einer technischen oder naturwissenschaftlichen Fachrichtung" which means only technical or natural scientific fields qualify. From my understanding Bioinformatics would qualify, because it could be considered a natural science and the learning content is dominated by topics from the natural sciences, computer science and technology. Pure computer science would not qualify because it is neither a natural science nor technical. It does not qualify because it doesn't satisfy the precondition to the sentence you quoted. I'm not a lawyer and this is just my reading of the law and I didn't find any court decisions or anything regarding this topic.
- Glawen 9y agoI worked for one of the supplier you mentionned. The SW really has a huge place in the company and enjoy a good recognition. It has its own method of development and is SW focused. The only drawback are the methodologies which are not agile and flexible, but on the other side this is due to recall costs being so prohibitively expensive if a million cars need to be reflashed due to a SW bug.
- weinzierl 9y agoI live in the opposite world. The importance of software isn't recognized enough but agile for almost everything is pressed very hard by upper management. A very strange version of agile, that is. One where the very first section of the agile process description elaborates how important processes are and how important it is that everyone "lives" them. Reading this made me smile, because first sentence of the original Agile Manifesto literally is "Individuals and interactions over processes and tools".
- lagadu 9y agoI can't speak for car software as our stuff is completely unrelated to cars, but I work at a company whose software BMW is a client of and we do a lot of customization for them. I can very confidently say that of our clients (most of which are banks and some of the largest pharmas in the world) BMW has the strictest software quality and testing requirements by a fairly wide margin. No idea how that reflects on software they develop internally or for their cars but to me they care a lot about the software they have.
- InternetOfStuff 9y ago> BMW has the strictest software quality and testing requirements by a fairly wide margin I find this worrying. Having worked on a variety of BMW projects over the years, I find their dedication to software quality... worthy of improvement.
- dpweb 9y agoSome countries will mandate electrics, but ICE engines will be the mainstream globally for the next 20 years and still common for at least a couple decades after that.