2 ms·
According to the linked faq, * They did not own all of the copyrights at the time the suit was filed. In fact, they may not own the rights now. * Internationa
by mcguire 9y ago
According to the linked faq,
* They did not own all of the copyrights at the time the suit was filed. In fact, they may not own the rights now.
* International treaties like the Berne Convention have means to resolve these disputes. The plaintiffs have ignored those and filed suit in their own, likely incorrect, jurisdiction.
* The suit, and the decision, does not ask for the texts in question be blocked in German jurisdiction. It calls for them to be taken down entirely, even though they are legal in the US.
- germanier 9y agoThe judgement clearly states that the books in question should be blocked from being accessed from Germany. The court is aware that such blocks can be circumvented but that's still fine. They never claimed jurisdiction over what happens to users outside of Germany and explicitly haven't ordered the site to take down those books completely.