3 ms·
70 years for copyright (no matter from what point) is a ridiculous length to begin with.
by shmerl 9y ago
70 years for copyright (no matter from what point) is a ridiculous length to begin with.
- Freak_NL 9y agoIt is even more painful when you realize that all of the 18 books mentioned were published in or before 1920. Most of these books are over a century old. I would expect that between the extremes of copyright abolishment and the current system of 'life + 70 years', most people would agree that some amount of protection is fair, but I seriously doubt that a majority feels that anything over 30 years since publication is necessary, much less considered fair. I wonder if that was ever researched in recent years. Not that it matters; global copyright laws are permantently frozen because amending them is a costly matter requiring global coordination, and there is little political will to tackle this (or even consider it a problem). Any attempt to lower the extend of copyright (in any jurisdiction) will be met by a wall of well-paid lawyers and lobbyists pay-rolled by all the major content owners.
- lucb1e 9y agoI think the lifetime of the author is not ridiculous: I made something, so I get to be the owner. That I live to be 100 years old and wrote it when I was 25 years old... I don't think that's completely unreasonable. I can also imagine that if Joe wrote something amazing, expects to feed his family with that for a few years, and dies in a car crash the next day, the poor wife or kids might enjoy some of the royalties for a few years (like 5-10 years). When written for a company, the span should be much shorter: like with patents, one can expect them to think of a new story after a while. So I agree that death+70 is ridiculous, but 70 by itself, so long as it's not past the author's death (unless s/he dies within 5-10 years after creating the work)... I think that's not completely crazy.