4 ms·
It's still used this way by contemporary philosophers, though oddly I've mostly seen it used in an adjectival form--"this argument is question-begging". It's g
by philwelch 16y ago
It's still used this way by contemporary philosophers, though oddly I've mostly seen it used in an adjectival form--"this argument is question-begging".
It's good practice in philosophy, because philosophers are trying to start from one (preferably obvious and uncontroversial) set of assumptions and derive their way to a (preferably astonishing and counterintuitive) conclusion. Starting from a cleverly worded re-statement of something your conclusion trivially follows from and ending up at your conclusion isn't very useful to philosophers.