5 ms·
> “We won’t formally discriminate against you” is a pretty watered definition of “equality.” Disagree. > It’s like saying everyone has an equal chance to win
by mpweiher 9y ago
> “We won’t formally discriminate against you” is a pretty watered definition of “equality.”
Disagree.
> It’s like saying everyone has an equal chance to win the race” because the rules allow anyone to win
That's pretty much the definition of equal chance.
> But there could still be rocks in one of the lanes and not in the others.
Could. Maybe. But, staying in the metaphor: it's both exceedingly rare for there to be rocks in one lane and not another, and exceedingly obvious if it is the case.
And nobody assumes that there are rocks because there are clear winners and losers in races. Everybody assumes that the person who won was fastest.
But for some bizarre reason in other fields, we not just assume that there being winners means there must be rocks, we absolutely insist that that is the only possible explanation and vilify people who say "well, maybe the person who won was fastest?"
- rayiner 9y ago> Could. Maybe. But, staying in the metaphor: it's both exceedingly rare for there to be rocks in one lane and not another, and exceedingly obvious if it is the case. It is obvious if you’re not willfully blind. How many women have to tell stories of, e.g., trying to make professional connections only to have a coworker make a sexual advance on them instead before you’ll believe that there’s rocks in their lane?
- mpweiher 9y agoWell yes, you are being willfully blind (a) Anecdotes != data (b) You cannot assume that a man in the same situation would have made a successful professional connection (c) In fact, the woman, if she isn't entirely daft, will have additional levers to pull (d) You might have noticed "staying in the metaphor"
- psyc 9y ago(a) Ah yes, the conversation-stopping killer of thousands upon thousands of Hacker News threads. Can I get a published study on whether this is a good cultural norm for a discussion forum?