4 ms·
The issues that concern me the most aren't ones arising from production scale. I think the project was just fundamentally flawed at the beginning because of th
by everyone 9y ago
The issues that concern me the most aren't ones arising from production scale.
I think the project was just fundamentally flawed at the beginning because of the choice to use cryengine, and they never corrected it. They doubled down and poured huge amounts of great work after bad. At the very inception of any software project you need a very small handful of experts to decide some fundamental things eg. What language / framework / engine to use. What platforms it will be on, what networking model it will use.
In the case of star citizen, Chris Roberts picked cryengine himself (probably just cus cryengine games tend to look nice), even though he hadn't produced a game in years. It did make sense for the demo-video. As I said, it worked, he got funded, but after getting funded he should have scrapped that visual demo and hired a few experts to draw up a plan for how to realise the actual game. I would have been looking to headhunt people who were architects for battlefield or planetside.
Instead it seems like CIG just started hiring everyone like crazy and dogpiling work ontop of the visual-demo.
It seems from their dev updates that the team is putting in a heroic effort trying to work through the issues, though it also looks like a perfect realization of the sunken cost fallacy.
- jdlshore 9y agoHere's what you've said about Star Citizen elsewhere in this thread: "An unmitigated clusterfuck." "A mess." "Crummy software." And now you're saying they chose the wrong engine? That's a Far Cry from being the Crysis you described, which makes it sound like choosing CryEngine makes a game Prey to any Monster Hunter Online. Sure, Crytek's in a State of Decay, but the CryEngine Kingdom's Come: Deliverance in the form of Amazon. The engine is still maintained, and still used for major games. Okay, I'm resorting to bad wordplay now. I guess that means I'm done. I'll let you have the last word.
- everyone 9y agoI wish I could give you points or karma or something for that excellent punmanship!