4 ms·
> PGLAF complied with the Court's order on February 28, 2018 by blocking all access to www.gutenberg.org and sub-pages to all of Germany. I can access www.gute
by weinzierl 9y ago
> PGLAF complied with the Court's order on February 28, 2018 by blocking all access to www.gutenberg.org and sub-pages to all of Germany.
I can access www.gutenberg.org and sub-pages just fine from Germany. So the block doesn't seem to be active at the moment.
> Q: Why didn't Project Gutenberg simply remove the items?
> A: The is no reason to remove them. The 18 eBooks are all in the public domain in the US, and have been for many years. Copyright status in another country is not relevant to the legitimate ability of Project Gutenberg -- or anyone/anything in the US -- to make any use of these books.
But why then even block access from Germany? If the stance is that "Copyright status in another country is not relevant to the legitimate ability of Project Gutenberg -- or anyone/anything in the US -- to make any use of these books.", what is the rationale for the blocking.
There is also the German Projekt Gutenberg (http://projekt.gutenberg.de/ http://projekt.gutenberg.de/) which is promoted by
Spiegel Online (one of the most widely read German-language news websites [1]) even under their own domain as http://gutenberg.spiegel.de/ http://gutenberg.spiegel.de/. I don't know what kind of relationship the German Projekt Gutenberg has with PGLAF. The German Projekt Gutenberg is accessible for me from Germany right now, but apparently has blocked the controversial books. For example the page that lists Heinrich Mann's works says about the book "Der Untertan": "Exists in Projekt Gutenberg-DE, but is blocked until 31.12.2020" {"Im Projekt Gutenberg-DE vorhanden (gesperrt bis 31.12.2020)"} [2].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiegel_Online https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiegel_Online
[2] http://projekt.gutenberg.de/autor/heinrich-mann-1637 http://projekt.gutenberg.de/autor/heinrich-mann-1637
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ballenf 9y agoThe link addresses just that: > The decision to acceed to the German Court's order to make items inaccessible from Germany is intended to be a temporary appeasement, while the appeal occurs - this is because the German appeal Court will likely look disfavorably on PGLAF if it shows contempt for the German Court.
- raverbashing 9y agoWell, no crap sherlock I don't see why Project Gutenberg thinks it isn't subject to German law. And yes, it sucks and it is against the spirit of the internet. But it's either them being sued or ISPs being ordered to block the website.
- freeflight 9y ago> But it's either them being sued or ISPs being ordered to block the website. Sued by whom? Afaik gutenberg.org is registered in California, no German jurisdiction, the cease&desist orders usually used to shut something like this down don't apply here. Same deal with ISPs: Afaik there's no legal framework to support anything like that, it's for exactly that reason why law firms like Waldorf and Frommer uses cease&desist letters to pretty much blackmail people into stopping the "distribution", it's all based on civil action.
- Xylakant 9y ago> Afaik there's no legal framework to support anything like that, You might be careful with that assertion. As recently as Feb. 1st 2018 (so a month ago), Vodafone was compelled to block access to kinox.to in a preliminary injunction (1). The EUGH decided in 2014 that blocking pages is at least an option (2). This is contradictory to the EU e-commerce regulations, so the legality is somewhat murky at the moment, but it’s not definitely off the table. (1) https://netzpolitik.org/2018/netzsperren-vodafone-muss-kinox-to-blockieren-und-kundendaten-speichern/ https://netzpolitik.org/2018/netzsperren-vodafone-muss-kinox... (2) Telekabel Wien vs. Constantin Film http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?text=&docid=149924&pageIndex=0&doclang=de&mode=req&dir=&occ=first&part=1&cid=515352 http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?text=&doc...
- freeflight 9y agoI missed that, somewhat recent, development thank you for pointing this out. Still, as you said, this is legally murky and I wouldn't be too surprised if this turns out to be overturned again by a higher court. Some German courts have a reputation for quickly and easily siding with copyright claimants, just to have it overturned later by a higher instance. It's still really shitty that stuff like this keeps on happening and even when these claims turn out to be straight up scams (like that whole Redtube mess [0]) it has barely any real consequences in terms of laws being changed. [0] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13600869.2015.1012777?src=recsys https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13600869.2015.1...
- ryanackley 9y agoHe explains this further down. To paraphrase, he doesn't want to endanger his appeal by flaunting the German court order