3 ms·
> Don't the studies show that, by and large, no it isn't? No, the studies are very clear. They were widely misreported. There are two things: how good the evi
by DanBC 9y ago
> Don't the studies show that, by and large, no it isn't?
No, the studies are very clear. They were widely misreported.
There are two things: how good the evidence is, and how strong the effect is.
The evidence that processed red meat causes cancer is now as strong as the evidence that smoking causes cancer. We know that both do cause cancer.
But processed red meat doesn't cause much cancer. Smoking causes a lot of cancer.
- taeric 9y agoI was explicitly attacking the strength of the effect. Poorly, I grant. That is, yes it increases the risk. It is such a weak source, though, that you are still better starting elsewhere, and are here unlikely to die from cancer if you eat these. Contrasted with smoking, where it is a strong influence.
- tptacek 9y agoWait, is it equally strong? We have lots of cohort studies. Do we have studies that show a mechanism of action? If one exists, do we know the circumstances in which it occurs? Are there particular formulations that are risky? Are there food handling or cooking factors we're not aware of? We know a great deal about the mechanisms of action by which smoke inhalation and tobacco in particular cause cancer. I don't think the distinction here is merely in strength of the effect.