3 ms·
My knee jerk to the headline, "because they are taught to." More than just them, we teach each other that there has to be a reason. Often that it has to be a
by taeric 9y ago
My knee jerk to the headline, "because they are taught to." More than just them, we teach each other that there has to be a reason. Often that it has to be a singular one.
It is tough, because headlines and short articles like this are easy to twist into misguided views. Too easy. And yet, I definitely want these fields researched. I can't imagine anyone doesn't want it. Having the patience to get real answers is not easy. :(
- coldtea 9y ago>My knee jerk to the headline, "because they are taught to." More than just them, we teach each other that there has to be a reason. More often than not, today, we teach each other that there can't possibly be a reason -- other than "taught to".
- taeric 9y agoDo we? I see more justifications on intrinsic differences than I see otherwise.
- coldtea 9y agoBack in the day or today? Because today you can even be fired for talking about intrinsic differences. Let's put it this way: such talk wont make you very popular in the mainstream media and progressive urban folks. At best you have a chance on FOX and in the Bible Belt.
- taeric 9y agoThe problem, I think, is that you are phrasing it such that the intrinsic differences are assumed. Could there be intrinsic differences? I don't know anything that precludes them. The evidence seems fairly strong otherwise, though. Lots of it. More, most of the people rhetorically asking about the differences, do so in a way that is clearly not in good faith. Now, I am a little worried about the damage for people looking in good faith. But, by and large, the evidence doesn't appear to support this actually being a problem. Most of the complaints about not being "very popular" with these sorts of views are fairly weak when put into perspective of actual persecution. Edit: Forgot to explicitly answer. I meant today. I have seen a lot of search for intrinsic differences. I'll try and pay more attention for a bit. I realize confirmation bias can easily paint what I see.
- coldtea 9y ago>The problem, I think, is that you are phrasing it such that the intrinsic differences are assumed. I happen to assume them, based on everything we know about biology and various species, and how human life on earth developed for several thousands of years. I also know that it's difficult to take any grants and have any sort of career outside of fringe right-wing sponsored institutions if your research is to chance upon any of such "intristic differences" today, so I take modern findings in soft-sciences on the matter with a grain of salt.
- taeric 9y agoAnd I assume they are grossly exaggerated, for much the same reason. :) That is, even assuming there are differences, I'd imagine they would be slight and barely noticeable except at the extremes. Think Olympic running. Obvious differences, but rather close. Especially when measured against what most people can do.
- throwaway1584 9y agoThis stems from the postmodernist idea that everything is a social construct, and that our biology does not influence our behavior at all. The interview of a postmodernist in [1] is the best tool I've seen for understanding how a postmodernists view the world and their rejection of obvious biological differences. It gets really interesting at 4m45 [2]. [1] https://youtu.be/tUs6_Kcfieg https://youtu.be/tUs6_Kcfieg [2] https://youtu.be/tUs6_Kcfieg?t=4m45s https://youtu.be/tUs6_Kcfieg?t=4m45s