3 ms·
Yep, "three-true-outcomes" (HR, strikeout, walk) players were seen as undervalued. Much of today's developments can be seen as flowing out of that re-evaluation
by majormajor 9y ago
Yep, "three-true-outcomes" (HR, strikeout, walk) players were seen as undervalued. Much of today's developments can be seen as flowing out of that re-evaluation of the "badness" of strikeouts.
OBP driven by consistent-but-weak contact was the sort of thing that sabermetrics types in 2008ish were shifting away from. Adam Dunn types (high OBP power hitter, low average) were seen as undervalued compared to Juan Pierre types (low power, higher average).
E.g. http://www.firejoemorgan.com/2008/03/this-column-is-eternal.html http://www.firejoemorgan.com/2008/03/this-column-is-eternal....
Fun thing about Pierre vs Dunn - Fangraphs has them practically tied in career WAR in the same number of seasons. But traditional evaluations praised the scrappy Pierre types a lot more than the strikeout-happy Dunn types.
- jghn 9y agoRight. What people always seem to forget about the analytics based approaches, particularly the "moneyball" concept is that the intent was to identify those undervalued players. If the current trend is to prefer players with attribute X, that means that they'll be more expensive than their relative worth, so identify attribute Y which is also important and you can pay them a lot less. People still refer to moneyball style approaches as if the exact metrics which were used in 2001 are the end all be all, but as soon as people caught on to OBP and such the real moneyballers were by definition off to something else.