3 ms·
Woooah. Huuge assumptions here. First of all, when we say that a classifier "misclassifies" an image, we have an agreed-upon definition of what that means: it
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
Woooah. Huuge assumptions here.
First of all, when we say that a classifier "misclassifies" an image, we have
an agreed-upon definition of what that means: it means we have an image, we
have a target label for it and the classifier assigns it a different label.
What exactly does it mean that a human misclassifies an image? More
specifically, when the article says that "humans think that they're looking at
something they aren't", what in the world does that mean? I mean, I have to
assume a confusion between "looking", and "seeing". I can't really believe the
article is saying that when I'm looking at the top right image I'm not
actually, you know looking at it; but instead ...looking outside the window?
Or what?
On the other hand- seeing? Really? Who knows what it is that anyone else is
seeing? Who knows what is there to see? Especially when it comes to an image
specifically manipulated to be confusing, as opposed to a real-world image?
What is the ground truth here, for the image on the top-right? Is it a cat,
just because Google reserachers say it's a cat and it's fooling my senses into
thinking it's a dog ish? Is it fooling my senses just because the Google
researchers say it is? Google researchers are the final arbiters of objective
visible reality, now?
To be more precise, who is to say that that image can just be a "cat" or a
"dog" and nothineg else? Because, you know, the first thing I thought when I
saw that image on the top right was "that looks like a jumbled mess made with
bits of an image of a cat and an image of a dog", or something along those
lines.
Of course, if you sit me in front of a computer with two buttons, one for
"dog" and one for "cat" like in the researchers' setup... well, then you can
force me to misclassify the image all you like. But what does that prove?
Besides the fact that if you force me to choose one of two things, without
knowing what you think is the "right" thing to choose, I'll choose the "wrong"
thing a lot of the time?