5 ms·
I'd hardly say that. "Forget me" can take a lot of design work (can introduce a ton of edge cases). "Export data" requires building an entire information proces
by crazygringo 9y ago
I'd hardly say that. "Forget me" can take a lot of design work (can introduce a ton of edge cases). "Export data" requires building an entire information processing pipeline.
Larger corporations have the resources to dedicate to this. But for a small startup deciding between spending 4 dev-months on "forget me" and "export data" versus on enabling the top 3 new primary use cases users are asking for, I understand how this could feel really difficult.
I really wonder if it wouldn't be better to make some of the requirements only for companies above a certain revenue threshold or the types of data collected. (E.g. export data is critical for health or finance-related sites, probably less so for a meme generator startup.)
- geocar 9y agoI would. I'm doing some GDPR consulting at the moment and most of my conversations are "I don't think it's as complicated as you do". Americans tend to read law very pathologically unless they are familiar with how European legislation works, and every programmer out there thinks they are an armchair lawyer since there are "obvious" skillset similarities between decoding software and decoding law. "Forget me" is very simple: If someone calls you up and asks you to stop using their data, you stop using it and remember that they've done this. You do not have to: - Destroy invoices - Delete web logs - Delete the record of them asking you to stop using their data - Reprocess all of your backups - Recall any reports you might have sent out Or anything else that is silly. But your salespeople aren't allowed to see that person's details in your CRM anymore. "Export data" is also very simple for most companies. If you have a CRM containing information about a person, then that person can ask for that information. > probably less so for a meme generator startup What possible "personal information" do you think a meme generator startup actually has to collect on individuals that aren't their customers? They should have a CRM containing companies who are purchasing advertising space on their meme generator startup, and perhaps leads that they have obtained through various incremental marketing sources. They probably do not have any personal information on their users, or if they do, their business will not be impacted by simply not collecting that personal information. But maybe I don't understand what a "meme generator startup" would do because I'm not in their target market.
- FooBarWidget 9y agoInteresting. Do you have a link to your consulting company? Do you have a blog on GDPR related topics?
- geocar 9y agoI don't operate a blog, and my primary function at my company is as an SME, so I mostly consult to our customer's in-house legal. That said, my contact details aren't difficult to discover, so by all means reach out if there's something specific you want to talk about that you don't want to share publicly.
- Silhouette 9y agoYou keep mentioning how you're consulting on this issue at the moment and claiming that those of us more cautious than you just don't understand how European law works. Would you mind sharing a little more to justify that authority -- what qualifications do you have that we don't, what sorts of business are you consulting with and how much is compliance (including your advice) costing them, and why is your interpretation of the GDPR reliable in cases where a literal reading either clearly contradicts you or contains significant ambiguity that you imply doesn't matter?
- geocar 9y agoHi Silhouette, I'm not claiming anyone more cautious than me doesn't understand how European law works. That's just silly. I also don't know what qualifications I have that you don't. What qualifications do you have? The sorts of business I am consulting to are sales and marketing agencies based in the US. As an SME I work with their in-house council to help them understand what the business is doing. I also help define process designed to make compliance obvious and transparent surrounding areas of my expertise. I have no idea how much compliance is costing them. I don't know if they look at it this way. Your last "question" consists of some more straw man and a little too much hand-waving: By all means, feel free to point to any contradiction with a specific recital and I can try to address it. If you have another source who claims to be an expert, I can also try to explain why I may have a different opinion than them.