3 ms·
I think the right to be forgotten is a serious flaw in what otherwise is a major step forward in Data handling law. Data today has been compared by Schneier to
by lifeisstillgood 9y ago
I think the right to be forgotten is a serious flaw in what otherwise is a major step forward in Data handling law.
Data today has been compared by Schneier to pollution in the industrial revolution. The GDPR is probably the first anti-pollution law with real bite and with a real grasp of just how far this all goes (the extra-territoriality etc)
This does not make this perfect solution. I honestly don't think that "being forgotten" actually makes sense as a right - it seems to have sprung from some unusual
case law in ECJ and could much more easily be dealt with by a "do not further process".
But we genuinely can always find ways to
implement new laws - the most obvious is to encrypt user data, and then lose the key, but beyond that i think the best outcome of all
this is to stop moving data around so much. moving data from
system to system is a smell in my view - and one that a eu law is going to help
architects the world over realise they are doing wrong
- deltron3030 9y agoLike pollution laws, it's nonsense if not enforced worldwide. The web can't be contained to a specific locality anymore, it's against the core idea of the technology. The people in the EU who are responsible for this have no clue about the technology.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoThe GDPR specifically states that any processing of EU citizens personal / private data essentially two huge things come out of GDPR - personal data about a EU citizen belongs to that citizen, and if you process data about an EU citizen even if you are out of the EU, you are covered by this law (extra-territoriality) These are huge forward thinking political steps. they do get this stuff. I just think the deletion part is a mis-step
- deltron3030 9y agoIt just sounds good, but in a more or less open world, small businesses selling digital products will just block EU access, even if they're physically located in the EU. Opening a company in the US is easy.