4 ms·
They develop a laser to do job that relatively small caliber autocannon can do.
by nabla9 9y ago
They develop a laser to do job that relatively small caliber autocannon can do.
- gandhium 9y agoI don't think autocannon can be efficient against drones. You need to hit a small and fast-moving target - that's a job either for AA gun (which will need to spend a lot of ammo saturating the area around drone) or for high-powered precision laser.
- stevenwoo 9y agoLaser does have a slight advantage, it's more immediately obvious where misses are going to go, less likely to miss, which might be easier to avoid civilian bystanders closer to land/port where a drone would be more likely.
- jforman 9y agoLockheed makes those, too. Lasers have unmatched range and speed and would be very useful in some situations.
- jjoonathan 9y agoIn the long term I'd expect lasers to outperform bullets at intercept tasks. They certainly travel faster and have the potential to aim faster and carry a deeper reserve of ammunition. Even if this system is only an incremental step towards that goal I think it makes sense.
- nabla9 9y agoThey are impacted by weather - dust, humidity, rain and clouds. If there is dust or smoke in the air that touches the optics they easily melt into the glass and start fast degradation process. The HEL demonstration with 15 kilowatts laser took forever to ignite small fire in a target boat (directed at a single point in the outboard motor). 150-kilowatt laser is ten times faster but simple water pump in the front of approaching boat is effective countermeasure. DARPA has had low power laser demonstrators for 20 years. They are cheaper now but developing yet another is not going to produce more improvement in the power scaling of lasers. High power lasers are hard for optics and all other parts.
- John_KZ 9y agoI think they mainly do it for cheaper-per-shot defence against badly equipped armies. Which means they don't like spending a lot of bullets on the phalanx system to counter enemy artilety in middle east, and it doesn't rain much in the desert anyway, so they're good to go. They can also have applications in high-altitudes and in space. Maybe to take down MRVs? That makes a lot more sense actually.
- nabla9 9y ago>Maybe to take down MRVs? You need very high power lasers for that. These are the hopes DARPA has for lasers but they don't seem to materialize.
- riku_iki 9y agoI see main application as air defense against UAV and missiles, not boats.. Hellfires and javelins will probably be more effective against boats..
- DamnYuppie 9y agoLasers have vastly different external ballistics, meaning they are not impacted by wind, density altitude, and gravity as much as a bullet would be. This means they would have a greater range and accuracy. Benefit of this, to a solider, is there is no difference in elevation between engaging a target at 20 meters out to say 700 meters. This will enable them to be far more effective in urban battle fields as they can engage targets far more quickly and effectively.
- lighthazard 9y agoThey need line of sight here, don't they? Or are they going to bounce weaponized lasers off mirrors in space?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DamnYuppie 9y agoSo from my understanding of urban warfare you would have direct line of sight of the target, and that distance can vary from very close to over a 1000 meters. It may sound like a long way, but in the grand scheme of things this is like looking down a few blocks, if you are on just the 2nd-4th floor of a building you will realize how far you can actually see.
- riku_iki 9y agoLasers in questions are for navy air defense, they will have line of sight.
- greedo 9y agoI know it's not fashionable to RTFA, but these aren't really intended for air defense, nor limited to air targets. They won't be much use against high speed aircraft... "HELIOS...is designed to track and destroy small, unmanned aerial vehicles or boats that approach a ship."
- 9y ago
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y agoThe three main advantages are: 1. can create effect on target independent of evasive manuvering 2. effectively infinite magazine 3. near infinite cost of exchange ratio. All of these make lasers very compelling for defensive CIWS. The fundamental problem the Navy is terrified about is huge barrages of high speed, high maneuverability, anti-ship missiles. Existing systems are very limited in stopping such an attack if large enough.