3 ms·
> The cost of hiring this employee goes way up. The cost of hiring an employee would be offset from the employee to the prospective employer. By requiring a d
by thomastjeffery 9y ago
> The cost of hiring this employee goes way up.
The cost of hiring an employee would be offset from the employee to the prospective employer.
By requiring a degree as certification, the financial burden is put on the employee before they can accrue capital to pay for it. This leaves millions in serious debt before they can even start making money.
The notion that all qualified persons became qualified in the same manner ignores the rest of us who learned and gained experience with other methods. Those other methods are abundant, freely available, and comparable in quality and result to academia.
> The difference is that a student who is 100% dedicated to self learning could do it all on their own, which is a net win, but I suspect that for the majority, things would not change too much.
That is exactly the attitude that got us into this mess. The only reason "the majority" considers academia as an integral part of their career paths is that it is by virtue of employers using degrees as accreditation!
I disagree with your notion that accreditation would [d]evolve into academia. Academia demands much more of a student than accreditation: homework, time, structure, etc. It also demands a more strict learning path.
If a diverse group of people relied on a test for accreditation, the test would be better applied to that group's diverse learning paths.
- com2kid 9y ago> If a diverse group of people relied on a test for accreditation, the test would be better applied to that group's diverse learning paths. The obvious counter argument to that is the incredible mess that is testing for software engineering positions! We've yet to figure that out, and compared to many other fields we have relatively quantifiable requirements! Of course the real engineering disciplines are much more quantifiable, and they have industry wide certification and licensing programs.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoYes, it's a tough problem; but that does not make college degrees as certification any better. I think that if we, as a society, stop kidding ourselves with inadequate workarounds, we might be able to find a real solution.